sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   news   photos

Forced medical procedures.  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 83/100. TDonald (1148) 3 years ago

John Edwards, one of the Democratics who wants to be the next USA president, is proposing mandatory doctor visits as part of his universal health care plan.

Would you want the government telling you that you are REQUIRED to have a medical procedure done?



 

sponsors
Washington Vein Disease
McLean Vein Center Offers Multiple Treatments for Veins.
DC.Vein-Treatment.com

Looking for a Job?
Find It On Monster. Search Jobs in Washington& Post Your Resume.
www.Monster.com

Elective Surgery Loans
Get a Loan for Medical Procedures. Even with Bad Credit. Apply Today.
www.myMedicalLoan.com

wotfpatty (1290) response was accepted on 9/8/2007.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  freedom, medical, political correctness, aussies dont like each other, birdbrain
 
1. myLot reputation of 99/100. lilaclady (19854)   3 years ago

I think intially it would be good for people so long as people's ownership of their bodies is not taken away, everyone must keep the right to say no it this is their choice, there are certain things I would say no to and I think enforced procedures is taking freedom away from people as it is your body...


myLot reputation of 83/100. TDonald (1148)  3 years ago

The intentions may be right, but the implications could be sinister.

Washington Vein Disease McLean Vein Center Offers Multiple Treatments for Veins.  DC.Vein-Treatment.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 95/100. CinderInMySoul (4350)   3 years ago

i can understand a mandatory once a year doctor checkup. but NOT being required to undergo a prodecedure, of any kind!

i dont care if i have a humongous wart that they want to take off, if i want to keep the ugly thing, then im keeping it!
not even considering major operations!

and you're right, its a good thought, that has some scary potential.

Looking for a Job? Find It On Monster. Search Jobs in Washington & Post Your Resume.  www.Monster.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 91/100. lpetges (2314)   3 years ago

i think this whole country needs an insurance policy of some kind.. not sure about the plan, but i know that it sucks for us. we have middle of the road insurance, and we pay for some of it. we just recently found out that when we were on vacation, we ae not covered unless a "network provider" works on you. this could bankrupt us if we are out of our network, and say my husband had a heart attack outside of our area that we live in. how stupid is that? insurance isnt what it used to be, but then again niether are the costs of any procedure. its ridiculous. i know a couple of people who have gone outside of the country to get their cancer treatents,, not only was it cheaper, it was quicker, and recovery was easier. we need somethng here for everyone. if your not poor, you cant get good health care.

Elective Surgery Loans Get a Loan for Medical Procedures. Even with Bad Credit. Apply Today.  www.myMedicalLoan.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 91/100. dumblnddzzy (10326)   3 years ago

Absoulutely not!! I want the choice to have a medical procedure done or not. Certainly NOT the government forcing us to do so!!Lori

Health Insurance Agencies Listings for local health insurance agencies serving Washington DC.  yellowpages.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 84/100. Aussies2007 (2937)   3 years ago

This is not about medical procedures...

It is about medical check up.
This would be more about protecting children than individuals. Nobody cares if you are sick and don't want to take yourself to the doctor. But we do care if your child is sick... and you don't take it to the doctor.

It is about protecting innocent children from bad parents. It could also be about protecting old people from bad children.

I think that you people in America are up for a rude shock as you come in line with the rest of the world. You seem to be enjoying a wild freedom that was taken away from the rest of us a long time ago.

It is ironic that you have no tolerance for anyone wanting to tell you what to do... but at the same time... you keep telling the rest of the world what to do.


myLot reputation of 83/100. TDonald (1148)  3 years ago

This is about the government telling you you have to subject yourself to medical testing.

You may enjoy mandatory bureaucratic probing, I don't.

Thanks for the anti-American rant. Don't confuse the policies of government and multi-national corporations with the wishes of the majority of American people.


myLot reputation of 84/100. Aussies2007 (2937)  3 years ago

For the record... I am not anti-American at all.
The problem is not with me... but with Americans who have a chip on their shoulders and view anyone not agreeing with them as anti-American.

Like it or not... but eventually you will have to fall in line like everybody else... and it is going to happen sooner than you think... mark my word.

While your freedom is wonderful... it does come at a price. In Australia... everyone is free. In America... only those with money are free.



myLot reputation of 83/100. TDonald (1148)  3 years ago



Fall in line with what? who? why?


myLot reputation of 84/100. Aussies2007 (2937)  3 years ago

Fall in line with what we call in Australia "political correctness".

In most cases... I hate it. But I am from the old school and I don't represent the majority anymore. However I still like to call "a spade a spade". But people won't allow me to do that on an Australian forum. I got ban from two of them. Which is why I am on an American forum.

Political correctness means equality for everyone (even if they don't deserve it).
No racism.
No discrimination.

It also means
No illegal emigrants.
No drink driving.
No speeding.
No guns.
No smoking.
All of those are viewed as anti-social and only smoking is not yet a crime... (give us a couple more years).

And as you would know... all those things are getting on your agenda in America.


myLot reputation of 83/100. TDonald (1148)  3 years ago

I would define PC as NOT saying what should be said.

So are you for or against the things you listed?


myLot reputation of 84/100. Aussies2007 (2937)  3 years ago

I am all for "no illegal emigrants".
I was against the rest when it was introduced... but I learned to live with it. My biggest problem with it is the way it is enforced with zero tolerance.

A lot of people get severely punish for speeding and drink driving for being just over the limit... and they don't deserve that. As for the smoking ban... it is pure hypocrisy.

What you also need to remember is... that when a government decides to take matters in its own hands by forcing people to do something... it is because people did abuse their freedom and broke the rules of common sense.

This has just happened in Australia. Ten years ago we gave the aborigines part of their land back... and the freedom to live on their reserve independantly from the rest of us. Today we find that those aborigines are abusing their children in all sort of ways... and we cannot simply sit there and watch it happening. So the government is taking their freedom away.


myLot reputation of 41/100. plooker (138)  3 years ago

As an Australian I am embarrassed and compelled to comment here. Aussies2007, despite his myLot username, is NOT an Australian, he is French! It is he, who has a huge chip on his shoulder and his anti-American rant indeed borders on insult, while showing a high degree of ignorance.
He confuses personal freedom with political correctness, the meaning of which he does not seem to understand in the first place. For you Aussies2007: political correctness (PC) is the term used to describe language, ideas, policies or behavior seen as seeking to minimize offense to racial, cultural or other identity groups. PC is the communal tyranny that erupted in the 1980s. It was a spontaneous declaration that particular ideas, expressions and behavior, which were then legal, should be forbidden by law, and those who transgressed should be punished. So, TDonald your question to Aussies2007 to explain himself is justified. Aussies2007's statement about 'falling in line with the rest of the world', is another one that makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. He does not define 'in line with rest of the world' and probably forgets that the rest of the world includes China!
Anyway, TDonald, if you continue this discussion with Aussies2007, who is off topic, remember that he is French, NOT Australian.


myLot reputation of 84/100. Aussies2007 (2937)  3 years ago

That is the problem with people like plooker. He is Dutch and he is racist. He hate political correctness and anti-disminicration laws.
He hates anyone who don't think like him.
He hates chinese because they don't speak english. He hates homosexual, aborigines, teenagers breaking the law... you name it... he hates it.

His idea of being a good Australian is to get piss after a hard day work.

You only need to live two years in Australia to become an Australian. I have been here 37 years... and I am more Australian than plooker will ever be. Being Australian is about tolerance towards other. Plooker does not even know how to spell the word "tolerance".


myLot reputation of 41/100. plooker (138)  3 years ago

Correction: Plooker has Australian citizenship! Aussies2007 has NOT!


myLot reputation of 84/100. Aussies2007 (2937)  3 years ago

It is a shame that the piece of paper you bought with a pound of sugar did not alter your way of thinking.


myLot reputation of 41/100. plooker (138)  3 years ago

Australian citizenship cannot be bought, Aussies2007. One has to qualify by attending an interview at the department of Ethnic Affairs (I went to their Parramatta office) and satisfy the conditions prescribed by the Australian Citizenship Act 1948. If you have any criminal offenses on your record, you do not qualify. Not paying your taxes is a criminal offense. You also have to have an understanding of the English language. So if you did not obtain Australian citizenship after 37 years (shame!) then what is your problem?


myLot reputation of 83/100. TDonald (1148)  3 years ago

I sense you two don't like each other.


myLot reputation of 99/100. wotfpatty (1290)  3 years ago

LOL, TDonald!

I was about to answer when I started reading this amazing exchange and just stopped and pondered.

I sense a distinct dislike between the two that I actually find interesting but way off topic. I will respond to the original question but it won't be as interesting as this exchange!

$74/Hr Job - 117 Openings (Edwards) Can You Type? Earn $74+/hr From Home. Seen On CNN & FOX News.  www.Chicago-Sentinel.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 99/100. wotfpatty (1290)   3 years ago

I don't mind the government wanting me and my kids to have a yearly checkup as long as THEY PAY FOR IT. However, I will not ever allow anyone to tell me that I have to have any sort of procedure done. I don't even think that is legal and doubt it ever will be. No one can force anyone to have an operation or procedure even if it means the person will die from not having it done.

I think people should be vigilant enough to go yearly for a checkup anyway to be sure everything is OK without being forced although I know some who refuse to go to a doctor for any reason. Kids should be treated and have their shots though.

But if you are asking if I want the government to to tell me I am required to have any sort of procedure, of course not, and I would break the "law" if need be if I felt that was right for me.

Not as engaging as the discussion before mine but the best I could do! lol.


myLot reputation of 83/100. TDonald (1148)  3 years ago

I think the intent is to require tests for certain diseases. How invasive this could become is open for speculation.

There could be conflicts with people with certain religious beliefs too.

And would you be punished if you refused a test or just denied medical insurance?




myLot reputation of 41/100. plooker (138)  3 years ago

Gday Woftpatty,

I am glad that I have been able to entertain you with my 'off-topic' discussion with Aussies2007. I am sorry TDonald. Yes, I know Aussies2007 and no, I don't like that birdbrain.


myLot reputation of 99/100. wotfpatty (1290)  3 years ago

Hi Plooker,

It was an amazing exchange! I have no idea what it is all about but the animosity was very vivid. It was a relief to not be one of the two who were having that kind of discussion!

And TDonald, I agree that if there is anything more than the government will pay for a yearly check up, I don't want it. I take care of myself in MY way and, as you said, some religions don't believe in certain tests and procedures and some people simply do not want medical intervention for their own reasons.

If I had to say yes I agree or no I don't to your initial question, it would be no. We need better health care but we need it for those who want and seek it, not for those who are forced to do things they don't want to do.

KLM Tickets Delhi Fly from Washington to Delhi for low fares. Book now on KLM.com!  www.klm.com/delhi
 
sponsors
Health Insurance Agencies
Listings for local health insurance agencies serving Washington DC.
yellowpages.com

$74/Hr Job - 117 Openings (Edwards)
Can You Type? Earn $74+/hr From Home. Seen On CNN& FOX News.
www.Chicago-Sentinel.com

KLM Tickets Delhi
Fly from Washington to Delhi for low fares. Book now on KLM.com!
www.klm.com/delhi

similar discussions
Should smoking be banned in public places?
A great number of mostly developed countries have enacted bans on smoking in public places or...
Principals Of Gandhi g.
Everybody knows about the great personality like Gandhi g.he is the man who fought against...
Have we got freedom now.
Have we got freedom till now.i don't think so because there are many problems in our country like...
Did we do the right thing with Iraq?
Have we destroyed that country or have we made it something better?
Do you practice properly your freedom of speech?
In school of developing young men, students voice out their opinions of what they believe is right...
Inappropriate Avatars
Okay...I am troubled by this. I am all for freedom of speech and expressionism...but I found an...
Why "Free Will" Really Doesn't Matter...
Man, this is depressing. Guess I may as well give up asking questions trying to understand God...
Is 18 Really Old Enough?
My sister turned 18 a couple of days ago and though she has grown up I could still see the lil 3...
Mrs Clarence Thomas: Wife of Supreme Justice launches TEA PARTY
Like many millions of Americans who are very concerned over the direction our country has been...
what is the greatest thing in life that is free?
What is the greatest thing in life that is free? A common question but being answered by " Love"...
sponsors
Health Insurance Agencies
Listings for local health insurance agencies serving Washington DC.
yellowpages.com
$74/Hr Job - 117 Openings (Edwards)
Can You Type? Earn $74+/hr From Home. Seen On CNN & FOX News.
www.Chicago-Sentinel.com
KLM Tickets Delhi
Fly from Washington to Delhi for low fares. Book now on KLM.com!
www.klm.com/delhi
earning money online
Get Paid $500 - $3500 Per Month! Simple Online Surveys. Start Now.
QuickPaidSurveys.com/EarnMoney
Get Your Washington Real Estate License
Complete How To Guide On This Topic and 1000s of Others.
howto-tutorials.com
washington DC sr 22 insurance
You Could Save Up To 50% On Auto Insurance! Compare Online…
WashingtonD.C..INScarriers.com
Washington Jobs
Train for a job in Washington paying up to $77k per year
www.LocalJobMatches.com
Universal Health Services jobs
We're Still Hiring. Local Job Openings
www.americanusajobs.net
Medical Insurance Washington
Get Your Free Health Plan Quotes in Seconds! Compare & Save. Fast.
www.HealthSurance.org/Medical
Earning Money on the Internet
Can You Type? Earn $74+/hr From Home! Seen On CNN & FOX News.
HoustonFinanceNews.com/-
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.