Awww... :(

I failed to watched it...so i dont have an idea whom you talking. Who was out of american idol?

who was in the bottom 2?

I hated to see Brooke go also. She was one of my favorites on American Idol besides David Arculeta. I wasn't surprised in a way because her first song Tuesday night wasn't that great. I was hoping the second song she had sung saved her.

Well, if the show were truly based on talent, she would have been gone before Michael Johns and Carly Smithson. Brooke was ok, but vocally and entertainment wise, she was below Michael and Carly. I have been surprised by Seyisha. She has stepped her game up. But I'm not sure it's enough to keep her on the show. It's fixing to get ugly folks. With it being down to David Cook, David Archuletta, Jason Castro and Seyisha Mercado, there's going to be some outraged fans next week. While my opion is just that, my opinion, I would like to see a David Cook-Jason Castro finale. Unfortunately I don't think that will happen. I think it's going to be a David Cook-David Archuletta finale. I'm not sure who will get the axe next week, but I believe it will be either Seyisha or Jason. They've been pimping Archuletta pretty bad. The local fox station in KC, MO has been doing special reports on David Cook on the 9pm news each Wednesday. I just discovered that last nite. I'll have to stick around and watch next week!

I liked Brooke alot, I thought the bottom 2 should have been her and Jason Castro or Seisha and Jason Castro with Jason going home. David Cook is my favourite and Brooke my second. I really like her singing (for the most part.)