sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

healthcare industry email this discussion to a friend?

rodica2006 (17)3 years ago

I watched the movie and I could not believe healthcare in other countries is so affordable and not costly like here in the US. Is it really true what Michael Moore shows in the movie or is it staged for political reasons (him being a democrat supporter!)

 
 
sicko
sponsors
Healthcare Design
Specialists in healthcare design. Improve productivity and flow.
www.healthcarefs.com

Covidien
Improving The Healthcare Industry& Patient Lives Through Innovation.
www.Covidien.com

Healthcare Advertising
Free guide to navigating FDA online marketing regulations.
www.klick.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  sicko, healthcare, michael moore, healthcare industry, roger moore
 
1. flotownwoman (18)   3 years ago

I am an avid Michael Moore fan because he gets to the nitty gritty of things and tells it like it is! The subjects he chooses, I feel, need to be addressed and brought out into the open. Unfortunately, I will have to wait to view until it comes out on DVD or travel 100 miles to see it...our theater in this little town has a reputation of not showing any movies that are controversial or avant guard.

Here is a link to facts used in the film and their resources. Perhaps it will help to ease your mind on whether the movie was staged or not...

http://www.michaelmoore.com/sicko/checkup/

I would like to suggest that you watch his other films such as...Roger and Me (his first), Bowling Columbine, Farenheit 9/11 (one of Oregon's own State Troopers, Andy Kenyon, was one of the interviewee's in this film).

Healthcare, in my opinion, is at an outrageously dangerous point in history...I don't know where the ethics have gone...oh wait a minute...I do...they got lost in the almighty dollar...where money has become more important than human beings. I have personal experience with some horror stories right here in my own town. Mis-diagnosis resulting in death...my own son's prescriptions costing almost $2000 a month! It is simply an outrage!

Healthcare Design Specialists in healthcare design. Improve productivity and flow. www.healthcarefs.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 89/100. Tanya8 (1452)   3 years ago

There are plenty of problems with the Canadian health care system that Michael Moore didn't focus on, however most Canadians highly value our universal access to medical treatment and are prepared to pay the high taxes that go along with it. Accident or illness could happen to any of us, so we're prepared to share the cost.

We have an aging population (like the U.S. does), and we are worried about how we're going to be able to continue to fund the system as more people need to make use of it, but most of us are adamant that we don't want to find ourself in a situation like in the U.S. where companies are profiting from denying coverage.

Covidien Improving The Healthcare Industry & Patient Lives Through Innovation. www.Covidien.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 78/100. xfahctor (5535)   3 years ago

There is a great deal of mis information in this movie, Michael Moore is famouse for this type of thing. Personaly too, i think he should be tried for his little excursion to cuba, he did in fact break the law. Also, what he doesn't tell you and not a lot of people know, it is ILEGAL for a hospital in this country to deny treatment on the basis of ability to pay or not. Another thing he fails to mention is that medicaid is availble to a great number of people who NEVER apply for it, leaving themselvs and their kids not covered and giving the apearence that this country denies medical treatment to a great many. In addition to this federal program, many hospitals have programs and funds available for people who can not pay for their treatment. Most people never seek these out or ask about them so they go uncovered.I have never been refused treatment for anything. The worst case scenario I have ever encountered is being taken to court to collect on an unpaid hospital bill, you know what came out of it? I paid 5 dollars a month on it and eventualy the hospital wrote the rest off and I STILL get treated with out question.
As for the wonderful medical center that Mr Moore brings the 9/11 workers to, you can be CERTAIN that this is not the typical thing an average cuban sees when they seek treatment. Why is it that thousands die every year trying to reach our shores? if the system there is so wonderful, then why do people come here? As for our system, I hear a great deal of outcry for a national healthcare system, a socialized medical system run by the government. Tell me something, do you REALLY want to trust your health and the health of your children to the GOVERNMENT? OUR GOVERNMENT? Look at everything else they get their hands on, you see how well they handle things as it is. Do you want the tax rates people pay in europe and canada? do you really want to put on a waiting list for treatment for something? Only to find that when you get the treatment it isn't what it used to be because healthcare has been rationed and the system is so bloated and expensive to run that the money to keep the technology up just isn't there any more? The simple fact is our healthcare is of the best quality in the world because the government is not involved. it may be the most expensive but Ive said time and time again, you get what you pay for. In many national healthcare systems around the world, did you know it is ILEGAL for you to pay a doctor out of your own pocket for treatment if you can afford to and choose do so? Is this REALLY what you want in this country? Please people, THINK. REALLY REALLY think about the consequenses and not just the hype and catch phrases and cliche's you see in a movie or in the national and international news. This movie is pure garbage just like the rest or Mr Moores MOCKumentaries. If he dislikes things in this country so badly and thinks places like cuba are so wonderful, then he should justleave the country and move there. I'll even buy his ticket for him. Leave our healthcare system private!!!!!!


myLot reputation of 90/100. thegirlnextdoor (241)  3 years ago

I may be playing devil's advocate a bit here. While it is illegal for a hospital to deny treatment based on ability to pay, it doesn't stop them from giving you less than adequate treatment because you cannot afford to pay. I have personal experience with this and so does my sister. I am epileptic and recently had my first seizure while not being insured. When I had health insurance I was kept in the hospital for monitoring and tests where run. Recently, I was released from the hospital after being conscious for about 30 minutes without even being able to function. Basically they kept me long enough to get my billing information. They jacked me up on so many anti seizure meds that I was basically comatose for 2 days. They did not even make sure that I made it to my car safely. But they released me from the hospital in this condition. I do not even remember leaving the hospital or getting home.
My sister went to the ER several times while on Medicaid with excruciating stomach pains and reflux. She was unable to keep down food. They kept sending her home and telling her she had heartburn and to take Tums. Later we found out she had gallstones and by that point they were so bad they had to remove her entire gallbladder.

So I will agree that they do not deny services, but I will add the caveat that just because they cannot legally deny you does not mean that they will necessarily give you the same level of care if you are on Medicaid, Medicare or uninsured.

related resources:
home care services, home health care, personal care

Healthcare Advertising Free guide to navigating FDA online marketing regulations. www.klick.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 90/100. thegirlnextdoor (241)   3 years ago

While I can't say that Moore doesn't tilt his perspective a bit, it is true that in Canada, France, England and a lot of other countries, healthcare is provided socially. This means that all health care is provided at the cost of the government in the form of taxes on the people. I have to say, as one of the many uninsured Americans, that I would be perfectly happy to pay more taxes if I never had to worry about health care costs. I am epileptic and the last time I had to go to the ER while I was having a seizure, it cost me well over $4000. What I found to be especially gripping in the movie was the part where the man had to choose which finger he could afford to have reattached. No one should ever have to make a choice like that, especially not in one of the richest nations in the world.

Healthcare Management Software Improve quality, reduce costs with Healthcare Management Software. www.healthlinesystems.com
 
sponsors
Healthcare Management Software
Improve quality, reduce costs with Healthcare Management Software.
www.healthlinesystems.com

Healthcare Government
Cook Medical Founder Says Treating Diseases Early Will Save Billions.
HealthCareAccess.CookMedical.com

Find Hospital Bill Audit Service
Healthcare Horizons offers detailed healthcare claims audits to self-insured employers across the nation. Recover overpaid claims that can be returned to the employer’s account.
www.healthcarehorizons.com

similar discussions
Micheal Moore the "SICKO"
I wondered into the store the other day and picked up Rolling Stone (August 2009) magazine upon...
Health insurance, anyone?
I just finished watching 'Sicko'. I was wondering who has health insurance here and would like to...
The 73-year-old man who repeatedly raped his daughter
This story has sickened me and shocked me. Josef Fritzl, the 73-year-old Austrian who imprisoned...
Disgusting Food Clerks that lick the bags before handling your food.
Saliva is nasty. I dont want some clerk's nasty saliva handling my food and putting it into the...
This is just too GROSS! Can you imagine? OMG!
The Big Bopper” Richardson’s casket, made of 16-gauge steel, was exhumed last year so the singer’s...
sponsors
Healthcare Management Software
Improve quality, reduce costs with Healthcare Management Software.
www.healthlinesystems.com
Healthcare Government
Cook Medical Founder Says Treating Diseases Early Will Save Billions.
HealthCareAccess.CookMedical.com
Find Hospital Bill Audit Service
Healthcare Horizons offers detailed healthcare claims audits to self-insured employers across the nation. Recover overpaid claims that can be returned to the employer’s account.
www.healthcarehorizons.com
Looking for Pain Relief?
Complete Local Chiropractic Care - For Washington DC. Visit Us Today!
www.JeffersonSpine.net
Washington DC Hospitals
Find listings for hospitals in Washington DC with YellowPages.
Www.YellowPages.com/WashingtonDC
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.