To use daycare or not to use daycare, that is the question....

Canada
February 18, 2007 11:09pm CST
I have been faced with some issues recently regarding my choice to put my son in daycare. FYI: this is a long read, I apologize. I'll start from the top, I went back to work a couple months early from my maternity because of financial situations. My son is now 2. I have recently retruned to school and I am almost 1 year in. Since starting him in daycare when he was 10 months old, I have decided it is probably the best thing for him and keep him in Monday - Friday basically from 9-5. I have a friend who is a Mother as well, but she owns her own daycare business. She is at a point in her life, where she will have to start her daughter in school. She does not think it is right for the child to be in school, or daycare for that length of time. I was under the impression that daycare and school was a good thing when your child is learning by leaps and bounds. I have begun to have my doubts about my choices and wonder if it is such a good thing to have him in daycare so much... What are your opinions on daycare and the amount of time your child should spend there. Am I wrong to doubt myslef or what?
1 person likes this
5 responses
• United States
19 Feb 07
It is not possible that you will have the best thing always. What I believe tha mother's company may be better than day care as I am a home-maker. But I stay at home because I didnot get job, now I don't want to start to search for a job. But if I had a job I would be doing the same thing what you're doing, even if my financial condition would be better. It is really a hard thing to decide. But if you are earning then it will surely help your child in further studies and making future. so be happy. every thing has pros and cons.
1 person likes this
@shannon76 (1232)
• United States
19 Feb 07
I think that the best thing for any child is with his parents (as long as they are loving, non-abusive parents of course). I think that as long as you have a working, live-in spouse, that one of the parents should be staying at home and raising the child instead of a complete stranger. My child only goes to a day care one day a week during church service (which our church provides). Why would anyone think that it would be better for your child to be raised by someone else? And if someone really wanted to, they could stay at home with thier children with one spouse working. My husband and I did it. We went from a two income household with my income being more then my husbands, down to a one income household with a child. We learned how to work the system, how to get assistance from the state (our income qualifications only let us get assistance for a short time because my hubby got a new job with more pay). We went without luxury items. We didn't go out to eat very often at all. We don't live in a fancy house nor do we drive a fancy car. We don't shop at Banana Republic and we sure as heck don't go out very often either. But you know what? Our child is at home with his mother, being taught the values and morals that WE want him to be taught. He is not learning things from a stranger that gets paid $7 an hour to watch 20 - 30 children and could NEVER care for your child like you do. Want my opinion on daycare? I think that you are missing out on your child development. I think your child is suffering because he is not at home with his mom or dad in a loving invornment being taught greater things then ANY daycare could teach. There will be time for your child to go to school and that is around 5 years of age. Enjoy your child now while you can because you can't get those years back. And just to let you know, my hubby and I didn't plan on having kids. We didn't even want kids. So we didn't have time to prepare ourselves for having a child and losing an income. But we knew the second we found out we were pregnant that I would be staying at home with our son. I would sacrifice anything to be able to stay at home with my child.
• Canada
21 Feb 07
MMaybe I should have set the stage a little more realistically. He is not in daycare monday - friday from 9-5, I am in school so my schedule is all over the place. He is in daycare until 5 only 2 days, and out of those two days, he starts at 9 one day and 12 the next. All the childcare providers in my sons daycare are ECE certified. The daycare is set up like a classroom, only 4 children per teacher. Their meals are catered, they have regular scheduled outside playtime, structured learning, inside playtime, singing, games, etc. The reason I have decided to return to school is because I want to provide my son with a better life than what my Mother provided for me. I do not want to live without living. I like going out, I like taking my son places. I'm going to like taking him places that I never was able to go as a child. Some of you have said that his place is at home wih his mother, and I would agree with you if you were the kind of mother that could sit at home with them all day and teach them all the things that he is learning in the real world. I, personally do not have the resources or education to do that myself and I feel more comfortable having a trained professional do that for me. (definately not saying keeping them home is wrong, just not right for certain people)
1 person likes this
@shannon76 (1232)
• United States
22 Feb 07
I do understand what you are saying. Alot of my friends are stay at home moms and they also home school. Now that is where I will draw the line. Once he is of age, he's going to school, because like you, I don't think that I can teach him what he needs to know to get the best possible education. But as far as his development as an infant/toddler, I do think children are best with their parents. But you're right, staying at home with the kids is not for everyone. And before I had my son, I thought moms were crazy to stay at home with the kids. Infact, I thought I was going to go crazy too when I got pregnant and thought about staying at home - I had worked since I was 14 years old and then all the sudden at age 29, I am going to just stop the corprate world and be a homemaker??? Was weird at first but I love it. So I do understand where you are coming from and I still will stand by my opinion that kids are better off with the parents (at least before school age). But you know what you are cabable and that is great. God bless you and your family =)
• Australia
22 Feb 07
I understand your predicament. I have recently gone back to work and have my child in care 2 days a week. In an ideal world I would love to be able to stay home with her full time. I have gone back to work for financial reasons - my husband and I do not have extravagent spending habits, we do not own a plasma tv or other expensive "toys". We planned and saved hard to ensure that I would be able to spend the first year at home with our baby without having to struggle financially. However in order for us to move forward in life (for example get a bigger house to accomodate our growing family) I need to go back to work. Me staying at home would mean that we would just tread water, we would have to survive in a small 2 bed room apartment with no yard, no airdonditioning (I know this is more than what most people have but I want to be able to provide MORE for my child and future children). Although I struggle with the idea of my child in the hands of "strangers" the ladies that look after my little girl are fabulous. Apart from my girl crying when I leave her (this is the part I struggle with) she settles well and have a good happy day. sheenac1983 the fact that you are questioning yourself tells me that you are a good parent. It sounds like you are doing a great job and personally I would be concerned about your friend (how can she own a daycare centre and not believe in the service she is providing????) Trust your instincts and do what you think is right for your child. Good luck to you.
@CherylPH (32)
• United States
23 Feb 07
As a daycare teacher, I always tell my parents that I would rather the child be home with his/her parents. That would mean I would be out of a job, but that is my feeling on it. I love my job as a daycare, and I love my infants. If you need to have your child in daycare, find one that is certified with qualified teachers, which it seems you have already done and that is great. All daycare have a student/teaher ratio that is mandatory. For infant rooms 5:1, toddlers 6:1, two's 8:1, and 3-5 15:1. These ratios are very managable for most teachers. In our infant room we have 8 babies and 2 teachers and each child gets personal attention, and personal love. Daycare are highly regulated and if your child is having a great time with his class, then I would leave him there. Do not doubt your desicion unless you see something that is wrong with him, or with the center that you have placed him in. Voice your concerns with his teachers as well, they should be able to help you through your concerns.
• United States
19 Feb 07
Daycare is a much needed part of many lives. If you are in school preparing for a better life or have to work to help out with finances, what choices do you have? I think as long as you do a thorough check and get references, it can be a good and educational experience for a child. I ran an in-home daycare for many years and made sure the children had a good experience with lots of love and activities. Since I had taught pre-school and kindergarted in a private school, we also had some lesson time which I made sure was fun for the kids. I was there to help with homework so the kids would be free to spend quality time with parents upon their pickup. So the key here is not whether to put them in daycare, it is finding one that offers love and growth.