Is maternity leave fair?

India
September 20, 2006 2:41am CST
So ... the women get the days off for being pregnant and time to spend with their new baby once he/she is born. What what about the guys? They don't get any sort of leave like that. Can you imagine if they went into the boss and said "Hey man, I've gotta take 2 months off for jock itch leave" *laughs* So....whatcha think? Fair?? Unfair?? or Who cares???
4 people like this
68 responses
• United States
20 Oct 06
Well comparing jock itch to labor is so wild its laughable. Men can request time off, under the FMLA act it might be paid or unpaid depends on the company, Not all females get paid maternity leave either.
1 person likes this
• United States
20 Oct 06
I agree completely. lol
• United States
20 Oct 06
yes, the woman should always have maternity leave. As many have said the father can usually get leave too if he asks for it. Its not only the woman that deserves it but dont we also think it might be fair to the baby, the baby who is most important. Also I would like to make a point that most fathers are happy just to be able to be with their children at all. My husband is in the military and thank god has been able to be here for the births but I know lots of people who are deployed who dont get to be with their wives and babies at all. War doesnt let you come home even for the birth of your child. Sometimes I think we should step back and think about things like that. Feel lucky that you can go to work and come home to see your wife and child and sit on your own couch and hold your baby
@Rileydog (197)
• United States
21 Sep 06
I beleive that the law in the United states provides for men to take paternity leave. It is part of the Family Leave law. However, I think it only applies to companies with more than 50 employees.
1 person likes this
20 Sep 06
yaa itz fair.. no problem in it.. babies need their mother atleast for the first three months.. also mothers need some rest b4 the delievery...
• India
7 Oct 06
ok
• India
8 Oct 06
i agree with rahul and in last 3 months additional care is a must
• India
16 Oct 06
which rahul...???? :-))
@juls2me2 (2150)
• United States
12 Oct 06
Are you jealous of a woman giving birth to a child? I'm sure if a woman could let her man go through the pain of delivery and recovery, she'd give it to him gladly. If JOCK ITCH is your only comparison to giving birth, you've got issues. At least Jock Itch, you can get rid of the pain with a cream instantly. Birth....the pain lasts anywhere from a few hours to days and then recovery takes a few months to fully get back to normal function. Remember going through all of that with a child at your bossom several hours out of the day, not getting much sleep. Your comments came off sounding very selfish and inconsiderate for your wife (the mother of your children). If you just wish you could be part of the experience and be there for your child too, I'd check into Paternity leave as well, some companies offer it and highly recommend it to be used. If your job doesn't offer Paternity leave, they may allow you to use your vacation leave to have time with your wife and new baby. Your wife would be lucky to have her husband help her at this time. My husband couldn't wait to go to work. Since the baby had to be fed every few hours for the first weeks all hours of the day. My mother came and stayed with us to help me while he was at work. Then my husband was ready to help with the baby when he got home.
• United States
28 Sep 06
Funny, my husband got paternity leave (he could take several weeks paid) and I got NOTHING for maternity leave. But a woman goes through a lot physically during labor that she needs to recover from, and additionally, babies should really be with their mothers to nurse for at *least* several months. I can totally see why it would seem unfair, though. But, hey, you guys start bleeding every month and THEN we'll talk. lol.
1 person likes this
• United States
20 Sep 06
Many places provide paternity leave if you ask. It's important for a father to bond with his baby. In the US, the FMLA is the law that provides both men and women with 12 weeks of unpaid family leave after birth or adoption. See this: http://www.babycenter.com/refcap/pregnancy/pregnantatwork/8258.html
• India
16 Oct 06
thank u everyone for ur valuable responses....
• United States
12 Oct 06
Yes. My husband took off 6 weeks after our oldest was born. He used all his saved sick time and vacation time so he could get paid, just like a woman would have to do in the US (since we don't get paid maternity leave). After each of the other three he only took 2 weeks. It was nice to have him around while I was recovering from my c-sections.
@chalmette69 (3007)
• United States
20 Oct 06
Do guys have to carry a child in there stomach for 9 months,or go threw the pain or anything like that? All they have to do is stand there, so why would they get a maternity leave, they haven't done anything.
• United States
24 Oct 06
Maternity leave isn't about giving birth only. It is about adjusting to life with a new baby and bonding with the baby and starting a life as a family. Men need just as much time to adjust as a woman. Plus who helps out at home if Daddy isn't there. Not all women have the option of having all their family around to help. When our youngest daughter was born we were 500 miles away from our closest family. None of them could come stay with us while I had the baby via c-section. So I went to the OR alone while my husband watched our 3 kids. He then took another week and half off so I could at least have a little time to recover. If he didn't take leave how would I have recovered from the birth? Mostly he did it because he wanted time to be with the baby, as he deserves.
• United States
21 Sep 06
yes maternity leave is very fair, its not just time to spend with the baby, its time to recover from having the baby. and there is such thing as paternity leave for dads
• India
7 Oct 06
where...???
@marciascott (25529)
• United States
20 Oct 06
Yes it's fair you can't work the full 9 months you could hurt the baby.
• United States
24 Oct 06
I don't understand that. Many women work until they go into labor. As long as you don't do anything real strenous in your job and there are no other health risks there is no reason a woman can't work until they give birth. My mom worked up unti the week I was due. Most women in the US save their maternity leave until after the baby is born so they have as much time at home to bond with the baby before going back to work.
@toonatoons (3737)
• Philippines
31 Oct 06
actually, there's now what is called paternity leave --- for the husbands. but i think they get just two weeks off, which i believe is fair enough, considering that they weren't the ones who did all the hard work in the labor room.
• United States
24 Oct 06
i believe that it is very fair, and also with the FMLA (Family medical leave act) a father can get time off anytime from the child's birth until the child's first birthday, do your research before posting such a sexist post
• United States
24 Oct 06
also, you are a man, you have no idea what being pregnant does to your body, you have no clue about the stress and pain that our bodies have to deal with while pregnant & dont even get me started about giving birth or the babys care right after birth, just like surgery or illness our bodies need to heal. How would you like to have a cut from your d*ck to your a$$ & have to go right back to work without it having time to heal, or force something the size of a melon out of your d*ck & go right back to work.....
@sree4030 (656)
• India
26 Oct 06
yes. they must be given that leave. ingfact, peternal leave also is indeed needed
• United States
24 Oct 06
??? I think that men should get some time off to spent with the baby once the baby is born and be able to get paid for it..... But jock itch is not even comparble to having a baby!!
• India
26 Oct 06
hey! I have heard some companies are giving mat. leave even to the 'to be' Fathers - Infosys is one such company. A great step towards building a great world!
@terriann (4450)
• United States
24 Oct 06
yes, it's fair.
@marciascott (25529)
• United States
24 Oct 06
Well that true but if I had to do it all over I wouldn't work but for about 7 months.
• India
26 Oct 06
Well... don't wann be rude, but mate you'r asking a really stupid question! even geoffery boycott's mom could answer it.. & for that matter any mom. Man its fair enough... what do you expect? women should come 9months pregnant to office & deliver their baby on their chair?? lol
• United States
26 Oct 06
Well since the majority of women take care of their babies and have to recuperate for at least 6 weeks then I say its fair. If your jock itch is that bad maybe you should ask for a personal leave!
@justvenkys (1357)
• India
26 Oct 06
that is womens advantage yar.we cant help it.
• United States
25 Oct 06
OK first off there is such a thing as paternity leave if men would just ask for it. And YES maternity leave is fair. I just got back from it. Although my husband took off 3 wks of vacation after the baby was born, I was the one who was sleep deprived because he did not feed her at 12, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10 in the morning. He was able to take a shower everyday, and did he ever help pick up the house or make dinner. No. I was the one who had to rearrange life as I knew it. Just as you get in a schedule and really bond with your child, then I had to turn around and go back to work. So now I have to suffer the guilt of leaving my child everyday for 10hrs.