Do you compare the quality of your discussions to others on my lot?

@vega83 (6342)
Bahrain
April 9, 2007 7:14am CST
Have you ever done that? When I first started out at my lot, I used to just start a discussion by asking a really brief question, and not really get into any details. Then after I made lots of friends here, I realized that the discussions I most liked to respond to were the ones that started off by an interesting story or that was truly a discussion, as in a person relating their views on something and then getting a reaction on that, instead of just a question. And I have adopted that way of starting a discussion, and I must say it shows a difference in the responses I get, now I know which people have actually gone through the whole topic or just read the discussion subject and tried to get away with a quick answer, he he, so it can also work as a good trap. But, truthfully speaking I have been comparing my discussions to others and I try to make mine better each time by learning something new from each. This has made my discussions more interesting, at least to me. So, do you do that, compare your discussions to others and take tips from the good ones?
6 people like this
14 responses
@brokentia (10389)
• United States
9 Apr 07
I think it is good that you are learning from looking at others discussions. I guess to me that would not really be comparing...but rather looking to see what works by examples. I also did not get what received good responses in the beginning either. By the way of my developing friends, helped me to figure out the way to give good detail to be able to make meaningful discussions. I am not very fond of short answers....so I hope that my length of discussion detail encourages others to give more than one line responses. :)
1 person likes this
@vega83 (6342)
• Bahrain
10 Apr 07
Yeah, you got what I meant exactly. It's not comparing in a vain way, it's just a way of learning from others. I too started off by just asking a question and not really elaborating on what I really wanted to know, the longer and more descriptive my discussions are, the longer and more descriptive responses I get on them. And I love lengthy discussions myself, but even short discussions can sometimes be really meaningful too.
@vega83 (6342)
• Bahrain
10 Apr 07
yeah, whatever we've all learned shows in how our discussions have improved and I must say most of them have.
@Tsferrets (421)
• United States
10 Apr 07
I wouldn't say that I compare mine to anyone elses way of writing but I do try to make awole discussion where people can either relate and respond or voice their point of view compared to everyone elses. I don't think its really worth while to just ask a question and then not add something about it yourself. I usually won't even respond to those. This is suppose to be discusions not Q&A. How can you really have a discussion if everyone only answer in mono. I like to read your view/topic and then discuss mine. Thats what I think is interesting and fun. Its a way for us to relate and share alittle about ourselves with each other. Its hard for me to talk to strangers that I can't relate too. But I love meeting new people from all walks of life and cultures. That I find really worth my time. Good discussion. You have a great day. And I do look for your discussions when I'm trying to find something to respond to. Good Work. Keep it up!! Tammy
1 person likes this
@vega83 (6342)
• Bahrain
10 Apr 07
Thanks for that, I do totally agree with you on a two sided discussion, it needs to be an ongoing thing and feedback from the person who started it is so very important, not just in making comments but also when we ask a general question to somebody the first answer should be from the person who asks the question. That makes the discussion more personable and also not just interrogation of other people. I try to incorporate that in most discussions I start, first give my point of view, then ask for other's opinions on it.
• Australia
10 Apr 07
No I don't compare the quality of other people's discussions with mine or anyone else's, but I find I gravitate to the same type of discussions. I prefer to be involved with "meaty" discussions which require a bit of thought and quite often have on-going threads with interchange of ideas. As long as everything is debated with courtesy and respect, it is very refreshing to hear different points of views discussed openly and intelligently. The other type of discussion I enjoy is one involving a number of friends, where an "interesting" but not very deep discussion is continued with humour and interaction. Then there are the warm and friendly "fuzzy" ones which special friends put up and we delight to participate in because they are such delightful people. Admittedly the "meaty" discussions are getting harder to find, but they are still around. While looking for those, we often come across an "everyday" variety to which we can give a reasonable input. No matter what the personal taste or preference, myLot seems to cater for all tastes, so everyone should be able to find something to suit. As for me, I'm just the same in any type of discussion.
@vega83 (6342)
• Bahrain
10 Apr 07
yeah, well i love those meaty discussions you're talking about, especially if one of those discussions is something that you've yourself started, even if there are just a few responders but active ones who keep conversing back an forth, it's really satisfying.
1 person likes this
@vanities (11395)
• Davao, Philippines
10 Apr 07
nope i dont compare one i just made it on my own and at least my own words..its good to compare also so that there will be a room for improvement for everything..
@vega83 (6342)
• Bahrain
10 Apr 07
yeah, of course I make my own discussions too and never copy anything and always use my own words but take tips every now and then on the type and style of discussing, not on the topics itself.
@aissha (2036)
• India
10 Apr 07
yeah i also started the same and i was not very regular also ,gradually i noticed and then i really got into it ,now also my discussions are not long i mean they are brief only still i try to pick up some catchy discussions and this has worked.no. of responses has increased.
1 person likes this
@vega83 (6342)
• Bahrain
10 Apr 07
Yeah, that's the right way, we all try to pick up ways along the way to make our discussions better, and it's always nice to keep improving ourselves.
@wildhorse (1293)
• Egypt
10 Apr 07
yes your discussions are interesting :) I still like to also respond to some of the easy question-like discussions to gather more points but I prefer serious and intelligent discussions, I always try to learn from others and others mistakes, it seems that if you have good friends they will respond to your good discussions, other friends will only respond to easy discussions and will not waste time reading and writing something more complicated than 2 lines.. What i try now is to make my discussions good but still not too long, I think many people take a look at a long text and respond with anything or they just decide not to respond and search for something easier.
@vega83 (6342)
• Bahrain
10 Apr 07
well, the people who are interested in your discussion and are actually interested in 'discussing' stuff don't really care how long a discussion is, and they'll read everything before they answer, and that's usually what I aim for, to filter all those one-liners and get the good ones, so I usually have a bit of text which might also sometimes stray away from the original topic, and you will easily get to know which ones have read the whole thing then, and which ones are just title readers and are just looking for number of responses they wanna add next to their name.
• United States
9 Apr 07
For me it depends on the topic and/or question. Some just have a simple one liner that get a ton of responses because everyone can relate or it spikes some type of interest. However, I've also liked to read discussions about something that have a question at the end. So it just depends on my mood basically. The ones I really don't tend to respond to are when they are about a page long, to me that's a blog and I'll read that in the blog section.
@vega83 (6342)
• Bahrain
10 Apr 07
Hmmm.... are you talking about comparing your discussions or about how you choose which discussions to respond to? And what if a page long discussion has to be started because there is a lot to share before expecting an answer, I'm sure I've started off many discussions with a lengthy explanation.
@lilaclady (28207)
• Australia
9 Apr 07
I don't compare my discussions to others, but I find myself learning how ro respond in a better way rather than just giving a direct answer, I think doing this sort of thing does teach you write as you speak almost...if that sounds sensible....
@vega83 (6342)
• Bahrain
10 Apr 07
Yeah, being on my lot has improved my writing skills and even the way I start out a new discussion. I too, take great tips and incorporate them into my discussions, and this way I can see the improvement and how far I've come along since I first started here.
@lpetges (3036)
• United States
9 Apr 07
i don't really compare,. i just read the discussions that im interested in, and go from there. i dont' like the jokes, or the recipe discussions, i could go elsewhere to find those. i only respond to the things that will matter to me.
1 person likes this
@vega83 (6342)
• Bahrain
10 Apr 07
ok, honest mistake, never mind.
@lpetges (3036)
• United States
9 Apr 07
i don't really compare,. i just read the discussions that im interested in, and go from there. i dont' like the jokes, or the recipe discussions, i could go elsewhere to find those. i only respond to the things that will matter to me.
1 person likes this
@vega83 (6342)
• Bahrain
10 Apr 07
Well, that's great but what i meant was if you see the quality of your discussions against others and then sort of have a healthy self-started competition to come up with even more better quality.
@subha12 (18441)
• India
10 Apr 07
yaa i do. but not always. I do it sometimes. I also reply to those discussions that attracts me. Not all. also look for discussions my friend's started. I reply some of them if I found them ok.
@vega83 (6342)
• Bahrain
10 Apr 07
Ok, so you do sometimes compare or do you not? Is that what you meant?
@hoghoney (3747)
• United States
10 Apr 07
no not really I just kind of use what ever pops into my head at the time and then I try to make it this best that I can. I also try not to do something that someone else done so that I am not doing the same thing as them.
1 person likes this
@vega83 (6342)
• Bahrain
10 Apr 07
oh, no no, of course not. I didn't mean 'copying' when I said comparing. What I meant was like before, when I started a discussion I used to keep it short because I thought no one would wanna read so much. But then I realized that the longer discussions got better responses as there was more to elaborate on, so then I got over my fear of lengthy discussions and would write as much as it would take to get my point across, without any restrictions.
• Canada
9 Apr 07
I always compare the differences in different discussions to my own and try to see areas where I can make mine better. Different people have different ways of wording things and if I see something that I like, or makes the discussion better, I try to remember it so I can incorporate it into my next discussion. I think that no matter how good we think we are at discussions, there's always room for improvement. I'm not striving for perfection, because I don't think there is anything such as perfection, but I at least want to be the best I can be in order to spark interest in other people.
@vega83 (6342)
• Bahrain
10 Apr 07
yeah, that's great, there's always room for improvement. Like, one of the things that I incorporated in my discussions is the topic, it doesn't always have to be a question but can sometimes just be statement, or any thing for that matter, it's the content that counts.
• Singapore
9 Apr 07
I have been doing that. When I see what others post, I would see what additional values in their post which I do not have. What I usually see is that when people with good ratings would post very quality stuffs, you can see that they put their heart and soul on it. The first few days I joined mylot, I did not give really detailed views. But as I participate in more discussions, I found that I improved a lot through comparing with other people's views. I also have seen people who gave views which are lacking of quality. I can tell that they are just trying to reply as much as possible and their main purpose is making money. I found out that if we are diligent in giving our views, we should not have problem with having brief details in our views.
1 person likes this
@vega83 (6342)
• Bahrain
10 Apr 07
absolutely agree with you on all points there, especially about the people, who put their heart and soul in their discussion, you really can tell that they've carefully read and pondered and then responded and not just cruising and typing out a few words that are remotely close to the topic of discussion, in fact I've noticed some responses where you can actually tell if a person has read the whole thing or just the first line and then responded.