American Idol, The Best Show On TV? Or The Worst?

@arvijhon (126)
Philippines
January 30, 2007 5:30am CST
Trying to settle "Idol" debate once and for all! The new season of "American Idol" is polarizing audiences. Some love it. Some hate it. Many hate loving it. Almost everyone loves hating it. But the fact remains: More people are watching it than ever before. They just seem to be complaining about it a little louder than they used to. Which makes us woner...Is The show's greatness equal to its monumental ratings, or is the show as overinflated as the egos of its three judges? Is it still catty? or has it becme downright cruel? And what the hell is wrong with Paula Abdul? How about you, what do you think? Any comments or suggestions?
2 responses
@freak369 (5113)
• United States
6 Feb 07
I watched a few episodes and thought it was a little on the cruel side; especially when they were doing it for the ratings or to get a laugh. I don't normally run around slingly quotes at people, especially ones that are biblically based but ... "don't throw rocks when you live in a glass house" is something that all the judges should repeat over and over when they are making snide remarks or making fun of people when they walk off from the audition.
• Philippines
30 Jan 07
For me american idol is the best. It showcase different talents. Paula Abdul is a sweetheart and a great singer too.