A few words about UK, the Prüm convention and the Schengen Information System

Tweet

Two days ago a former French prime minister was telling to a tv that dismantling Europe would lead to war. When I read the comments about France in some UK newspapers, I am sure about that : they are full of clichés and hate about France and French, while you would hardly find a comment against Britain in a French newspaper. As an example I am giving a link to an article published today in the Daily Express about «France trying to block UK access to crucial EU crime and anti-terror database after Brexit». The UK wants to stay into the Prüm convention but France is blocking it. The Prüm convention from 2005 was written to combat terrorism and fight cross-border crimes. Crucial database ? UK (I am tempted to write «as usual») opted-out and asked to join it only in January 2016, it was accepted by the EU commission in May, one month before the Brexit. The convention permits to exchange data between countries about DNA, fingerprints and vehicle registration of any EU citizen. There are several problems about UK keeping access to these data : first, the convention is opened only to countries members of the EU, but as UK was member of the EU, maybe an exception can be made here. But, second, the use of the data is controlled by the European Court of Justice, and UK leaving the ECJ, the only response seems to be a big «NO», nobody would be able to control the use done by UK of these data after the Brexit. The same article tells that the British police carried 539 millions checks of the Schengen Information System last year. The SIS contains mainly information about stolen or lost guns, vehicles, money, illegal migrants, people searched for crimes, etc. OMG ! Britain is not member of the Schengen area and it is an island, it received 39.9 millions of visitors last year. The only use in UK for this database is for the border police to check the ID of visitors at arrival. 539 millions checks for 40 millions visitors, not all from the EU ? London, we have a problem. Since UK got access to the SIS in 2015, an unlawful use of it has been done : the content of the database has been copied and transmitted to private contractors outside of the EU, it has been shared with some US companies, it has been copied on laptops, etc. Already in 2015, after a first control by the EU, UK was warned to reduce the abuse it was doing of it, but it never complied. Another control done by the EU in 2017 demonstrated that the situation had worsened. Letting Britain to continue to have access to these database after the Brexit ? For the SIS, the damage is already done, but for the Prüm convention database ? The readers of the Daily Express can call me like they want, I support completely the concerns of my country about letting UK access to the personal data of any EU citizen after the Brexit without any control : photos, fingerprints, vehicles, etc. The possibilities of misuse are too important, and the profit dubious, UK has no personal ID and cannot offer a similar counterpart to the EU.