sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

good cop/bad cop roles in disciplining a child  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 96/100. ctv101103 (624)   ranked 435 out of 9,011 in parenting 5 years ago

I understand that most parents play "good cop, bad cop" roles when disciplining their children. Couples does not necessarily assign roles to each other. They just take on whichever role as they see fit for a certain situation/scenario. But what do you do if your spouse/partner always assumes the "good cop" role, leaving you to always be the "bad cop"?

You see, when it comes to disciplining our daughter, I am more of the disciplinarian between my husband and I. But whenever I say 'NO' to something our daughter wants (for example, when it's already bedtime and she insists on playing or watching tv), it's my husband who easily gives in. So now, since my daughter knows that she can easily get what she wants through her dad, she always seeks him when I disagree with her. I always end up being the "bad cop". How do I deal with this?

 

parenting
sponsors
Online Psychology Degree
Earn a Psychology Degree Online at American Public University. Enroll.
www.apus.edu/psychology

Child Development Degree
Earn your Child Development Associate Certificate at home.
www.PennFoster.edu

Ask a Lawyer Online Now
18 Lawyers Are Online. A Lawyer Will Answer You Now.
Law.JustAnswer.com

charms88 (4635) response was accepted on 4/23/2007.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  discipline, child, disciplinarian, disciplining a child, good cop/bad cop
 
1. myLot reputation of 90/100. Married2aMarine (951)   ranked 64 out of 9,011 in parenting   5 years ago

Hubby and I already agreed before we had kids that we're not going to play the good cop/bad cop role. We feel that it's confusing for the child. We decided that it's going to be a shared responsibility and we're going to agree on what the limits are going to be, how to discipline, etc. Now, we have a 2 year old and we try our best to do everything the same. I think consistency is key. Children need to see and know that Mom and Dad are in agreement. As a result, I hardly get any protest from him cos' he knows he cannot just run to one parent and get away with stuff. I think your husband and you need to sit down and talk about what the boundaries are going to be for your child and how you are going to handle it together.


myLot reputation of 96/100. ctv101103 (624)   ranked 435 out of 9,011 in parenting  5 years ago

yes, i think we should have a talk about this. thank you for your advice :)

Online Psychology Degree Earn a Psychology Degree Online at American Public University. Enroll.  www.apus.edu/psychology
 
2. myLot reputation of 98/100. charms88 (4635)   ranked 496 out of 9,011 in parenting   5 years ago

You should talk with your husband and be straight with him about your role as a disciplinarian. It can be quite tedious for you if things will not turn out the way it should be. Inform your husband that he should be firm with your daughter too. Giving in for the sake of lessening the tantrum is certainly not a good way to teach your daughter. I hope your husband will support you in this aspect. Good luck.


myLot reputation of 96/100. ctv101103 (624)   ranked 435 out of 9,011 in parenting  5 years ago

hi charms! thanks for the advice. you're right, i think i need to talk with my husband. thanks again!

Child Development Degree Earn your Child Development Associate Certificate at home.  www.PennFoster.edu
 
sponsors
How To Stop Bad Behaviors
How I stopped the defiance, lying, backtalk and outbursts in 3 steps.
www.Democratic-Parenting.com

Owed Child Support?
We Help Frustrated Parents Collect The Child Support They're Due.
www.SupportCollectors.com

Child Educator MA Degree
Make Positive Impact on Kids' Lives w/ a Master's in Child Development
EducationDegreeSource.com/Online_MA

similar discussions
time out on children... face the wall
we parents have different styles of teaching our children disipline and telling them to behave. in...
Are you able to manage your time effectively?
The most challenging part of being self-employed is that you have to manage your time effectively....
Counting before discipline?
I know many parents who tell their children if they don't behave that they are going to discipline...
Do you think that schools protect the young generation too much?
It is a known fact that every action has two different outcomes: Positive and Negative--despite...
sponsors
How To Stop Bad Behaviors
How I stopped the defiance, lying, backtalk and outbursts in 3 steps.
www.Democratic-Parenting.com
Owed Child Support?
We Help Frustrated Parents Collect The Child Support They're Due.
www.SupportCollectors.com
Child Educator MA Degree
Make Positive Impact on Kids' Lives w/ a Master's in Child Development
EducationDegreeSource.com/Online_MA
Child Development
Looking For Child Development? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.