Giving or Receiving?

@leateagee (3667)
China
September 30, 2012 5:14am CST
One of my job description at work is to give feedbacks to trainees. These trainess are teachers to be of the school where I am working with. I had been working in this school for five years and now it is expanding and as one of the trained teachers here I have to watch these teachers as they do their best to follow the school's system. Every time it comes to feedback time, I can always hear and see nervous chats and looks from their faces. I had been in this situation too. I had been strong enough and have known my skill so I survived and got through with things. I don't personally like receiving feedbacks because I feel being judge even though I did my best but a company has their rules or criteria and that should be met. Now that I am giving feedbacks, I feel bad too whenever I see people with potentials but ha snot meet the criteria of what the company wants. I also give advices or suggestions on how to help them learn quicker and be able to pass the tests and demonstrations. What about you my friends? Which one do you prefer, the one giving the feedback or the one receiving it? Have you received or given one and the result wasn't satisfactorily? I feel like if I said something not good it might ruin their lives. Or it might not be good to the company too if we don't get the right person. Thanks in advance myLotters!
9 responses
@deazil (4723)
• United States
30 Sep 12
I see you are busy tonight! I would rather be the giver of feedback. And in your case it is a delicate position to be in. Ruin someone's life or bad for the company. Tough spot to be in. I would think carefully about my feedback. I think honesty and integrity are key elements. Constructive criticism is good but it depends on how the (receiving) individual perceives this critiquing. Some people don't take it well. Tact is important. In giving feedback you can help a person develop their skills and strengthen their weaknesses. This is one of the ideas (I think) behind constructive criticism. The person being evaluated needs to realize this. It is to help them in the long run. Unfortunately, not everyone will see it this way. You are sweet and kind and I can imagine this is difficult for you. Try to look at it in a positive light. I had a manager once who would never say a good thing about anybody. She was terrible. No matter what a person did she criticized. And it wasn't constructive. She was a most hated individual. I never heard anyone say a nice thing about her. She used her position of authority to bully people. That's the other extreme. Try to stay in the middle. Good luck with your feedback. Don't know if any of this helped you. But I'm sure you'll do the right thing and give it your best.
@leateagee (3667)
• China
30 Sep 12
Good morning to you and good night to me! &(*._.*)& It did help. I remain firm with my decisions and make sure that I show what I preach. I do my best not to get too personal. I was not choosen to do the job to make friends but to improve or enhance their abilities. My trainees are not all certified or graduate of education. So, I make it clear to the trainees that I am not judging their diplomas or whatever credentials they have shown earlier. Since they pass that part, it means work for all of us. They show to me that they could be an asset to the company then they have a big chance for the position. Friendship is allowed but it won't be a basis too. I am glad I am in China and the people I train are in the Philippines. I am glad we are not near or else I will see little gifts in my office. You are right, it is so hard for me sometimes to decide but I told them honestly if I will be soft or dishonest about your performance, sooner or later we will discover that you are not good for the comapny then you will be fired and all the chances that should be for the right person is wasted. I have someone whom I consult also if I don't feel the words or decisions I have said were right. I make sure I check my own performance and also seek guidance from my superiors. Have a great day! I will go to bed now. Good night to me and good morning to you again!
@leateagee (3667)
• China
2 Oct 12
Oh. Thank you. They say I am that's why the pressure is too much. I do need advices from you and the others. I need to hear what people really think because I cannot ask the trainees ... we might build a personal attachment which is not good. We mean only business.
@deazil (4723)
• United States
30 Sep 12
Wow! You do a really good, thorough job. You're really a big asset to that company. I'm sure they appreciate you. I am very impressed. You didn't need any advice from me! Good night.
@else22 (4317)
• India
30 Sep 12
Hi sis,the question is difficult to answer.I can only say that I want to receive feedback from people who are older and more learned than me and you are one of such persons.At the same time I would like to give feedback to people who are younger and less knowing than me.As I want to improve myself,receiving feedback from people like you is perhaps what I want.How can I improve others if I have my own shortcomings?
@leateagee (3667)
• China
30 Sep 12
I agree with your opinion. I also enjoy receiving feedbacks not just to the older but also to those who are more experienced than me. I love to listen to people's personal experience and how they overcame their obstacles. As what I've told my trainees, I may be here right now and guiding them, sooner or later I have to let them go an dthey have to work with minimal or no supervision at all. The trust we give to them must be maintained as they earn it every day o fthe training and by teh time they are hired. Honestly, when I was younger, I hated receiving feedbacks from my parents, relatives and especially my teachers. As I grow older, I understood they had a point and though they are irritating, their role is to reitirate to my brain and heart how life works when they are not around.
@leateagee (3667)
• China
2 Oct 12
Life really sucks when we were younger. We want to have our own criteria without the age gap comparison but it's not possible. The more experienced people which are our parents are more responsible and know better. I am one of the rebellious type but my mom gives me some time tehne evntually I follow her. She wins all the time!
@else22 (4317)
• India
1 Oct 12
Of course,sis,when we are children,we want to do everything that we like to.We at that time hate feedbacks.As we grow up,we realize that we have to improve ourselves.We are mature then.So feedbacks begin offering us a chance todo away with our minus points.Thanks,sis.
@walking2010 (1009)
• United States
1 Oct 12
I think that I would be the one giving feedback, because the main thing about it is, its the way that you deliver a message of how some one need to change something to become a better worker, because in most cases people take authority to far and they don't car about people lives and what they need. If you deliver a good message in a good way that is different then delivering a message with an attitude on the end of it.
@leateagee (3667)
• China
2 Oct 12
That is true. if my comment or message is for their improvement, then even though it's not good, it isn't a bad feedback because it will make them better.
@jenny1015 (13366)
• Philippines
1 Oct 12
Either way is fine. Although there would be negative comments, these should not be taken in a negative way, but rather it should be a means of encouragement for the betterment of the person.
@leateagee (3667)
• China
2 Oct 12
True! I agree with you. Whatever the comment is ... it's for their betterment!
• Philippines
1 Oct 12
Hi leateagee, as for me its always depends on the people, the situation and the place. Nothing is permanent yet we cannot judge nor they cannot judge either..It's true it's better to give than to receive and whatever the situation maybe just be yourself and do whatever you think that will benefit others from your good deeds.
@leateagee (3667)
• China
2 Oct 12
Thank you so much. I will keep that in mind. I wouldn't feel guilty whatever the result is because I know I did my bets for them.
• China
30 Sep 12
How kind you are! All the feedbacks are good,as long as they are given before you think twice, and made through the dialetics. I prefer to be the giving,I will try my best to give the objective suggestions as you do,to help them make progress.
@leateagee (3667)
• China
2 Oct 12
Thank you! Sometimes I don't feel like giving feedback because there are bad feedbacks that I have to say and people are very expressive, I will see immediately that the effect was negative. There are those who accepts negative feedbacks pretty well and learns from it and there are those that don't. Also, what I don't like when I give good ones too is because some people become immediately proud or relaxed instead of maintain the good feedback given. It's so difficult to hadnle people.
• China
3 Oct 12
That's the challenge for you,you can also improve yourself when dealing with these problems,you can make it,come on!
@lou_is (665)
• India
30 Sep 12
Hi Leateagee, if you ask the same thing then according to me its your job or duty to give feedback to your trainees. If you are in office you should forget the relationship between you and the person who is next to you. You are serving a good job and you should server it better whomever is your trainee. So feel proud that you are giving feedback to your teachers who helped you to learn a lot and made you to grow like this. One more thing is Feedback is nothing but taking it in rite way and improving our mistakes. Hope you will serve better. Have a nice day.
@leateagee (3667)
• China
30 Sep 12
Thnak you so much. In a way or the other as I train them every day, even without asking personal matters it comes it in our conversation. As much as I wanted to avoid because sometimes it affects my judgement, I can't help but close my eyes and really pin point what must be improved no matter what. I am glad so far, none has come up to me and said: "You are wrong, only if you saw me more." They are very interesting and talented peopel. You are right I am learning from them too. I take notes on all the things I learnt and also share it to them or to others to come.
@natliegleb (5175)
• India
1 Oct 12
trust me if i say this,its all about giving and not kickbacks so when we trust a lot then we can give and eventually you will receive more from them than what you expected ideally
@leateagee (3667)
• China
2 Oct 12
I will trust you and would be very observant on that matter. Usually I don't follow up when I let them go. I just hear positive or negative progress from the bosses if there are any. I just hate it so much when they become boastful and don't work hard anymore.
@Raine38 (12257)
• United States
30 Sep 12
That's a tough one. They say that it is better to give than to receive, but in your case, it would be very hard if you are always doing the giving of feedbacks. We're just humans, and sometimes, we tend to forget and we can also be a bit abusive of the authority, even to a smallest degree. If I am also being evaluated and the recipient of feedbacks, I can form some sort of sympathy to those who are at the receiving end of my feedbacks therefore, I can improve on the manner or how I communicate with them. Truly, one cannot fully learn the lessons of being in a certain situation if he hasn't been in the same spot. Maybe I will choose to be both; I wanna be able to give feedbacks and advises, to impart what I have learned. And at the same time, I wanna be able to improve and evolve that I will also want to be evaluated by someone who is smarter and more knowledgeable than I am.
@leateagee (3667)
• China
30 Sep 12
I enoy what I am doing now because there are peopel who really appreciate the feedbacks I give to improve them. It's just that there are peopel who really thinks they are talented and/or skillful BUT it doesn't show. In my case, I have to see both, when you say you are good, you've got to show it. My boss would wnat only to hire a doer not a talker. You are right. It's better to experience both. Being able to really give comments based from experience is better than just by the book.