If you had to pick 5...

United States
March 14, 2007 12:13pm CST
former finalists to compete in a one night, winner-take-all event, who would you select? I think it would be an awesome idea to have a "best of" show where the best five, maybe even ten, former finalists come back, get one chance to perform, and the winner takes the title of "Best American Idol" contestant not to win. I'm making it five for me cause I don't want to go that far back, but you can add more if you like. The only requirement is that the singer you select must have been a finalist in their season and did not win. (runner-ups count.) my five are (in no order) 1.) Chris Daughtry (season 5) 2.) Clay Aiken (season 2) 3.) Tamyra Gray (season 1) 4.) Kimberly Locke (season 2) 5.) Jennifer Hudson (season 3) it was difficult for me to get to those conclusions: names I left out, but could be in a top 10 include: -George Huff(season 3), Paris Bennett(season 5), Josh Gracin (season 2), Diana DeGarmo (season 3), and Latoya London (season 3). Who would you pick?
1 person likes this
2 responses
@sunnypub (2130)
• United States
14 Mar 07
5 Idol hopefuls who I would love to see in a best of show, I have to think about that for a moment. Okay here is my list in no particualr order. Chris Daughtry (season 5) Constantine Maroulis (season 4) Bo Bice (season 4) Paris Bennet (season 5) John Peter Lewis (season 3) If I went on to include 10 I would include: Kelly Pickler (season 5) Clay Aiken (season 2) Diana Degarmo (season 3) George Guff (season 3) Tamyra Gray (season 1) What a terrific show that would be. I know we wouldn't be diapointed like we have been this year so far.
• United States
14 Mar 07
That would be awesome show. I might even be willing to include some of the top participants in this season if they don't make it, cause I really do like some of the top talent here. This show would be a great season in itself. I would love to see my favorite former Idol contestants together, for one night, just throw the gauntlet down. With each of them bringing their best competition, it would be great. And yah, I forgot about Bo Bice... he'd definitely get into my competition as well.
• Philippines
16 Mar 07
mine would look like this.. 1. katherine mdcphee 2. jennifer hudson 3. elliot yamin 4. vonzell solomon 5. paris bennett 6. tamyra gray 7. nikko smith 8. anwar robinson 9. george huff 10. chris daughtry