sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

Could you ever forgive someone who murdered your child? email this discussion to a friend?

Proserpine (83)4 years ago

Two years ago in my community, a drunk driver killed a teenager. The teenager's family says they have forgiven the man, and they are actually fighting in court to get his sentence shortened because they say the remorse he feels has been punishment enough. I have very conflicting emotions about this, because while I believe forgiveness helps everyone move on and heal in the end, I do not believe I would ever be able to forgive someone for taking my child's life, especially a drunk driver. What are your thoughts?

 
 
sponsors
Spa On The Hill
Read reviews for this business wit directions, offers and more.
Citysearch.com

Meineke
Find Auto Part& Accessory Dealers! Try Citysearch® now
Washingtondc.Citysearch.com

Midway Roofing
Find prescreened roofers in Midway Washington in just one click.
contractors.clicksmart.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  forgiveness, murder, child, kill, children
 
1. myLot reputation of 91/100. dellion (5585)   4 years ago

I don;t I can even face it if that was happended to my family and for the rest of my life I don't think I can really forgive it.


Proserpine (83)  4 years ago

It is even hard to imagine, isn't it? Hopefully we will never have to face such a dreadful thing, ever.


yokus52 (2)  4 years ago

No, that is something I could never forgive.


Proserpine (83)  4 years ago

Thanks for commenting.

Spa On The Hill Read reviews for this business wit directions, offers and more. Citysearch.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 95/100. sbeauty (4507)   4 years ago

I would like to say I could, but I don't know. That would be the most devastating thing that could happen to me. I admired the Amish people who said that they had already forgiven the man who killed 5 of their children. That takes real strength of character, and I believe they have it if anyone does.

For me it would also depend on the circumstances. If it was premeditated murder or a serial killer, or something like that, I'd have a harder time forgiving than if it were an accident. One thing I would always want to remember is that the killer's family is grieving, too. I'd never want to be as vengeful as some of the people I see on the news. Hurting that other family isn't going to bring your child back.


Proserpine (83)  4 years ago

You are so right. Your child won't come back no matter what. And I admire and respect the Amish so much, as well as the Quakers, who also believe that forgiveness is paramount and always possible. I do so wish I could be as sure as they are that I could forgive. I certainly don't think I could forgive that man who shot all those Amish children. There is always a choice. If that man was so miserable that he couldn't live without the thought of doing others harm, he had other options that would not have hurt anyone else. I am not saying I condone suicide, but in cases such as these, it is hard not to say I'd choose that. Just look at that man last week who killed his four year old son and survived. He had hoped to kill himself and both his children in a suicidal car crash. Why didn't he just kill himself? I cannot imagine being so emotionally distressed as to want to kill my own children or anyone else, even if I had "snapped." For some reason I just do not think your conscience abandons you completely even in moments of a dire stress. But if I had to defend the life of my own child or any other person, I do think I'd be able to kill. Not without remorse, not without much mental disturbance, but I do think it would be a normal survival reflex.

Meineke Find Auto Part & Accessory Dealers! Try Citysearch® now Washingtondc.Citysearch.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 92/100. missinghim (915)   4 years ago

I really believe that it would really take a lot of growth and character for me to forgive something so heinous. And even though that man may be remorseful now, he wasn't too remorseful when he made the decision to drive while he was intoxicated. What he did was willfull and deliberate, and unfortunately that resulted in the death of an innocent child. Quite frankly, he deserves to serve his full sentence, and quite frankly whatever time they gave him was not enough in my opinion.


Proserpine (83)  4 years ago

Thank you all for your heartfelt answers. This is an extremely sensitive subject and difficult even to imagine having happen in our own lives.

Midway Roofing Find prescreened roofers in Midway Washington in just one click. contractors.clicksmart.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 93/100. sabrinam (711)   4 years ago

No, absolutely not and if it made me a bitter terrible old woman, so be it. Once upon a time I was told I would never see my son again and now, those people wish they'd never crossed that line. I'm the proverbial mama bear. Leave the cubs alone.


Proserpine (83)  4 years ago

I think your thoughts are very close to mine. I don't think I could ever forgive and I would protet my children as fiercely as you've protected your son.

Macy's ® Wedding Registry Create or Find a Registry @ Macy's. Rewards Program Save 5-10%! MacysWeddingChannel.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 98/100. euniceeleanor (3371)   4 years ago

Though I would hope to say that I will forgive and forget, i believe that during the initial stage, i will be so angry with that person. I mean, for being so irresponsible, driving under the influence of alcohol, and resulting the death of a teenager. Well, come to think of it, it's kinda hard to forgive him, ever!


Proserpine (83)  4 years ago

I have to say I agree with you . . .

2004 honda insight at Yahoo! Find Washington, DC area used Honda car dealers and get a free quote. www.promotions.yahoo.com/honda
 
6. myLot reputation of 97/100. dollbaby (269)   4 years ago

I agree with you. It's hard to say how I would actually feel if this happened. However, I would die for my kids and the thought of someone else taking their life senselessly...well I don't believe I could ever forgive that.


Proserpine (83)  4 years ago

Let's just hope we never, any of us, have to face such circumstances, ever. It is awful even to imagine.

Washington VIN History at Carfax Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get CARFAX Vehicle History Reports. www.Carfax.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 98/100. Cortney (3064)   4 years ago

I could never forgive someone who killed my child. I don't care how remorseful they are. They took a life. If a person is stupid enough to get behind the wheel smashed out of their mind, then they should suffer the consiquences. I think that killing someone, especially when driving drunk, should be a 1st degree murder charge. They got behind the wheel intensionally when they could have called a friend, relative, or cab.


Proserpine (83)  4 years ago

You are so right. They had a choice, a very serious choice . . .

DC Area Attractions Find museums, national monuments, historic homes, wineries and more. www.fxva.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 94/100. magikrose (4951)   4 years ago

That is a very hard question for me to answer. My biggest fear is loosing any or all of my children for any reason. I would have to say that if the person really was honestly remorsefull then I might be able to forgive but if it was done out of hate then there is no way I could forgive.


Earth Girl

Proserpine (83)  4 years ago

That's a very balanced answer. It is what I would hope to feel myself, but I honestly do not believe I'd ever be able to forgive someone taking my child's life, either intentionally or unintentionally. I suppose that makes me imperfect, but I could never forgive myself either if I had caused the death of someone else's child . . .

Back in Action Spinecare & Rehab Chiropractic - Spinal Decompression - Rehabilitation - Nutrition. www.virginiachiro.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 66/100. mshenzi (230)   4 years ago

I can forgive him if he lets me kill him and not report this matter.


Proserpine (83)  4 years ago

Wow. That's a little harsh! But again, I have no idea how I would respond. I would certainly have moments I would wish to kill the person, but hope that I would not, because I do not think we can ever recover from taking someone else's life. And if I was the one who had drank, drove and killed, especially a child or teenager, I do not believe I could live with the guilt and remorse. There are just some things that cannot be forgiven. This is a tough discussion matter . . .

Carpet Cleaning: Chasecarpetcleaning.com Chase Carpet Cleaning offers professional cleaning services. Serving Washington DC, Maryland and Virginia. Visit our site for more information. Great deals. Contact us for a free quote. www.chasecarpetcleaning.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 73/100. divir_vij (1378)   4 years ago

No matter how long it takes they should not loose hope and get justice for the sake of their dead child... This would be the only thing they can do for their demised loved one


Proserpine (83)  4 years ago

I agree, justice should be sought and gone after by all means, it's the forgiving and forgetting I would find impossible . . .

Home and Office Construction General contractor serving Washington DC, Maryland and Virginia. Specializing in basements, decks, additions, new homes, offices, barns and garages. www.worthington.tv
 
sponsors
Macy's ® Wedding Registry
Create or Find a Registry @ Macy's. Rewards Program Save 5-10%!
MacysWeddingChannel.com

2004 honda insight at Yahoo!
Find Washington, DC area used Honda car dealers and get a free quote.
www.promotions.yahoo.com/honda

Washington VIN History at Carfax
Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get CARFAX Vehicle History Reports.
www.Carfax.com

similar discussions
Are you ready to forigive those people who have sinned you?
The year is about to end. While people really make mistakes, it's not easy to forgive those who...
I decided to remove all bitterness
I saw a lot of injustice in my life, from my relatives from people i know, but i removed them all...
Christmas is a time to forgive......
It's almost Christmas and we are all busy doing preparations to make the event memorable for the...
Does saying " I'm sorry" is enough for you to give forgiveness?
There are times when hearing the words "I'm sorry" is enough for us to give forgiveness while there...
God forgives but can i forgive Myself?
Im trying to discover Christianity and i am struggling with it! Im wondering what people think of...
Would you forgive?
Disagreements is a given in relationships. Regardless if it's your husband, your friend, boyfriend,...
In the spirit of Christmas, are you willing give forgiveness?
We often heard people saying " you must forgive for the sake of Christmas." Do you think it's right...
Why is it so hard to forgive a friend than an enemy?
Why is it that you can forgive your enemy for the hurt they caused you, but you can not forgive...
Cheater or Liar: Which deserves to be forgiven first?
A friend of mine asked question to me, Cheater or Liar: Which deserves to be forgiven first? I...
What do you think they have in their minds?
ONe of my friend had got married to a guy about 7 years ago. But she married on her own accord that...
sponsors
Macy's ® Wedding Registry
Create or Find a Registry @ Macy's. Rewards Program Save 5-10%!
MacysWeddingChannel.com
2004 honda insight at Yahoo!
Find Washington, DC area used Honda car dealers and get a free quote.
www.promotions.yahoo.com/honda
Washington VIN History at Carfax
Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get CARFAX Vehicle History Reports.
www.Carfax.com
DC Area Attractions
Find museums, national monuments, historic homes, wineries and more.
www.fxva.com
Back in Action Spinecare & Rehab
Chiropractic - Spinal Decompression - Rehabilitation - Nutrition.
www.virginiachiro.com
Carpet Cleaning: Chasecarpetcleaning.com
Chase Carpet Cleaning offers professional cleaning services. Serving Washington DC, Maryland and Virginia. Visit our site for more information. Great deals. Contact us for a free quote.
www.chasecarpetcleaning.com
Home and Office Construction
General contractor serving Washington DC, Maryland and Virginia. Specializing in basements, decks, additions, new homes, offices, barns and garages.
www.worthington.tv
DC clinic
Looking For DC clinic In Your Area. Call Now.
TheQualityOfLifeGroup.Local.com
Insurance Captive Solutions
The Taft Companies, an Insurance Captive and consulting group, provides captive management in Bermuda, Washington DC, South Carolina and Montana.
www.taftcos.com
Travel to Washington DC
Why Wait? Browse Travelzoo's Washington DC Travel Deals Now.
www.Travelzoo.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.