Colorization of Movies

@Pocs39 (39)
August 5, 2012 1:45am CST
When film was first introduced to the viewing audience, there was no choice, it was simply black and white. Technology improved and the film makers now have their moving pictures viewed by the crowds in color. Today we have 2D, 3D and IMAX to captivate the viewers. With all the ways we see our favorite flicks, do we really need to have color added to the classic black and white film? Why does Hollywood feel the need to add a splash of color to a feature that was perfectly fine in black and white, is it for more emotion, more action or suspense? Color adds nothing to the original film just some green and red hues. It ruins the nostalgia, the era and the integrity. For instance the film It's A Wonderful Life, did color add anything to the scene, when Mary and George danced their way into the swimming pool under the gymnasium floor or the angels as stars blinking to communicate, no it added nothing, not even more charm. Or when George was running through the snow covered streets, the color actually took away the charm from that scene. Black and white films need to preserved and kept what they are, black and white films. They are a recorded history of Hollywood and it's film makers of that era, changing them changes history. Colorization isn't restoring, remastering or repairing the films, it's assault of a cherished time. Why fix something that isn't broken?
3 people like this
6 responses
@celticeagle (159451)
• Boise, Idaho
5 Aug 12
I so agree with you. I Think that the original film should be kept in its full glory. I am a ventige film buff. I think they should be left alone. Changing them does change history. So many remakes are made any way why would they have to ruin the original way a film was done when they can just do a remake?
@Pocs39 (39)
5 Aug 12
I agree totally except with the remakes, I have issues about that also, but that's another discussion. Can you image the Wizard of Oz without the black and white scenes.. Not the same movie
1 person likes this
@celticeagle (159451)
• Boise, Idaho
5 Aug 12
True. But I would rather see a remake made than the vintage film altered.
@burrito88 (2774)
• United States
5 Aug 12
Remakes are seldom as good as the originial.
@rafiholmes (2896)
• Malaysia
5 Aug 12
yeah..it just the way it is..improvisation of movie/film industries.. its all for the better.. and sound wise..its already movieng from 5.1 surround to more advance 7.1 surround that will blow ur mind and excite ur aural sensation.. :)
@thezone (9394)
• Ireland
5 Aug 12
Hey Raf. I dont mind the sound being updated at all
• Malaysia
5 Aug 12
yeah soundwise..nobody mind ..lol its all for the better.. ;)
• United States
6 Aug 12
I can't agree with you more. When t.v. channels played a beloved movie that was colorized I first wulfd just take the color out of mt t.v. Then I thought I just won't watch. And soon they stopped colorizing! then something happened! Modern films were filmed in black and white! Schindler's List got best picture. It was filmed in black and white! When all the suits wanted to colorize everything, Turner Classic Movies made a point to say they will Never colorize the classic films! The suits wanted to colorize the films because they thought they could get the kids and teens to watch the older films. But... it didn't work. All they did was upset us classic film fans and when they aired something colorized , No one watched. The kids were not into the films of yesteryear! And many of us refused to watch something that looked like a comic strip. Instead of making the films more interesting , they made them [/i] Look[i] silly!Thankfully I haven't seen a classic film being aired that was colorized. The suits are too busy making reality shows!
@thezone (9394)
• Ireland
5 Aug 12
Agreed there is no point. But then people these days wont watch anything if it is in black and white or has subs! I used to watch the snooker on the telly on a black and white telly at my granparents and I always had fun
@deazil (4723)
• United States
5 Aug 12
This has been a pet peeve of mine for a long time. I mostly only watch vintage movies - anything made before 1950. The b&w movies allowed for a lack of color by using shading or light to enhance the different moods of the movie. This is lost when it's been colorized. I don't watch them if they're in color. It just ruins it for me. I'm glad to find others who feel the same!
@deazil (4723)
• United States
5 Aug 12
That's funny, I used to like the silents, but not so much anymore. Too lazy to read I guess!
@Pocs39 (39)
5 Aug 12
It sends me over the edge. I really enjoy movies of all eras, except for the silent, I really never cared for those. You're right it ruins it! I have seen several with colorization, none of them any good. I'm also glad I'm not the only one also..we need to stop the maddness!
@nyssa102 (748)
• United States
6 Aug 12
Oh wow, film purists are certainly going to hate me here. I know this for sure. I love film, it's something that I dearly care for and believe is a superior art form, that being said, what I am going to say is going to sound a little 'bad'. I actually like the colorization of films. I know I know, but when sometimes it's the only time that you can get younger people to watch and appreciate them. Also, I just sometimes like the way it looks. Almost like another kind of art piece. So yes, I do like it. I really enjoyed the Technicolor period of movies. That i really found nice. I enjoyed many of the musicals that were in technicolor. cinematics is a huge part of any film, so it's important to remember to have it match the ambiance of the film. But yeah, I don't mind colorization. My sister hates it, most film majors and such hate it, but I love it :D.