The Walking Dead: Which Six Characters Would You Keep?

@srhelmer (7029)
Beaver Dam, Wisconsin
November 28, 2018 10:10am CST
First, an explanation. I read yesterday that the show The Walking Dead continues to lose viewers. It is my opinion a large part of the reason behind that is the show has too large of an ensemble cast and that is causing popular characters to be reduced to cameo roles or get completely lost in the shuffle. Because of this, I think the best thing the series could do is find a way to wipe out all but six of those survivors and essentially start over with a streamlined cast. I'm assuming the show's writers won't follow this advice. But, if it were to actually happen, which six characters do you think should make the final cut? My list would be as follows: Daryl and Carol - Both because they deserve some respect for being with the series since season 1 and because they have survival skills (I am, for the purposes of this discussion, also assuming the various communities would be destroyed too). Michonne and Judith - Judith makes the cut to pay homage to the departed Rick and maybe give the show a do-over for the poorly-used Carl while Michonne gets to be her mother figure and finally gets to show off her fighting skills again. And, yes, I would be heartless and have her mystery child (who I'm assuming is also Rick's) killed off. One kid is enough, thank you. Eugene - Tough decision on this one because I think he is an annoying character. But, the group needs someone that can come up with unique solutions to get them out of a bad situation and he seems like the perfect character for that. Negan - I would have him join the survivor group as a reformed villain/anti-hero or, in other words, a re-vised version of Merle Dixon. It's just not a zombie apocalypse show unless there's a member of the group that will cross questionable lines and can't be fully trusted.
1 person likes this
1 response
@JohnRoberts (109857)
• Los Angeles, California
28 Nov 18
I would have to agree with your choices. I think a huge mistake was made in killing off Carl. Daryl and Carol are essential at this point. So is Michonne. Right about Judith keeping Rick's presence alive. Negan is the uber bad guy. Eugene is interesting and different. Tara, Rosita, Gabriel, Aaron and Enid have been on awhile but don't do much. None of them can step in for Glen, Sasha, Maggie, Morgan, Hershel, Abraham or Andrea. Characters are becoming weaker.
@srhelmer (7029)
• Beaver Dam, Wisconsin
28 Nov 18
I agree. That's mostly because the show became almost solely about Rick and nobody bothered to develop any of the other characters in case there was a reason to write him off the series. Wasn't a fan of the decision to kill Carl. I know he wanted to focus on school. But, they could have had him just go away for a while, like they did with Maggie.
1 person likes this