do u think harry potter would do better if it was tv series rather than movie?

@vik24587 (144)
India
January 22, 2007 11:18am CST
how many of u think harry potter would be better tv series than movie? they could have covered more of the book and could have put all the plots (ofcourse we could have seen the whole world cup).
2 people like this
15 responses
Multanee
@Multanee (267)
• Pakistan
24 Jan 07
Off course yes,Cause it is a novel and novel cant be fully presented in a 1.25 hours movie.In a TV series it can be presentd effectivle and effeciently.
electrocomsengu
@electrocomsengu (4)
• India
24 Jan 07
yes of coarse.People would have enjoyed for many days put together rather than just 3 hours
cyfernet
@cyfernet (2383)
• United States
23 Jan 07
i don't think it would be any good cos the effects in the movie cannot be made in the TV series. it would be a ordinary TV series if they happen to make it
joad203
@joad203 (80)
• Philippines
23 Jan 07
No. I think i want it only in the movies.. so that the story will be continuous and not like a series wherein you have to wait for the next episode 24 hours after.. i mean, when the episode today ends.. you still have to wait until tomorrow to view the next one. totally bad,.
elixer
@elixer (253)
• India
23 Jan 07
yes they could have covered most of the book if it was a tv series. seeing the movie without reading the book does not give u a clear idea of whats exactly happening and u will be missing a lot of humoured jokes and more. so it would be better if it would have been a tv series. but never mind becas by reading the book everything seems to be happening in front of us.
hotvebs
@hotvebs (106)
• India
23 Jan 07
i think harry is better as a actor in a movie than a tv serial.
siddhinfo
@siddhinfo (1500)
• India
23 Jan 07
I agree with you if it was TV serial then it would have been more famous as most of the people worldwide would have seen it. But afterall this is business. The producer earn more on name only by relaesing it in the Theaters all over the world
the_dutchess
@the_dutchess (2610)
• Philippines
23 Jan 07
i don't think so although that's a good suggestion. but the a tv series is not as big as a movie so that's why it's made as film. people may easily be tired of seeing the characters everyday unlike when it's a movie, people's level of excitedness and intesity is so high that they can't resist watching it. can't wait for order of the phoenix this july, hope it'll be a great one!
emeraldisle
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
23 Jan 07
I don't know if it would be better but I wouldn't mind seeing one come of it. After all no reason it can't be both. The show could fill in the gaps left from what the movies didn't show, especially the fourth movie. Who knows maybe they plan to in the future. Be nice if they did.
yoleis27
@yoleis27 (557)
• Israel
23 Jan 07
Cool Question :) I think I would prefer a tv series becaus ethen they woudnt have to cut all the stuff they cut in the movies because of the short time.. Maybe an anime series would be even cooler since japanese can do really cool stuff with animes :)
eliza_bennet
@eliza_bennet (133)
• South Africa
23 Jan 07
I think if the movie could ruin the essence of the book a tv show would perhaps ruin its soul. Would be like a soap opera that just never ended and irritated your very being until you ended up hating harry potter.
gautam007
@gautam007 (271)
• India
23 Jan 07
no harry potter is better in movies only..........
adanickdisini
@adanickdisini (46)
• Indonesia
23 Jan 07
i don't know how many i think about it.. but i allready think about it since the frst time i watched Harry Potter and the socceres stone... I much rather watch in tv series than cinema... but of course with great computer effect...
chino_k
@chino_k (9)
• Jamaica
23 Jan 07
oh yes i do i do just to keep up with the book but then again it wud cost alot for the producers
shobejen
@shobejen (644)
• Philippines
22 Jan 07
definitely yes, harry potter is a novel, a movie cannot fully cover everything written in the novel... if harry potter was a tv series, the chapters can be the episodes and more details would have been given each scene... but ofcourse, if it was a tv series, it wouldn't earn much compared to a movie...