sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionsblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLot

Have you watched this movie? email this discussion to a friend?

rechel (14)   ranked 24 out of 37 in gone with the wind11 months ago

I prefer the book to the movie,though the wovie has received a lot of rewards of oscar.THE STORY GIVES ME THE ENCOURAGEMENT WHENERER I FACE UP DIFFICULTIES.I SET THE YOUNG GIRL AS A SYMBOL OF COURAGEMENT.

 
 
gone with the wind
sponsors
DIRECTV Subscribers Only
Special Offer: 3 Months of Playboy TV for $12.99/Mo. Offer Ends 7/31.
www.directv.com/playboy

Instant Pins, India as Ow as 8¢/Mi
45min for $4.0, just 8¢/Min Pinless Dial, Good cards for India instant online pins. Good voice quality.
www.10dollarscard.com

Latest Movie Info
Watch Movie Trailers, Animated Reviews& More w/Free Movie Toolbar.
Movie.alot.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  gone with the wind, movie, mother india
 
1. myLot reputation of 87/100. TeresaK (8104)   11 months ago

Yes, I have seen this movie many times. I own a copy of it, so I watch it at least once a year. I also own a copy of the book, and I read it at least once a year as well. I, like you, prefer the book to the movie...there are more details in the book, things left out of the movie which I believe are very important to the story.


rechel (14)   ranked 24 out of 37 in gone with the wind  11 months ago

there are more details in the book,which can tell more background about that time,society,custome,and so on. the custome is very important,especially for those people who are not amercian.hehe,I'm so glad to hear you also like this book.Enjoy it!!!

DIRECTV Subscribers Only Special Offer: 3 Months of Playboy TV for $12.99/Mo. Offer Ends 7/31. www.directv.com/playboy
 
2. myLot reputation of 81/100. bargaingirl (586)   11 months ago

Actually I have never seen the movie or read the book.

Instant Pins, India as Ow as 8¢/Mi 45min for $4.0, just 8¢/Min Pinless Dial, Good cards for India instant online pins. Good voice quality. www.10dollarscard.com
 
3. mandalashir (68)   11 months ago

I've both watched this movie and read the novel for many times.I agree that the book is more outstanding than the movie.It contains more things,such as Scarlette's first son and daugther,and I think these can help us understand her more clearly.
Although the movie doesn't show the novel overall,we can't deny that it's a really good one.I like Vivien Leigh.She made me feel that she was Scarlette,a real Scarlette.

Latest Movie Info Watch Movie Trailers, Animated Reviews & More w/Free Movie Toolbar. Movie.alot.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 97/100. cobradene (405)   10 months ago

Regardless of what the movie says, I consider it as a wonderful piece of art. A story so well told, has been presented so picture perfect,is just amazing. It's not easy to convert a book into a movie. Many films based on books have failed. For eg, The Runaway Jury and Da Vinci Code failed miserably inspite of the books having done really well. Obviously, Gone with the wind speaks of courage, but at the same time, the woman was too self-centered. There is a similar theme on femininity in an Indian film which was nominated for the Oscar the first time. It was called Mother India and am sure it deserved an Oscar too. Even that movie spoke about a village woman and her farmer husband who had 4 children. Her husband loses both his hands and then commits sudicide and it's up to her now to bring all the children up and one of her sons becomes a dacoit, but in the end it's the mother who takes the extra step of killing him for the betterment of the society.:)

Acai As Seen On Oprah Powerful Antioxidant Acai Berry The #1 Super Food. 14 Day Free Trial. www.secureeasypay.com/extremeacai
 
5. binglan412 (2)   10 months ago

yes,and i love her saying "tomorrow is another day"most!~

Gone With The Wind Browse a huge selection now. Find exactly what you want today. www.ebay.com
 
sponsors
Acai As Seen On Oprah
Powerful Antioxidant Acai Berry The #1 Super Food. 14 Day Free Trial.
www.secureeasypay.com/extremeacai

Gone With The Wind
Browse a huge selection now. Find exactly what you want today.
www.ebay.com

Live TV on PC. $49
Watch 3,000+ Live TV stations on your PC. One fee, no monthly charges.
SatelliteTVPC.com

similar discussions
Which movie could you watch 100 times?
Which movies do you love enough to watch over and over again? Would you watch your favorite movie...
Gone with the WInd
I love reading and this only book of Margarett Mitchell is one of the superb love story i have ever...
Which did you like better the book or the movie?
I have read both the book & seen the movie & I honestly can't decide which I like better LOL. The...
Best Picture of All Time
Gone with the Wind is the best picture of all time.The costumes and actors were superb.The...
Today in History Gone with the Wind was published Have you seen it or read it?
In 1936, Margaret Mitchell's epic of the Civil War, Gone with the Wind, was published. I saw...
How Old Is Old?
When you think of an old movie, what criteria do you consider that makes you think of it as "old"?...
sponsors
Acai As Seen On Oprah
Powerful Antioxidant Acai Berry The #1 Super Food. 14 Day Free Trial.
www.secureeasypay.com/extremeacai
Gone With The Wind
Browse a huge selection now. Find exactly what you want today.
www.ebay.com
Live TV on PC. $49
Watch 3,000+ Live TV stations on your PC. One fee, no monthly charges.
SatelliteTVPC.com
movie
Find listings for local movie theaters - indie, multiplex & more.
Movies.YellowPages.com/losangeles
NYC Top Bars, Clubs, Lounges & Nightlife
Get latest on NYC Bars-Clubs-Lounges with Thrillist Free Daily Emails.
Thrillist.com
movie
Find listings for local movie theaters - indie, multiplex & more.
Movies.YellowPages.com