Does your child ever hold his/her breath?

United States
January 21, 2007 7:59am CST
I find this behavior really strange in my son. I have mentioned this to his doctors, and to various therapists, etc.. nobody seems to have heard of anything like it, so I'm not sure why he does this. My son does this (as far as I know) on a daily basis: breathes in, holds it for a second, then breathes out. There is an obvious pause. He may relax and breathe normally for a while, but then he goes back to this strange breathe in-pause way of doing things. I wonder if this is part of his Autism? Something sensory related, where he just is more aware of his breathing? Or if he's just goofy? LOL Anybody have a child that does this?
3 people like this
11 responses
22 Jan 07
How old is your son? does he have any siblings or do you think he may be doing this to gain your attention. For example when he first did it, did you comment, make an issue, ask him, fuss over him, show concern towards him. Now do you do that same type of behaviour every time he does this. If you do chances are you son has found a way to gain your attention. So the trick is to try to ignore it next time he does it, just either walk away, make no comment or pretend it doesn't bother you. Okay so you have the added let's say "hangup" of him being autistic. How autistic is he, some of them are very intelligent youngsters and although you think they are just interested in their own little world, this might be his way of communicating something to you about his world. God knows how their minds work. My nephew and great nephew are autistic, figure them out? notta chance! So this breath in-pause way may just be part of his routine, something has made him think that by doing that, something happens in his environment that creates a change. Which brings me right back to your reaction to his behaviour. "Stop that" or "Why are doing that?" I would still guess if you pretend to ignore it, it will go away all by its self. If it doesn't then I'm stumped Sylvie and it may be just another little nuance that your son has developed as part of his autism. If the doctors are not worried about it, and he is physically healthy and its not leading to any harmful behaviour like bashing his head on the floor. I would just let him get on with it. He'll be fine, my nephew is 17 now! He goes to college, he has a girlfriend, he wants to get married! Bright blessings Sylvie
1 person likes this
• United States
23 Jan 07
I never say anything when he does it. He just does it, and I know it's been happening for quite some time now, because I remember asking one (or more) of his therapists about it quite early on... and he started being seen by them a little over a year ago. Basically I might come up next to him, and try to interact with him. At some point, I can notice his breathing sounds very deliberate- he breaths in, pauses, lets it out. It goes back to normal at some point, and then he does this holding process again. I don't recall saying anything to him about it, because I don't know if he would even understand the words "holding your breath". I just listen to his breathing, and that's about it. that's so great about your nephew! :) congrats for him, and for your family. What a wonderful achievement!
1 person likes this
23 Jan 07
Thanks Sylvie and I hope things get better for you. Kids are amazing, even those with special needs. I love them to bits but I am not a mom/mum so I suppose I do not worry about little things that they do. He may just grow out of it, quick question, when you see or saw your doctor, did he check him over you know listen to his heart and lungs, I would get him checked out just to make sure. Although it is probably nothing physical at all, and if your doctor has already seen him then don't worry. But next time he has a physical, mention your concerns to the doctor. Doctors tend to brush parents off, as being over anxious or "your worrying about nothing" but Mum/Mom knows best and if your worried I would mention just how concerned you are. Now I am not saying that you should rush to the docs this minute hun, just when you see them next. It will put your mind at rest because all in all its probably nothing. Bright Blessings Sylvie.
1 person likes this
@cjsmom (1423)
• United States
23 Jan 07
Yes, kitty...CJ used to do this an awful lot a few years ago. It was very noticeable and it scared me so much at times. I'd have to keep saying, "CJ, breathe", and then he'd start again. It got to the point where I was so scared that I'd sleep with him to make sure he was breathing; didn't get any rest myself, of course. I'd hear him stop breathing and nudge him, then I'd drift off and jerk awake, listening again. We took him to have a 'sleep test' for apnea as a result without any conclusions because he couldn't sleep long enough. He'd keep twisting and turning and moaning, groaning; he didn't like all the wires. I slept next to him trying to keep him relaxed by caressing his back and arms. But we didn't get any results. Made me mad! I think that he still holds his breath while he's awake but I haven't been able to really catch him at it any more. So, prayerfully he's outgrowing that as well. I feel for you, kitty.
1 person likes this
• United States
23 Jan 07
Thank you for your post. I guess it's nice to hear somebody else knows what I'm talking about. I'm so kicking myself right now that I forgot to mention it at the Autism clinic when I took him in 2 weeks ago. The dr mentioned possibly doing the sleep test for the night terrors, but this might be another reason for her to want to do it.. of course I don't know how they'd manage to get him to keep all the wires on. (do they put the wires on after he falls asleep??) With our luck, we wouldn't get any results either. LOL
1 person likes this
@toonatoons (3737)
• Philippines
22 Jan 07
this is strange, indeed, something that i feel must not be neglected by doctors, because what if later on in life, the pauses would increase to more than a second? twenty seconds without breathing could be fatal. there must be some doctor who could give you the answers. i think we have a doctor here in the mylot community --- username's drpotpot or something.
• United States
22 Jan 07
Is this person a legitimate doctor? I hate to sound rude about it, but obviously on the internet, one could say they're God. LOL :)
@lisado (1227)
• United States
23 Jan 07
Our son doesn't do this, but since everyone's child is different, it's possible that maybe he is forgetting to breathe until his body reminds him? I don't know what else to say. I don't know anyone who has done this, either, but it doesn't mean there aren't others out there.
1 person likes this
@abhiquest (579)
• India
22 Jan 07
I have tried it a lot of times myself. Infact I used to taking it up as a challenge. I used to keep a digital stop watch besides me. Then I would take a deep breath and would try to hold it for as long as possible. Initially I took up aim to hold my breath for a minute. Which was soon achieved. And then I targetted it for 2 minutes. It took me nearly a month to achieve that, but then I started having headaches because of it and I just stopped. So if your son happen to take it the same way as I had, there should not be anything wrong with the child. Just discourage this practice. There are other ways to take up challenges. And scintifically also this is not good.
• United States
23 Jan 07
I used to do this all the time myself, while in the bathtub.. seeing how long I could hold my breath underwater. There's nothing wrong with that.
• Sweden
22 Jan 07
I think it's a way of wanting to control the breathing, I do that sometimes. My little brother had a thing with his breathing last year where he wouldn't breathe at all when he went in to his room. He was an obsessive cleaner and didn't want to "mess up" his room with his breath.
• United States
22 Jan 07
Hmm.. that's interesting. Was he really young? (I'm guessing probably not, if he was an obsessive cleaner, but who knows).
• Sweden
23 Jan 07
No, he was actually pretty young. 10 years old! It was very weird indeed so I'm glad he doesn't do it anymore.
@rainbow (6761)
21 Jan 07
My son has always done this, although I don't know why. Once he had a bad dream and I couldn't wake him up and he was hardly breathing but when I took him to the hospital they didn't seem worried at all. I was once told it is because he is aware of his breath so is playing with it. As long as norml breathing returns I suppose it can't be anything too bad.
• United States
21 Jan 07
Thank you for posting your experience. I guess as long as regular breathing resumes at some point, I shouldn't worry?
@earning (141)
• United Kingdom
22 Jan 07
Breath holding is quite common. I certainly did it to see how long I could. In the case of your child it does seem he is doing it regularly. I'd think it was just a child's curiosity as he discovers things he can do. And if you do it yourself (I am doing it now), it is quite intriguing, it makes you more aware of yourself. Ultimately, what would happen if he held his breath forever ....? He would simply pass out, at which point the body would naturally start breathing again, so no worries there!
@ronita34 (3922)
• Canada
24 Jan 07
Actually no i haven't and you might as well say that i have practically raised 4. Two are mine and two are my younger sisters! I have known of children to lose their breath crying and stuff but never just hilding their breath...wow! Maybe he is just being goofy and already has a good personality going on...LOL!! Or maybe he is just bored and trying to let you know with a huge paused sigh...LOL! I wish i could help out more and good luck with this i am sure he is fine keep an eye on him just in case though! God Bless!
• United States
22 Jan 07
I know my response seems odd and perhaps nuts but... What came to my mind when I read your post is how some teenagers do what is called 'choking'. Its a terrible game where they can experience a small brief 'high' by having someone hold their throat and block their airways until they nearly pass out, it supposidly gives them a quick euphoric sensation. Perhaps your child discovered this and is doing it to himself by holding his breath. Just a thought, and perhaps his doctor needs to be made aware of it if he/she isn't already.
• India
22 Jan 07
don't worry about u'r child ,u'r kid is doing good without knowing himself.why i'm saying is this the type of YOGA one has breath and stop his breath for a second this help's to relax the people .this is yoga which i can follow daily morning......