People Who Left American Idol Thursday Night 2-22-07

United States
February 23, 2007 1:47pm CST
What do you think about those people leaving? Amy Krebs Nicole Tranquillo Paul Kim Rudy Cardenas
3 responses
• United States
24 Feb 07
Amy and Nicole may have been forgettable, but Antonella and Alaina really butchered their songs. They were awful! I can't believe those two girls are still in the competition. Okay, so some ppl might consider them prettier, but they'd better sing a lot better next week or they're going home. (I hope I hope I hope.) Paul and Rudy needed to go. Rudy was on key but his voice is reedy and weak. No timbre. Paul needs to put some shoes on.
@leedug (921)
• United States
25 Feb 07
Antonella has the prettiness factor but that will only take her so far. There was a model that was eliminated in the top 24 last season because for 2 nights in a row, her performance was weak. Unless Antonella brings a better performance this week, she will be next. Poor Paul: I guess his bare feet didn't help him!
@usmcsgtwife (4999)
• United States
23 Feb 07
i think that Paul KIm left too ear;y I am not sure the kids name on there but the youngest one who's sister was there in Hollywood with him I thought he should of went home
• United States
23 Feb 07
Sanjaya Malakar his is name
@leedug (921)
• United States
24 Feb 07
Wow, I thought Sanjaya did GREAT! I thought the judges were way too harsh on him. As far as Paul Kim; I think he has a great voice but he totally butchered his song. I thought almost instantly that he would be one of the ones going home. The other guy Rudy, had an ok but forgettable performance ( I agree with Simon), and I think he just happened to get less votes than the others that just had average votes. The girls: I can't even remember them at all even though I watched the show, so yes, I think it was proper for them to go!