sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Helicopter Moms vs. Free-Range Kids  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 74/100. icyorchid (1382)   ranked 981 out of 9,012 in parenting 4 years ago

A New York columnist lets her grade-schooler ride the subway alone, provoking a wave of criticism. But do kids really need more supervision than in generations past?

Would you let your fourth-grader ride public transportation without an adult? Probably not. Still, when Lenore Skenazy, a columnist for the New York Sun, wrote about letting her son take the subway alone to get back to her Manhattan home from a department store on the Upper East Side, she didn't expect to get hit with a tsunami of criticism from readers.

"Long story short: My son got home, ecstatic with independence," Skenazy wrote on April 4 in the New York Sun. "Long story longer: Half the people I've told this episode to now want to turn me in for child abuse. As if keeping kids under lock and key and helmet and cell phone and nanny and surveillance is the right way to rear kids. It's not. It's debilitating—for us and for them."

For more of the story: http://www.newsweek.com/id/133103?GT1=43002

 

parenting
sponsors
Ask a Lawyer: Child Law
12 Family Lawyers Are Online! Ask a Question, Get an Answer ASAP.
JustAnswer.com/Law/Child

Publish a Children's Book
More Flexible Royalties, Lower Book Prices& New Expanded Distribution
www.BookSurge.com

Self-Publish Your Book
Check Out New Publishing Services& Get 555 Free Book Promotion Tips.
www.CreateSpace.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  mature content, child-rearing, children, independence, independence for children
 
1. myLot reputation of 97/100. Malyck (1680)   ranked 470 out of 9,012 in parenting   4 years ago

Okay, so grade four, that's around 10 or 11, right?

Personally, I don't have a problem with this, I mean obviously the son is familiar with the area and was happy to take the trip alone.
I've been walking and catching public transport alone since I was 9 or 10 also.
I mean obviously not all the time, but my parents and I both knew that it was unnecessary to be escorted everywhere.

Obviously it's different for everyone, depending on their own views on parenting, their child's personality and maturity etc, but I don't think that anyone has the right to tell her what she did was wrong.

The world can be unsafe, but unfortunately we can't always shelter other people, even children, from this, even if we are right there with them.

=)

Live and let live, I think.
I wouldn't berate her for her choice with her own child, even if I wouldn't do the same thing myself if I had children.

=D
Have a great day!
Mal.

Ask a Lawyer: Child Law 12 Family Lawyers Are Online! Ask a Question, Get an Answer ASAP.  JustAnswer.com/Law/Child
 
2. myLot reputation of 99/100. KissThis (2638)   ranked 31 out of 9,012 in parenting   4 years ago

I think as a parent its my job to do the best job I can to keep my child safe. Personally I wouldn't allow my child to roam free till they are a teenager and even then I would still make them check in every so often after I get all the details on where and what they would be doing. Before I allow my children to do anything I ask myself what would the worse case scenario be and could I love with the consequences. My daughter just informed me that she was getting teased at school because I don't allow her to roam free around town like the other children in her class get to. I explained to my daughter why I feel the way that I do. I don't feel it is safe to allow children as much freedom these days because of hearing about kidnappings and children going missing. I live in a small hick town that might have 1500 people at most but I have heard of two children going missing from here.

Publish a Children's Book More Flexible Royalties, Lower Book Prices & New Expanded Distribution  www.BookSurge.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 36/100. wickedangel (1384)   ranked 2,466 out of 9,012 in parenting   4 years ago

These people are so silly reacting like this. Not too long ago children were forced out of their homes at the ages of 11 to go to work so that the rest of the family could eat. These kids would work in incredibly dangerous environments where machines could kill them if they weren't quick enough to move out of the way.

I bet we all remember the first time we were allowed to go to school or come home on our own. Our parents were probably scared to death that something would happen but children need to learn how to fly from the nest, slowly but surely. It isn't as if at the age of 16 they are suddenly allowed out, have money, go out with their friends.

Some people are over protective of their kids and it doesn't help them and anyway children need a bit of independence to learn from their own mistakes too! I started going to school on my own when I was 8. My mother didn't want to do this but it was the only way I could get to school and she could be at work on time. I am still here and I learnt by my adventures.

Thanks for sharing that with us icy.

Self-Publish Your Book Check Out New Publishing Services & Get 555 Free Book Promotion Tips.  www.CreateSpace.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 87/100. youdontsay (2050)   ranked 1,175 out of 9,012 in parenting   4 years ago

This post contains content of a mature nature. You must be Signed in or Registered to have the option to view this content.

Children's Room Décor Everything You Need For Your Child's Room Or Nursery!  rosenberryrooms.com
 
sponsors
Children's Room Décor
Everything You Need For Your Child's Room Or Nursery!
rosenberryrooms.com

The Dentist's Office Blog
Sharing how to run a quality, successful& profitable practice
dentistoffice.blogspot.com/

Dental Marketing Company
Find Dental Marketing Company Near You. See Actual Customer Reviews!
Local.com

similar discussions
Religion : the true intent..
Hi lotters.. Its just a theory of mine.. so if you disagree, feel free to share your...
Is my friend a lesbian? (confused)
I have this close friend of mine who is acting a bit weird these days. I don't know but my family...
Do you smoke this..
I would not want to smoke for some good reasons. The main one being it is a habit I can't afford. I...
Forgive and Forget... Is it really possible?
It is always hard to forgive but in the act of forgiveness, forgetting is usually the hardest part....
sponsors
Children's Room Décor
Everything You Need For Your Child's Room Or Nursery!
rosenberryrooms.com
The Dentist's Office Blog
Sharing how to run a quality, successful & profitable practice
dentistoffice.blogspot.com/
Dental Marketing Company
Find Dental Marketing Company Near You. See Actual Customer Reviews!
Local.com
Sjogren's Syndrome
Treatment Options, Latest Advances. Trustworthy, Current Report.
www.sjogrens-guidebook.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.