homeinterestsdiscussionsblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLot
web | myLot | discussions | blogs | news | photos
 
 

Fishing email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 64/100. wooitsmolly (1384)   ranked 11 out of 134 in thinking2 months ago

My boyfriend went out to a cabin with his dad and said they are going fishing. I asked him not to, but he said he is doing it anyway. He thinks it is okay because they are only doing catch and release. I do not see the point in doing that at all... I mean, they are not even trying to catch fish to eat... I didn't feel like arguing about it, he can do what he wants, so I said fine and dropped it.

What I want to know is why do people think that fish cannot feel pain? I hear this all the time (even my boyfriend the vegetarian who doesn't even eat fish said this!)

Do you think it is true that fish do not feel pain?


Fishy fishy
 
 
thinking
sponsors
Mini Planer Boards You Can Steer
Give them a little tug to flip direction. Starting at $2.50.
www.bulletbobber.com

Portable Fishing Boats by Porta-Bote
Porta-Bote folding boats revolutionized the world of fishing boats.
www.porta-bote.com

pain
Learn about the causes, symptoms, and treatments for Arthritis.
www.HealthTalk.com

whywiki (2661) response was accepted on 5/11/2008.
denotes best response.
tags:  fish, animals, fishing, pain, life
 
1. myLot reputation of 93/100. sedel1027 (10526)   ranked 114 out of 134 in thinking   2 months ago

I am the exact opposite. To me any animal with nerve endings can feel pain.

I believe that people do not think fish can feel pain because they can not cry or make other noise.

Fishing is really cruel, those poor fish suffocate. I can just imagine how cruel of a death that would be.


myLot reputation of 64/100. wooitsmolly (1384)   ranked 11 out of 134 in thinking  2 months ago

Yes, I agree with you 100%. I could never fish. I do not even want to think about the poor wormy getting hooked on the line:\

Mini Planer Boards You Can Steer Give them a little tug to flip direction. Starting at $2.50. www.bulletbobber.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 94/100. whywiki (2661)   ranked 107 out of 134 in thinking   2 months ago

I think fish feel pain. I grew up on boats and around fishermen. My mom was a fishing guide. I used to love going out on the boat. I would hide in the cabin when the murders would take place. I caught a salmon once and whacked it over the head. That was 30 years ago and I still feel bad about it. What gave me the right to kill this fish. So from that day on I was not into the whole fishing thing which made me really popular with the family! I have a friend that does the catch and release thing. I thought how sweet at first then thought about it. This poor hungry little fish swimming around looking for food, so hungry that he takes a chance and gets a hook stuck in his lip. Then he has the fight of his life to get free, worried he or she will die and who will look after his family? Then he gets hauled out of the water and can't breath. Then manhandled and thrown back in where he is separated from his friends and family who are off mourning his death. Then he has to recover with this big hole in his mouth and search for his family. It seems a little bit cruel to me. So I think that they feel pain and they feel love too. I am anti hunting too but that is another rant...


myLot reputation of 64/100. wooitsmolly (1384)   ranked 11 out of 134 in thinking  2 months ago

Yes, I agree with you. I do not like hunting either. I think if people want to hunt since they think it is the natural "food chain" and "circle of life" and all that other nonsense maybe they should try doing it with their bare hands instead of a rifle... since, you know, it's so natural for them. Oh no, here I go! Don't even get me started! Humans think they own all the animals of the world and just want to forget that we, too, are animals and dammit if we aren't made the same way all other animals are, with feelings and instincts. It will be a fine day when we die out and the rest of the animal kingdom can take back the earth. I gotta stop myself now!!!

Portable Fishing Boats by Porta-Bote Porta-Bote folding boats revolutionized the world of fishing boats. www.porta-bote.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 78/100. Xdrowninghavocx (1607)   ranked 50 out of 134 in thinking   2 months ago

I have never heard that statement before. Fish are alive so why shouldn't they be able to feel pain? I think that's a strange statement to make, especially since one has never been a fish before. I definitely would not rule out pain as a probability.


myLot reputation of 64/100. wooitsmolly (1384)   ranked 11 out of 134 in thinking  2 months ago

I have heard many times people call fish "swimming vegetables". A lot of people do not know they are animals, truthfully! Many do not consider them "meat" hahaha what is this world coming to?!

pain Learn about the causes, symptoms, and treatments for Arthritis. www.HealthTalk.com
 
sponsors
Mbna sport Credit Cards
0% Intro APR on Bal. Transfers Earn Pts, Rewards, Cashback APPLY HERE.
millionairecreditcards.com

Cabela's Fishing Supplies
Find Essential Fishing Supplies Outdoor Apparel at Cabela's Online.
www.Cabelas.com

Quick& Easy Recipes
Find Healthy& Fun Recipes Your Family Will Love.
www.Family.com

similar discussions


mother_earth
(48)
Fish

Because of the tragedy about the ship and still many dead people are inside on it, and on the seashore, can you eat fish like tuna or blue marlin or even the lapu-lapu?

Started by mother_earth (48) in cooking • 1 response • Last response by vanities (6670) • 8 hours ago
Tags: fish, fisherman, forbidden, leaks, ship

hiccup
(2751)
* This is NO Goldfish, catfish57.*

This one's for my (mate) friend catfish57. You will need to look at the picture to get an Idea of the size of this fish. (click on the picture to make larger) This is a Murray Cod The Guy is Gus...

Started by hiccup (2751) in goldfish • 18 responses • Last response by diansinta (3263) • 12 hours ago
Tags: fish, fishing, cape cod, catch, cod fish

maryann82
(39)
then rice shortage now fish scare

after typhoon frank hit the philippines during which mv princess of the star sank we are now experiencing fish scare due to some reasons like the sunken ship has a cargo of poisonous substance called...

Started by maryann82 (39) • 1 response • Last response by lilaclady (13997) • 1 day ago
Tags: fish, people, polution, rice

maleek49
(58)
I need four fish names!

Just got four fish and I need names.What are some random cute unique fish names. But they are naughty all like bite each other and fight for food?

Started by maleek49 (58) in fish • 10 responses • Last response by Hatley (8650) • 1 day ago
Tags: fish, bite, eachother, fighter, names

Ldyjarhead
(2829)
Odd Pizza Toppings

A recent discussion talked about pizza not being pizza anymore and it prompted me to start this. What type of pizza toppings do you NOT like or think are just plain weird?Now I've tried lots...

Started by Ldyjarhead (2829) in pizza • 35 responses • Last response by cwilson26 (1260) • 1 day ago
Tags: pizza, toppings, food, cheese, fish
  privacy  •  terms  •  about myLot  •  legal  •  contact  •  FAQs  •  RSS  •  toolbar  •  guidelines  •  advertise  

©2008 myLot™. All Rights Reserved.