sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

So what did you think of "3:10 to Yuma"? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 93/100. zenmachado (1106)   ranked 120 out of 11,450 in watching movies2 years ago

"3:10 to Yuma" is about a poverty stricken farmer who commits to handle an outlaw (for money) whose being held while waiting for a train, that will lead him to court/prison.

I blame director James Mangold for the uninspiring, overall performance of "3:10 to Yuma".

His direction was timid, and the action sequences were outlandishly boring. The storyline was typical and the script lacked the important aspect of originality.

And the conclusion fails to be authentic, seeing as how the characters did things outside of motivations, that supposedly they had. Making the ending unbelievable.

Plus, the fine performances of Foster and Mol will be overlooked because they were severely underused.


The one thing that aids in redeeming the foul aspects, is the brilliant acting. Bale and Crowe sizzle in their gritty portrayal's. Each one nails every scene and makes you wish that they had more to work with. They carry the film into a territory that is worthy of being viewed. In the end you care not for the story and directing, but are able to praise the continued beauty of proper acting from Bale and Crowe. They manage to deliver intense feelings in serious subtle ways.


So what did you think of "3:10 to Yuma"?

 
 
watching movies
sponsors
Art in Fredericksburg, VA
Galleries, Museums, and the Performing Arts. Request a free guide.
www.VisitFred.com

yuma
Find Local Yuma Online. Search For Yuma Today!
Tazinga.com

car dealer purchase used at Yahoo!
Find Washington, DC area used Honda car dealers and get a free quote.
www.promotions.yahoo.com/honda

sarahruthbeth22 (10486) response was accepted on 1/20/2008.
denotes best response.
tags:  movie, bale, crowe, film, yuma
 
1. myLot reputation of 99/100. sherrir101 (2918)   ranked 2,116 out of 11,450 in watching movies   2 years ago

I, for one, loved the movie. I think I have watched 4 or 5 times now. I loved the old westerns of the 60's and 70's and this reminded me so much of them. I think it was intended to be like a typical western. I am going to go watch it again.


myLot reputation of 93/100. zenmachado (1106)   ranked 120 out of 11,450 in watching movies  2 years ago

Im glad you enjoyed this film. Im sort of the opposite, Ive never really enjoyed the old westerns of the past decades, so that is surely why it was less than pleasing to me.

But Im glad that there are those out there that can enjoy the western's for the rest of us:D

Art in Fredericksburg, VA Galleries, Museums, and the Performing Arts. Request a free guide. www.VisitFred.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 97/100. sarahruthbeth22 (10486)   ranked 2 out of 11,450 in watching movies   2 years ago

After reading your post I am so glad I didn't see this version. When This version was advertised, I saw the original instead. it was made in 1957 and it starred Glenn Ford as the outlaw and Van Heflin as the farmer. It is a great 50's western.And from the sound of your review of the re make it should stay a western of the 50's.


myLot reputation of 93/100. zenmachado (1106)   ranked 120 out of 11,450 in watching movies  2 years ago

It seems to be that way, even if I dont have a valid opinion, because I have yet to view the original film from 1957.

Yet one thing I do know is that very few remakes are ever equal or better than the original. Most times the second coming ends up being horrid.

This film did seem like it was doing was following the original storyline, and keeping all creativity to themselves...


myLot reputation of 97/100. sarahruthbeth22 (10486)   ranked 2 out of 11,450 in watching movies  2 years ago

That is why I don't usually see remakes if I know or even own the original.No one should try to remake a film unless they want to up date it, like the second D.O.A., or bring something new to it.I hope you rent the original 3:10 to Yuma.Let me know if you like it better than the remake.


myLot reputation of 93/100. zenmachado (1106)   ranked 120 out of 11,450 in watching movies  2 years ago

Ill surely attempt to check it out... Hopefully the original will give me a sence of authenticity and I'll enjoy it better..

Thanks for the recommendation...

yuma Find Local Yuma Online. Search For Yuma Today! Tazinga.com
 
sponsors
Cheap Hotels Yuma
Compare Cheapest Hotel Deals in Yuma. Compare& Save Up to 65% Now.
www.TripMama.com/Hotels

chat online in yuma
Chat with singles in your area now! We're 100% free for everything.
DateHookup.com

Local Yuma Radar& Weather Report
Yuma Radar, Maps,& Forecast.
localweather-forecast.com

similar discussions
Favorite childhood movie?
They always leave that special mark... I have to say The Lion King, which was also the first movie...
Sleep in CINEMAS!!!!! How funny??
hey friends.. I really enjoy movies in cinemas. I always used to go for movies in cinema with my...
Do you fall asleep while watching movies?
One thing thats really funny and bad too in me is that most of the time while watching movies i...
mmmm
I watched it last night. Everytime I watch it, I end up feeling like that will be my next career. A...
Do you read novels before the Movie?
Recently I ran to the box office and grabbed by seat for the "New Moon" Vampire movie but not...
2012
The long awaited and most talk about movie is showing now. 2012 - is really a great movie. The...
sponsors
Cheap Hotels Yuma
Compare Cheapest Hotel Deals in Yuma. Compare & Save Up to 65% Now.
www.TripMama.com/Hotels
chat online in yuma
Chat with singles in your area now! We're 100% free for everything.
DateHookup.com
Local Yuma Radar & Weather Report
Yuma Radar, Maps, & Forecast.
localweather-forecast.com
Washington D.C. Carpet Dealers
Find Complete Listings For D.C. Carpet Dealers. Shop Around & Save.
Carpets.YellowPages.com/DC
600 Washington
Read reviews for this business with directions, offers and more
Newyork.Citysearch.com
Senior Housing in Yuma
Get Free Information on Qualified Senior Housing in Your Area.
SeniorLivingSource.org/Housing
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.