Crime of Passion

Philippines
March 19, 2007 9:05am CST
I read it on CNN that the first hearing of the husband of the teacher would be sometime in the last week of March. One attorney says this case was interesting and could be passed for a crime of passion. The husband shot dead the senior student who was allegedly carrying on an affair with his wife, who is also the teacher of the victim. Given this fact, is there any chance of the husband getting lesser penalty once he pleads guilty of the crime? I'm not big on the law and stuff but I have to know where all these unpleasantness will lead the suspect and the victim.
5 people like this
11 responses
@Kasssy (107)
• United States
20 Mar 07
I really don't think it matters what the reason was. Unless it is self defense I don't thiink one has the right to take another's life period. I couldn't see any reason to ever hurt anyone either. Everyone needs to learn how to walk away from these problems that make us so jealous and mad. I know anger takes over sometimes,but these are things we all need to work on. Nothing done to you is ever deserving of an act so malicios.
2 people like this
• United States
20 Mar 07
Crime of Passion constitutes a legal defense. It's possible that he could get lesser time.
1 person likes this
@Shaun72 (15959)
• Palatka, Florida
19 Mar 07
It proberly will give him less time. In a way you can't blame the husband. Although it would of been easier to kick her out or to tell her to leave if she was going to continue with her affair.
@gabs8513 (48686)
• United Kingdom
19 Mar 07
Goodness that is bad, I mean I know it hurts when something like that happens in a Marriage but to shoot someone for it that is terrible. Sorry but I think that Teacher will have to be punished for that, he took a Life and it was not a valid reason to shoot someone, Crime of Passion or not.
1 person likes this
@mzbubblie (3839)
• United States
20 Mar 07
It's very possible he will definetly be a suspect, however, there has to be thourough investigation to prove he had a part in it, also to prove that the student was having an affair with this teacher. It's very possible the husband found something or found out something and instead of talking to his wife was so furious he went after the kid. I can tell you with so many different stories I hear from the media and just day to day life, it wild what people will do for love...
1 person likes this
• Philippines
20 Mar 07
a great factor to be considered to properly answer your question is the definition of the crime with which the husband has been charged... next would be how mitigating circumstances are appreciated.. when and under what circumstances was the victim killed? was the teacher and her alleged lover-student caught in flagrante delicto (in the act of committing an unlawful deed) when they were shot by the husband? if that were so, as a lawyer, it could be argued that it was in self defense that the teacher was shot- a defense of the husband's honor. that would probably work especially if they would have a jury with guys thinking "yeah, i'm a man!"
@neglitex (347)
• Latvia
20 Mar 07
Husband is going to be jailed, no matter what, I don't understand these kind of people....This is madness how things get screwed up sometimes...
1 person likes this
• Philippines
20 Mar 07
I'm not privy with this case but if the defendant does plead guilty then he'll probably have a relatively lesser punishment in exchange for pleading guilty as oppose to losing in court where he'll face the full brunt of the law. If this is considered as a crime of passion though, I doubt that he'll plead guilty. I don't know much about U.S. law but crimes of passion is usually a mitigating factor in a case.
@Perry2007 (2229)
• Philippines
20 Mar 07
There are certain law on crime of passion. When the husband will be able to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the victim was having an affair with his wife, there is a posibility that he can be aquited. In our country if you have witnessed your spouse with another and killed them, you may be aquited.
• Philippines
19 Mar 07
the crime can only be mitigated if the suspect pleads guilty of the crime... although in the US, they have a jury system of court proceeding, still the same, a verdict of murder is likely to be given. murder is defined as the unlawful killing of any person which is not parricide or infanticide, provided that any of the following is present: 1. treachery; 2. with evident premeditation; 3. with cruelty. if these 3 qualifying circumstances can be proven beyond reasonable doubt by the jury, then a murder was committed.
• Philippines
20 Mar 07
the husband and the school where she teach can also sue her for immorality. as it is now, she is already considered as fugitive from justice. flight is admission of guilt. and thanks for the best response tag my friend...
@cdparazo (5765)
• Philippines
19 Mar 07
Since it's just speculation and there is no proof that they really are carrying an affair, then I could say that it MAY NOT be considered as crime of passion. Crime of passion only becomes that when one becomes overwhelmed with emotions and is blinded by rage and jealously beyond rationality such as catching ones partner in the act of commiting such crime. If the situation under consideration actually allows the suspect some time to consider and think of his actions without witnessing incriminating behaviors, then I think it's more a murder than crime of passion.
@xu530923 (28)
• China
20 Mar 07
To criminate sb,the motivation and the infection are the two important parts,I mean just in China's law.In this case,the husband,as a murdre,killed the senior student.We can make it as a retorsion.Follow this opinnion,you will find that ,it's impossable to reduse his crime.If not ,we are giving a wrong signal that we are encourage peaple to make retaliate.That my thought ,as a human without proffesional law knownleadge.