sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

in your aquariums, do you prefer Tropical or Saltwater fish?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 93/100. 66jerseygirl (1960) 5 years ago

I love tropical fish.I have always had freshwater and bettas. Freshwater seems so much easier to keep than saltwater. I was looking at a fish catalog I have and it looks like it would be complicated to have a saltwater aquarium.What do you think?


freshwater fishies
 

sponsors
Eimco type Products
National Filter Media (NFM) is experienced at filters& parts
nfm-filter.com

Kashi®: Get Protein
Add Protein& Fiber to Your Diet. Get Nutrition Info on Kashi® Foods!
www.kashi.com

Seafood Restaurants
Seafood Restaurants in Your Area
yellowpages.com

CritterKeeper (325) response was accepted on 5/14/2007.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  aquariums, fish, tanks, tropical fish
 
1. myLot reputation of 98/100. tinamwhite (1966)   5 years ago

While I love the bright colors of the saltwater fish....I do not have any at this time....it is a lot of work to maintain. We do have a frshwater tank...it holds my sons fish and he take care of them each day...every month we vacuum the gravel to maintain a clean tank...he makes a huge mess usually, but he is 5...so that is expected...we always do this together and we benefit from the closeness of spending this time together.

I think that it is important that a child, if they have pets, take care of these pets and the parent should be helping them figure out how to best work this into their daily routine......


myLot reputation of 93/100. 66jerseygirl (1960)  5 years ago

I agree with you. Kids need the responsibility of caring for pets. I am so glad that you have your son take care of them. I really hate it when people get fish and don't care for them. Right now ,I just have betta fish but i want to get several aquariums when we get back home.What kind of fishies does your son have? I used to have platies,male guppies,black mollies ,neon tetras,and the zebras.


myLot reputation of 98/100. tinamwhite (1966)  5 years ago

He has a black finned shark, a red tailed shark (both are less than 3" in length), a black molly, a silver angelfish, and a placostamus(misspelled, sorry).

We have natural plants which we grew from seeds in his tank.

He also has a "teddy bear" hamster which he provides care for daily.

He also, goes out most days and helps either me or his dad provide care for the 2 black labs, 2 horses, chickens, and guineas. I think it is vital to teach him the importance of providing daily care for our animals.

I have seen several pets throughout my life which we not taken care of...I simply do not understand a person who will own an animal...and not take care of them....of course, there are some people who do not take very good care of the people in their lives either!


myLot reputation of 93/100. 66jerseygirl (1960)  5 years ago

I have never had any sharks. I knew what you meant about the placto I call them. Does your mollies attack the other fish? I had a problem with one of mine constantly nipping the others fins.


myLot reputation of 98/100. tinamwhite (1966)  5 years ago

No, I have not had this problem..since we only have the more warm-blodded, aggressive fish.....I do not think our molly would dare take on the other fish in his tank...they all seem to get along quite well.

I have seen other fish tanks where the fish had partial fins because of this type of behavior....but luckily we have not had this occur in our tanks.

Eimco type Products National Filter Media (NFM) is experienced at filters & parts  nfm-filter.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 99/100. Trace86 (3618)   5 years ago

I have an aquarium of tropical fish. I think the saltwater tanks too much knowledge and skill to keep the salt balance just right.
I have several pineapple tetras, two platys and a cory. I had more, but a bad bout of ich depleted my tank. I want to get some more fish, but want to be sure the ones I have are healthy first.


myLot reputation of 93/100. 66jerseygirl (1960)  5 years ago

I love tetras but have never heard of pineapple tetras. What do they look like? I had two platies-red swag moon or something like that. I also had a cory. Two in fact,Fred and Barney

Kashi®: Get Protein Add Protein & Fiber to Your Diet. Get Nutrition Info on Kashi® Foods!  www.kashi.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 89/100. CritterKeeper (325)   5 years ago

Awww don't give up on the idea of a saltwater tank! It sounds like you're one of the people that would actually do it properly and be a great fellow hobbyist! Yes, I have a 130 gallon saltwater reef tank, worked as a fish specialist for a local store, and have taught many people how to successfully keep saltwater fish! If you go to www.saltwaterfish.com they have a message board with some really knowledgable and friendly people who would help you figure it all out too.
Really the main bad difference between a freshwater tank and a saltwater tank is the cost. The fish are more expensive, must be chosen as carefully if not moreso for compatibility/water requirements/etc., and some of the equipment is much more expensive depending on what you get. The maintenance is essentially the very same! Do a partial water change at least once a month with a gravel vaccume. The only difference is you add the salt to the water and use a hydrometer or other device for measuring the salinity. Hydrometers are actually very simple to use! You just fill it with water, tap out any air bubbles, then read where the pointer is pointing. Add salt if the salinity is not high enough, fresh water if it's too high, simple!
For beginners I heartily recommend a 40 gallon or more (realizing that the bigger you get the more expensive it will be in the end) FOWLR tank (fish only with live rock) and some of the tougher, smaller varieties of fish. Live rock is attractive and extremely beneficial! It gives a more natural look to the tank which is pretty and homey for the fish, it houses beneficial bacteria essential to the nitrogen cycle so acts as a biofilter, and introduces various organisms into the tank like "pods" (teeny little crustaceans which are a natural food source for the fish) and, if you're lucky fun creatures like feather dusters! There's a variety of beautiful fish that would be appropriate for this size aqaurium too like clownfish, damsels, royal gramma, many gobies and blennies, etc.
You use the exact same kind of heaters in saltwater as fresh, the same kind of florescent lighting if you stick with fish only, and you can use the same kind of filtration. Many saltwater enthusiasts get into some pretty complex filtration and I don't recommend a undergravel filter with these but for a smaller tank a biowheel power filter would be a fine one to use, just as one example. Cannister filters are another filter that might be familiar to you and can be used in saltwater. Many people recommend using a protein skimmer along with your filter which freshwater hobbyists might not be so familiar with but it's effective and as easy to set up and use as any filter! The substrate is the last difference. You can't use freshwater gravel and instead use crushed coral or marine sand.
Saltwater tanks really only get the most expensive and touchy to maintain when you add creatures like starfish, anemones, corals, and the like. These animals have more stringent requirements! Most of them require very pristine water conditions requiring more partial water changes and/or multiple filters/more complex filters. Many of them are also photosynthetic like plants and to survive must have upgraded, more complex, more expensive lighting such as actinics, metal halides, etc.
I really adore keeping fish and helping others be successful in the hobby! If you'd like to try saltwater please visit the message board I mentioned earlier and/or don't hesitate to contact me!! I'd LOVE to help!

related resource:
air filtration


myLot reputation of 93/100. 66jerseygirl (1960)  5 years ago

I haven't completely ruled out saltwater fish. It's just that it seems to be so much more work plus expensive. When we move back home i plan on getting a lot of fish. I know i will get some freshwater but if I do get saltwater,i will probably need your help

Seafood Restaurants Seafood Restaurants in Your Area  yellowpages.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 16/100. Sacrificialclam (4461)   5 years ago

I would LOVE to have a salt water tank. But the start up costs are so expensive. They are so pretty to look at though.

My sister has one where she works right across the hall from her desk. Lucky her. I get to stare at a bamboo plant on my desk.


myLot reputation of 93/100. 66jerseygirl (1960)  5 years ago

I hear ya.I would love to have a saltwater tank but it seems so expensive and more work. I do plan on getting a lot of fish when i go back home to hersey and maybe i will see if I can swing some freshwater and saltwater. I'm not sure

Weathervane Seafoods Maine Lobster - Seafood - Chicken- Clambakes - Fresh Catch- Cocktails.  www.weathervaneseafoods.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 99/100. kgwat70 (10233)   5 years ago

If I did have an aquarium it would not matter what type of fish that I had in there. I think all fish are beautiful though I know that they all do not get along with each other. My neighbor and friend has several aquariums. I am not sure if they are tropical or saltwater but they are nice to look at and they get along great.


myLot reputation of 93/100. 66jerseygirl (1960)  5 years ago

Hi,K! You really should consider getting a fish tank.They are so relaxing when you are stressed out. I cant wait til i get home so I can get some more fishies.

Local Coupons 1 ridiculously huge coupon a day. Get 50-90% off your city's best!  www.Groupon.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 81/100. copperkitten (2086)   5 years ago

Both are Beautiful. And yes a tropical tank is easier. A salt water tank isnt that hard its just more expencive for everything and fish.


myLot reputation of 93/100. 66jerseygirl (1960)  5 years ago

I wouldn't mind the extra work so much as the expense. Maybe one day when I move back home i may be able to afford one but until then i'll be content with my tropical.


myLot reputation of 81/100. copperkitten (2086)  5 years ago

Ya once the kids are older id like to get one. Im just afraid after all the cash spent they might nock it over! That would suck!!


myLot reputation of 93/100. 66jerseygirl (1960)  5 years ago

Suck isn't the word,especially with the prices of some of the saltwater fish i have seen.Wow?

Blue Bank Resort Stay where Bill Dance Kevin VanDam & the rest of the pros stay.  www.bluebankresort.com
 
sponsors
Weathervane Seafoods
Maine Lobster - Seafood - Chicken- Clambakes - Fresh Catch- Cocktails.
www.weathervaneseafoods.com

Local Coupons
1 ridiculously huge coupon a day. Get 50-90% off your city's best!
www.Groupon.com

Blue Bank Resort
Stay where Bill Dance Kevin VanDam& the rest of the pros stay.
www.bluebankresort.com

similar discussions
Does anyone know what the name of these animals are?
I am going to be setting up a fish room to breed fish and inverts. I am going to be looking for an...
How many people lost fish during this early snow storm?
During this early snow storm that nocked down many trees and power lines, I was with out power for...
This is torture
It was my little brother's birthday, so i came home to buy him a special gift...A very big, and...
Dolphins as house pets.
If you have a large yard and a water source, what's so bad about having a friendly dolphin as a...
what do you think of marine aquariums?
personally i love marine aquariums - you can see the whole world in a small glass box in the...
How to breed flowerhorn?
i have flowerhorn ....one with long head that's oroginal breed otherr is different breed...when i...
What is the most unusual animal that you ave had living in your aquarium?
Right now I have a couple of self cloning crawfish which means that there are no males of this...
Golfish feeder fish
Hi, I have a 30 gallon tank with 6 jack Dempsey in it. and if you know your fish, you know JD's are...
My fish
Do you raise fish ever or right now?Share you opinon about this stuff!
Why are my aquarium fish dying one after the other?
I have 1 big aquarium i had 2 black skirt tetra's, one pelco, one snail, and 4 guppies. In another...
sponsors
Weathervane Seafoods
Maine Lobster - Seafood - Chicken- Clambakes - Fresh Catch- Cocktails.
www.weathervaneseafoods.com
Local Coupons
1 ridiculously huge coupon a day. Get 50-90% off your city's best!
www.Groupon.com
Blue Bank Resort
Stay where Bill Dance Kevin VanDam & the rest of the pros stay.
www.bluebankresort.com
About Tropical Fish
Looking For About Tropical Fish? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com
Aquariums
Huge Aquariums Deals Online, Free US Shipping this Winter!
Aquariums.ComparedStores.com
Discount Fishing Tackle
Crankbaits $1.25 Poppers $1.99 Swimbait $1.99 Spinnerbait $.99
www.themangler.com
fish food
Find fish food Online. Free Shipping $50 on 100,000 Items!
Target.com/FreeShipping
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.