troy or 300????????????????

i go for 300 as 300 is an absolutely terrific movie. the attitude, the valour the spartans display send a chill down my spine. so much to keep their honour. they challenged and even demured a person who projected himself as god. i think they were bogged down by the wrong priests who just had no respect for these warriors. my personal favorite line in the movie when the king says : SPARTANS NEVER RETREAT!!!!!!!!!!. the greatest sequence when the king as a young lad fights the beast and also , when he kicks the intruder into the well..

300 for the awesome fight scenes! Troy for the actresses, actors and storyline.

Troy was great but not good enough to beat 300. Ithink 300 is some kinda legendava movie..

300 and king leonardus, never really liked troy and brad pitt :) the movie 300 is good and its very unique. I commend the director for its attack in terms of cinematography is excitingand superb

i like troy much better, maybe bec the epic was famous (plus im a big epic lover)and the cinematography is very detailed.

If compared for their skills, i'll go for Achilles. But for bravery and honour it's definitely King Leonidas.

I like achilles more :D

hey i didn't like the 300 concept...its too fictitious but i really like the troy movie ...so may vote is for TROY

for the bods, i love them both... on the story, ive read of troy than about 300... i know the story of troy well so i love it more than 300... ;)

troy was much better movie than 300.and the character of achillies was more attractive then the king leonardaus.

Hmm.. i don't like the settings of 300 movie.. I think it is so dark and surealism... So i vote Troy is better than 300. And Achilles more powerfull than Leonidas

both of them are sexy.both are must watch.gives you a good knowledge of history as well as the fighting techniques during earlier times

I feel Troy was way better than 300 in all aspects. Although Troy was helped by a great historical story, the way the story was picturised was awesome. And i also feel that Brad Pitt's character was superbly portrayed, the kind of portrayal that would not have suited any other actor. Also his acting was great. 300 had great graphics but it was more like an animation movie rather than a real movie. The story seemed far away from reality, the picturisation made it even farther. Overall i would give 5/5 to Troy and around 3.5/5. Hence Troy is the comfortable winner among the two movies.

I prefer Troy than 300 but prefer Gladiator than Troy. I find Troy to have more human drama than 300 whose main saving grace is its remarkable, gigantic and well executed fight scenes. It has the element of good drama too but is drowned by too much emphasis given to the fight scenes. It is not the movie's fault of course. It's plot made sure that the fight scens to be staged should overwhelm the viewers and it succeeded enormously.