sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

Lucas/Brooke OR Lucas/Peyton email this discussion to a friend?

misskatex (23)   ranked 129 out of 130 in one tree hill3 years ago

Which do you like better Lucas/Brooke or Lucas/Peyton?

I like Lucas and Brooke better! For some reason Lucas and Peyton just annoys me. Their moments are not bittersweet like Brooke and Lucas!

 
 
one tree hill
sponsors
Gillette® Anti-Perspirant
Learn About The Causes And Solutions To Excessive Sweating.
Gillette.com/ClinicalStrength

If You Luv One Tree Hill
You'll luv Secret Life. See the new show Jan 4 on ABC Family at 8/7c
www.ABCFamily.go.com

Carfax Vehicle History - Official Site
Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get a CARFAX Report before you buy.
www.Carfax.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  one tree hill, lucas, brooke, peyton, couple
 
1. myLot reputation of 91/100. rodeotexas (1055)   3 years ago

I love Brooke and Lucas together. I just don't like Lucas and Peyton but I do like Peyton and Jake. He needs to come around more again.

Gillette® Anti-Perspirant Learn About The Causes And Solutions To Excessive Sweating. Gillette.com/ClinicalStrength
 
2. myLot reputation of 96/100. KrisNY (7347)   ranked 25 out of 130 in one tree hill   3 years ago

I think they wanted to stick with Lucas and Brooke- but their off air (Real life) marriage and then divorce in a matter of months put that sour. They didn't want to work together as much- didn't want to be kissing etc. I prefered them together also- But I do like to see Brooke being a sleeze and the way the show portrays her now. Livened it up a bit- Can't wait to see the new show soon and see what happens to Peyton- I'm sure Lucas will save her again-- But it looks pretty good.


padmeamidala (4)   ranked 72 out of 130 in one tree hill  3 years ago

as I said Kate...what's the name of their cardset at Tric? EMO NATION.

they don't fit together at all. in the beginning? Sure but as they show evolved and they both grew as characters? No they just dont fit now. I agree that the whole real life thing between sophia and chad screwed the chemistry up. But if they were good actors? They could have made it work. I dont see them being jerks and saying "Well i'm gonna make this hard on you because he/she cheated on me and broke our marriage up" It was moreso the stupid writers work probably. Btw writerS? YOU SUCK.*mumbles*

If You Luv One Tree Hill You'll luv Secret Life. See the new show Jan 4 on ABC Family at 8/7c www.ABCFamily.go.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 95/100. speedy1279 (1490)   ranked 2 out of 130 in one tree hill   3 years ago

Um, that is a hard decision for me because I think Lucas has different qualities that fit with both Brooke and Peyton. Can't wait for the new shows to start up again. I believe they start on Wed. YEAH!!!

Carfax Vehicle History - Official Site Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get a CARFAX Report before you buy. www.Carfax.com
 
4. shihtzulover (14)   3 years ago

I prefer the Lucas/Brooke loveteam. But I do pity Peyton's character coz she seems to be so luckless in love. Always being left behind. I like Brooke's character better coz she's a strong-headed woman,definitely not a pushover.

DC's Condo Specialist Rachel Valentino, your Washington, DC real estate professional agent. Proven aptitude combined with a powerful work ethic. www.rachelvalentino.com
 
5. missrocksteady (30)   3 years ago

I like Lucas and Peyton together! (I seem to be the minority here, though!) For some reason I feel like someone else has to come along who "clicks" better with Brooke.


Eve_888 (14)   ranked 119 out of 130 in one tree hill  3 years ago

You are not the only one sweetie, I also like to see peyton and lucas end up together... I think a good love story should start from the beginning lighly, probably start as friends and eventually grow (and/or gets more complicated )as the story progresses. The very reason you wanted to see more from this pair.

Cooksillustrated.com Official Site – Get all 17 years of Recipes That Work® - Try it Free. www.CooksIllustrated.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 95/100. lafavorito (2493)   ranked 10 out of 130 in one tree hill   3 years ago

I like Lucas and Peyton better because both of them are in touch with their own emotions, Lucas is a writer while Peyton is an artist, a perfect match.


Lucas and Peyton
2 Rules For A Ripped Body I Got Ripped In 4 Weeks Obeying These 2 Simple Rules. SixPackAbsGuide.com
 
7. partnersincrime (6)   3 years ago

i liked brooke and lucas together. i think that the way they are so different makes the blend of their personalities even better and amusing to watch. with peyton and lucas, who are both deep, quiet brooders, it would not be quite as amusing.

but i guess their offscreen situation makes the shift in couples understandable.

still, brooke and lucas forever.:)

The Quality of Life Group Looking For The Quality of Life Group In Your Area. Call Now. TheQualityOfLifeGroup.Local.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 94/100. joimarquez (1289)   ranked 75 out of 130 in one tree hill   3 years ago

i like lucas and brooke. peyton has alot of issues that she needs to deal with.

Marié Digby - Music from One Tree Hill Her songs have been featured on the show. Check out her new album now. MarieDigby.amazon.com
 
9. meighlee (21)   3 years ago

I like Lucas and Peyton better. Brooke has the tendecy to become a little bitchy just to get people's attention. Yeah Peyton may not have a good start to thinn that she is snatching somebody elses boyfriend, worst her bestfriend's BF. But admit it I think Peyton is more real than Brooke.

Property for Sale in Lucas County Detailed descriptions of Realtors, homes and property for sale in the Lucas County and surrounding areas. This website offers all styles and price ranges. www.toledohomesellers.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 85/100. Melissa528 (503)   ranked 54 out of 130 in one tree hill   3 years ago

I guess i'm in the minority to because I prefer Lucas and Peyton. I don't know why. I think they look cute together and have much more in common. Brooke is a wild child. A little too wild for Lucas.

Washington DC Banks Find Washington DC Banks Today - Great APY and High Savings Rates. Banks.YellowPages.com/DC
 
sponsors
DC's Condo Specialist
Rachel Valentino, your Washington, DC real estate professional agent. Proven aptitude combined with a powerful work ethic.
www.rachelvalentino.com

Cooksillustrated.com
Official Site – Get all 17 years of Recipes That Work® - Try it Free.
www.CooksIllustrated.com

2 Rules For A Ripped Body
I Got Ripped In 4 Weeks Obeying These 2 Simple Rules.
SixPackAbsGuide.com

similar discussions
Where do you get your OTH spoilers from?
I get mine from YouTube videos or http://onetreehillblog.com
How do you feel about Antwon/Skills leaving?
How do you feel about him leaving? I am kind of sad about it, but I know what has to be done has to...
Do you think Peyton on One Tree Hill will live?
Well...do you think she will survive the pregnancy?
Would you buy Brooke's clothes?
Do you like her fashion line? Would you buy it if you could?
Anyone boycotting One Tree Hill
Has anyone boycotted watching one tree hill since Lucas and Peyton are now off the show. I realized...
It's official!
I just read this article. I am very disappointed. I am not sure if I want to watch next year...
Favorite Chad Michael Murray Character
I've only seen him in One Tree Hill and in the movie House of Wax. I love his role in One Tree...
What makes you love One Tree Hill?
What is is that makes you crazy for One Tree Hill? I personally love the show. Every Monday night...
Any One Tree Hill fans out there?
Whats your favorite charecter? episode? moments?
One Tree Hill, Gossip Girl Do you watch these shows
Ok so tonight is one of my fav tv nights of the whole week it has One Tree Hill, and Gossip Girl...
sponsors
DC's Condo Specialist
Rachel Valentino, your Washington, DC real estate professional agent. Proven aptitude combined with a powerful work ethic.
www.rachelvalentino.com
Cooksillustrated.com
Official Site – Get all 17 years of Recipes That Work® - Try it Free.
www.CooksIllustrated.com
2 Rules For A Ripped Body
I Got Ripped In 4 Weeks Obeying These 2 Simple Rules.
SixPackAbsGuide.com
The Quality of Life Group
Looking For The Quality of Life Group In Your Area. Call Now.
TheQualityOfLifeGroup.Local.com
Marié Digby - Music from One Tree Hill
Her songs have been featured on the show. Check out her new album now.
MarieDigby.amazon.com
Property for Sale in Lucas County
Detailed descriptions of Realtors, homes and property for sale in the Lucas County and surrounding areas. This website offers all styles and price ranges.
www.toledohomesellers.com
Washington DC Banks
Find Washington DC Banks Today - Great APY and High Savings Rates.
Banks.YellowPages.com/DC
Mel Brooks' New Musical
Don't miss Young Frankenstein at the Opera House. Get tickets here.
Kennedy-Center.org
Compare to Hawaii Bridal
Store Prices. 20-30% Sale on Select Dresses. Guaranteed delivery dates.
www.BestBridalPrices.com
One Tree Hill Quotes
All One Tree Hill Quotes & Sayings. Largest Quote Site On The Net.
The-Quote-Site.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.