The British Electoral System

@phreak (23)
January 4, 2007 10:51am CST
The British political system is effectively a elective dictatorship. Realistically there are only two parties with any chance of being elected (Labour and Conservative). Do you think the system should be changed to a more representative system, or do you think the current system is effective?
1 response
@snowflake5 (1579)
• United States
4 Jan 07
I'm afraid I disagree with you. If it was an "elected dictatorship" as you put it, only ONE party would have a chance of victory and you would be FORCED to vote for them (that's usually the definition of "dictatorship"). But as you say, there are two parties, Labour and Conservative, who both have a very good chance of winning, and as there are two, there is a choice, and what's more you are free to vote for whoever you like, or even abstain - so there is no "force" or "dictating" going on at all! Some of the minor parties like to pretend that there is a "dictatorship" and that's the reason they haven't done well in elections. But the truth is, they haven't done well because their policies are rubbish and they haven't persuaded enough voters to vote for them! Instead of sour grapes and blaming "the system", they should think about why people are rejecting them and improve their policies. Think about it, if you failed an exam, would you conclude it was your fault because you hadn't studied hard enough, or would you blame the test paper and "the system" and demand that they be changed?! P.S. it is possible for a minor party to become a major party - the Labour party came from nowhere at the start of the 20th C. Both Labour and the Tories have adapted over time - the Tories under Thatcher reached out to the working class, and Labour under Blair reached out to the middle class. The reason the Lib Dems have shrivelled since WW1, when all men and women over 18 finally got the vote, is that they refuse to reach out. Instead they remain a precious minority party, more interested in keeping themselves pure than in reaching out and making the broad coalitions and compromises that you see in the Tories and Labour.
@phreak (23)
6 Jan 07
Thank you for your opinion, what I mean is even though there are two parties only one has a chance of getting in unless the Party in power is majorly disgraced in some way. And another thing the Labour Party did not come from no where they actually originated from the Labour Representation Committee. They later mixed with the more radical members of the Liberal party. So really the collapse of the Liberal Party brought the Labour Party to power.