sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

OTH: Lucas is making a mistake? or not? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 95/100. speedy1279 (1490)   ranked 2 out of 133 in one tree hill2 years ago

Last nights episode was heartbreaking. I really think Lucas is making a mistake with marrying Lindsay. I mean, Lindsay seems like a nice person. But there is just something about her that is not right. I get this feeling she is hiding something. What? I don't know. Lucas should be with Peyton. They are meant for each other. When Hailey asked Lucas if he really loved Lindsay, he said she was his #2. Now, even though Lucas quickly told Hailey, she was his #1. I really think in his heart Peyton is his #1 and always will be. What are your thoughts on Lucas marrying Lindsay? Good idea? or Bad? Or, do you think he should be with Peyton? Why or Why not?

 
 
one tree hill
sponsors
Heartwood Tree Service
Tree care, removal or consultations Visit today for monthly specials.
www.HeartwoodTree.com

Southside Tree Services
Offering tree trimming, removal, storm damage prevention and more.
southsidetree.localplacement.net

King Tree Experts, Inc
Read this Shrub& Tree Service's reviews& find Lawn& Garden Info.
Atlanta.Citysearch.com

rockerchick (245) response was accepted on 3/13/2008.
denotes best response.
tags:  one tree hill, lucas, peyton, marriage, lindsay
 
1. myLot reputation of 92/100. luvingmygirls (325)   ranked 14 out of 133 in one tree hill   2 years ago

Def not a good idea!!!! Ok if you are going to propose shouldn't it be a new ring. Ummm that just didn't make sense to me. Am I wrong or is that the ring he had been keeping from when he proposed to Peyton.

During the episode I was thinking, So maybe he is just proposing to her because she found the ring. But then he said "lets get married right away" Now I am not sure.

I like Lindsay, I just don't think that Lucas is really following his heart and thats what makes it a bad idea. I swear when Peyton was talking to him he kept acting like he was going to cut her off and say something.

I think L and P should be together but its probably not going to happen.


myLot reputation of 95/100. speedy1279 (1490)   ranked 2 out of 133 in one tree hill  2 years ago

Sorry I didn't respond back to you sooner. Been crazy around here. But anyways, I do believe that the ring was the one he had proposed to Peyton with. I also agree that Lucas is not following his heart but we will all have to wait and see how it plays out. Hopefully some good drama will come out of this and he will end up with Peyton. I know wishful thinking!!!


myLot reputation of 92/100. luvingmygirls (325)   ranked 14 out of 133 in one tree hill  2 years ago

Yep. We were def right. When I saw the Lib episode I was like Ha.

How is he going to propose with the same ring???

Heartwood Tree Service Tree care, removal or consultations Visit today for monthly specials. www.HeartwoodTree.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 71/100. southernpixie (724)   ranked 31 out of 133 in one tree hill   2 years ago

I don't think that Lucas should marry Lindsay. He belongs with Peyton. Also, I don't know why everyone expects Peyton to be nice to Lindsay. I mean Lindsay is sort of snotty. I thought it was hilarious when they were in the library making up lyrics and Peyton called her "Man-faced Lindsay".


myLot reputation of 95/100. speedy1279 (1490)   ranked 2 out of 133 in one tree hill  2 years ago

Yes he does belong with Peyton and I think a lot of people feel that way. Lindsay is definitly snotty and I can't stand her. Of course maybe that is because I have always loved seeing Lucas and Peyton together and now that they aren't it bugs me. The library scene was hilarious but in a way I did feel bad for Lindsay losing her father. But I don't think we have seen the last of the fighting between Lindsay and Peyton. Did you see the look that Peyton gave that other girl (Can't think of her name) when they were walking off from the library? That right there tells me the fighting is not over.

Southside Tree Services Offering tree trimming, removal, storm damage prevention and more. southsidetree.localplacement.net
 
3. myLot reputation of 90/100. rockerchick (245)   ranked 32 out of 133 in one tree hill   2 years ago

I think Lucas' pride is getting in the way of him being with Peyton. She said not now to him when he proposed and now she is practically begging him to take her back. She should have thought about that before he met Lindsay. I mean I think deep down he does want Peyton but I guess he is afraid that she only wants him now because he is with Lindsay. Also, maybe he doesn't want to hurt Lindsay's feelings by choosing a past love over his current love. Maybe he is just confused right now.


myLot reputation of 95/100. speedy1279 (1490)   ranked 2 out of 133 in one tree hill  2 years ago

What you have said does make a lot of sense. Lucas is probably very confused. So we will just have to wait and see how this all plays out. Hopefully they won't make us have to wait that long.

King Tree Experts, Inc Read this Shrub & Tree Service's reviews & find Lawn & Garden Info. Atlanta.Citysearch.com
 
sponsors
If You Luv One Tree Hill
You'll luv Secret Life. See the new show Jan 4 on ABC Family at 8/7c
www.ABCFamily.go.com

Spider Vein Treatment - No. VA
McLean Vein Center Offers Multiple Treatments for Spider Veins.
DC.Vein-Treatment.com

Free Estimates - Ajs Tree
Tree trimming, pruning& stump grinding. Fully Insured.
AJsTree.localplacement.com

similar discussions
Do you support Nathan and Haley
Do you support Nathan and Haley? Always and Forever!
Will Lucas and Lindsey get back together, or should he go to Payton?
I hope he chooses Payton. They are destined to be together, and he wrote 2 whole books about her!...
Where do you get your OTH spoilers from?
I get mine from YouTube videos or http://onetreehillblog.com
How do you feel about Antwon/Skills leaving?
How do you feel about him leaving? I am kind of sad about it, but I know what has to be done has to...
Do you think Peyton on One Tree Hill will live?
Well...do you think she will survive the pregnancy?
Would you buy Brooke's clothes?
Do you like her fashion line? Would you buy it if you could?
Anyone boycotting One Tree Hill
Has anyone boycotted watching one tree hill since Lucas and Peyton are now off the show. I realized...
sponsors
If You Luv One Tree Hill
You'll luv Secret Life. See the new show Jan 4 on ABC Family at 8/7c
www.ABCFamily.go.com
Spider Vein Treatment - No. VA
McLean Vein Center Offers Multiple Treatments for Spider Veins.
DC.Vein-Treatment.com
Free Estimates - Ajs Tree
Tree trimming, pruning & stump grinding. Fully Insured.
AJsTree.localplacement.com
3B Tree Removal & More
Trimming, grinding, emergency tree service. Read our reviews online.
3BTree.localplacement.com
Tree & Stump Removal
Land clearing, tree trimming, stump grinding. Free estimates. Cal.
ericwalter.localplacement.com
For Your Tree Care Needs
Call us for removal, cable and bracing, stump grinding, trimming.
www.treesofcarolina.com
Everett Tree Services
Tree Removal, tree cutting, stump grinding. View our website.
www.EverettTreeService.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.