United States - A "Christian Nation"?

United States
March 6, 2008 8:32pm CST
I have recently seen a lot of studies that suggest that between 75 and 82% of citizens in the United States claim to be mostly Christian. If this is so, then why are so many people opposed to basing the country on what we put on our money; "In God We Trust" and why is it so hard to have the 10 Commandments up in Public places? Why is prayer a difficult thing for schools to accept? Why do people consider themselves Christians? What makes you a "Christian" by what these people have stated to believing? Do you categorize a Christian as being someone who believes the Bible or someone who just thinks that there could be a God out there? Or do you think the 17 - 25% of people who don't claim to be Christians are the ones who speak out the most in our country?
3 people like this
4 responses
@lecanis (16647)
• Murfreesboro, Tennessee
7 Mar 08
Because the rest of us still feel like we should have rights, and shouldn't have someone else's religion forced on us just because we're in the minority. I grew up in a town that was almost solely Christian, and I had to deal with discrimination for my beliefs every single day, from when I was a small child to the time I moved away at 17. It wasn't fun. Prayer in school encourages discrimination because it makes any child who doesn't want to participate an outcast. Likewise, any public endorsement of a specific religion by people in power encourages such discrimination. If the United States is a Christian nation, does that mean that I'm not an American because I'm not Christian, even though I was born here?
1 person likes this
• United States
7 Mar 08
I'm not talking about forcing any religion on one another, like prayer being forced, but rather being allowed in school. If a student wants to go and pray let them - I've so many friends who got in trouble for doing such. I am not saying that people who aren't Christian aren't American. Just wondering why it's considered a Christian nation when it clearly is not.
2 people like this
@lecanis (16647)
• Murfreesboro, Tennessee
7 Mar 08
Sorry if I misunderstood. I'll admit to being a bit touchy on this topic sometimes. When I was growing up, no one ever got in trouble for praying, but I got in trouble for even mentioning my religion. Then again, it was small-town Kentucky, and that was a while ago now. I can't really say what schools are like now, though I'll find out in a few years when my son is in school. I'm hoping Michigan schools are better than Kentucky schools were. :P I have nothing against students praying of their own volition, as long as it's allowed for every religion and not just Christianity. As for the percentages, I think a lot of people who grew up Christian but don't consider themselves religious still put Christian on surveys and such by default. I know tons of people with Christian parents who aren't religious themselves at all but still refer to themselves as Christian because it's their parents' religion. Also, a lot of people who aren't Christian claim to be just because it's socially acceptable. I can think of at least 20 people I know off the bat who aren't Christian but have claimed to be just to avoid family or social conflict.
1 person likes this
@lecanis (16647)
• Murfreesboro, Tennessee
8 Mar 08
You say what I'm thinking better than I do, anniepa! :P I feel the same way about the prayer issue. I can pray anywhere, silently by myself, and there isn't really anything anyone could do to stop me. I don't see why it would be any different for Christians. I wouldn't want my child taught about the Bible in school either, and not for the reasons you may think. I've read the Bible myself, and I fully intend for my child to learn about a lot of religions, including Christianity. But I want to be able to supervise that learning, because if my child does choose to be Christian, I'm hoping he'll be one like my husband who focuses on the positive points of that religion rather than like some people I know whose Christianity seems to lead them to hate and judge everyone else. I want to be able to help my child determine which parts of the Bible have more to do with the culture of the time than anything religious, and which parts have been misinterpreted and used for the wrong reasons over the years. I wouldn't want my child to be taught about my own religion in school, either, for very similar reasons. Just because someone claims the same beliefs you do doesn't mean their intentions are good, and I wouldn't trust just anyone with my child's religious education.
@heathcliff (1415)
• United States
7 Mar 08
What about the theory that America already is run by the "religion" of capitalism. A person cannot, ultimately, serve two masters and at their moment of truth, most capitalists will look to make money, or at least survive financially, instead of living devoted to their "God". If you argue that capitalism is not a religion, it ultimately doesn't matter what you call it if it takes people away from what they call their religion. Should the dollar say, "In Profit We Trust"? Certainly don't see anywhere near 75% of Americans ACTING "Christian". They can call themselves whatever they want.
@anniepa (27955)
• United States
8 Mar 08
You ask a lot of questions in this post so I decided the easiest way to respond is to take it one question and statement at a time. "I have recently seen a lot of studies that suggest that between 75 and 82% of citizens in the United States claim to be mostly Christian." I touched on that in a response to another response here; I'm not at all sure how accurate that figure is because there are many people I know personally who would probably list themselves as "Christian" but if the truth were told they're more "religion neutral", if there is such a thing. "If this is so, then why are so many people opposed to basing the country on what we put on our money; "In God We Trust" and why is it so hard to have the 10 Commandments up in Public places?" Quite simply, since we have a Separation of Church and State, Bible passages are not appropriate on government buildings. "Why is prayer a difficult thing for schools to accept?" Again, in public schools it's not appropriate for a prayer of a particular faith to be recited; as someone else here said, those who choose not to participate would be considered outcasts. However, if someone wants to have a silent prayer, no one can stop them. Why isn't that enough? "Why do people consider themselves Christians? What makes you a "Christian" by what these people have stated to believing? Do you categorize a Christian as being someone who believes the Bible or someone who just thinks that there could be a God out there? Or do you think the 17 - 25% of people who don't claim to be Christians are the ones who speak out the most in our country?" Obviously , some people who "consider themselves Christians" truly are very devout Christians who live the total Christian life. However, many among this 75-82% are considered Christians because they haven't told anyone any different. Maybe they got married in a Christian church or were baptized as a baby or child. Possibly their parents or grandparents were church members but they themselves rarely set foot in a church but they're still part of this questionable statistic. I believe it should be as our founders intended - we have the right to worship or not as we please and the government shouldn't have any say or control over it either way. Annie
• Malaysia
7 Mar 08
I think USA is a secular country, and most of developed countries are secular country. There's secular people who don't go to Church, Mosque, Temple, etc.. they mostly think about science, economic, and how can they develop their country rather than how can they be a good religious person and spread their religion. Sometimes being secular is better than being radical. Indeed, many Hollywood artists are not Christians. I heard that Scientology will become the most popular religion among the celebrities.
1 person likes this