sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Do you keep betta fish in the same tank?  email this discussion to a friend?

hoopgurl333 (61)   ranked 7 out of 27 in betta fish 4 years ago

I've always heard that betta fish cannot live together in the same tank unless it is a male and a female pair. The females aren't vibrant colors like the males, so most people have the male betta fish. One day last week I was in the pet store and saw two bright colored betta males swimming in a tank with other fish. I asked the boy working there and he said that they can live together if the other fish are slightly aggressive. I have never seen this before and always been told differently. When I went back to the store yesterday, neither of the betta's were in the tank. I don't know if they were purchased or moved (hopefully nothing bad!!) but I was wondering if any of you knew the truth? Can you keep them with other fish and can you keep two bettas in the same tank without a fight??

 

betta fish
sponsors
fish
Get the High Protein Diet You Need. See Info on Kashi® Foods!
www.kashi.com

Seafood Restaurants
Seafood Restaurants in Your Area
yellowpages.com

Your Favorite Restaurant
Could be featured for 50-90% off today. Find old favorites& new gems!
www.Groupon.com/Sign-Up

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  aggressive, betta fish, fish, fish tank, mature content
 
1. myLot reputation of 92/100. keasling (378)   4 years ago

i have always been told they have to be separated. This is very interesting. Please let me know if you find out the truth.
Thank you soo much for posting

fish Get the High Protein Diet You Need. See Info on Kashi® Foods!  www.kashi.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 97/100. ersmommy1 (11456)   4 years ago

This post contains content of a mature nature. You must be Signed in or Registered to have the option to view this content.

Seafood Restaurants Seafood Restaurants in Your Area  yellowpages.com
 
3. thehoodoo (26)   ranked 8 out of 27 in betta fish   4 years ago

There is no way to keep two male bettas in the same tank. They'll fight each other to death. Females on the other hand, CAN be kept in the same tank. Initially they will fight amongst each other to establish a pecking order. But eventually the order will be established and they'll be able to coexist. Sometimes though you get cases of repeated bullying. Then you have to seperate the female being victimized or it'll die. I've kept a group of about 15 females in a large 30 gallon tank before without problems. Males ALWAYS have to be seperated.

Your Favorite Restaurant Could be featured for 50-90% off today. Find old favorites & new gems!  www.Groupon.com/Sign-Up
 
4. myLot reputation of 99/100. walijo2008 (4169)   4 years ago

I've always heard that they will kill each other if you have them in the same tank. I had two, and they were in the same tank but it was divided by a wall, but they could see each other,and they would swim up to the wall like they wanted to fight, their gills on their sides would flare out, it was wierd watching them. I knew if I had them together one of them probably would of been dead. I don't think you can keep them together.

Blue Bank Resort Stay where Bill Dance Kevin VanDam & the rest of the pros stay.  www.bluebankresort.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 95/100. CinderInMySoul (4337)   4 years ago

i am 99.9% positive that you CANNOT keep two male bettas in the same tank, no matter what other fish you have in there.
and if the other fish are "slightly aggressive" that is dangerous to the bettas, because their fins make easy bully targets and will be quickly shredded!!

bettas are very territorial when it comes to members of their own species. a male wants to be the ONLE MALE in his "area" (tank) that way he is guaranteed to get the girls lol!

id bet my very last dollar that those 2 bettas were gone the next day for 1 of 2 reasons. #1 they killed each other (they WILL fight to the death) OR #2 someone with more knowledge about the species saw them going at it and seperated them from each and from the "slightly aggressive" fish in the tank.

hopefully the second one happened. how awful would it be that they both died because some moron thought he knew it all?!

Healthy Happy Puppies Adorable Puppies from Responsible Breeders with Health Guarantee  CaliforniaPuppiesforSale.com
 
6. Manns151 (1)   4 years ago

Male Betta fish are very aggresive (hold a mirror up to their fish bowl or aquariam, watch them puff their cheeks). Male betta fish can live with no less or no more than 4 female Betta fish. Male bettas can also live with algee eaters or bottom feeders. They can't live with other male bettas ever!!!!!

It is problay the best to keep male beta fish alone or get algee/ bottom feeders. I wouldn't suggest putting females with a male. Because if they mate, the mother of the babies is a canibal. She will eat her baby betas.

Hope i helped,
Peace Out Peeps!

Fish Tank Looking For Fish Tank? Find It Nearby With Local.com!  Local.com
 
sponsors
Blue Bank Resort
Stay where Bill Dance Kevin VanDam& the rest of the pros stay.
www.bluebankresort.com

Healthy Happy Puppies
Adorable Puppies from Responsible Breeders with Health Guarantee
CaliforniaPuppiesforSale.com

Fish Tank
Looking For Fish Tank? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com

similar discussions
Help my dog is being aggressive after having puppies!!!
I have two small dogs, the girl just recently had puppies there about 5 days old. Ever since the...
What's Your Nature- Calm,Aggressive,Short tempered orArrogant
I am basically a calm person.Ofcourse all men/women show different reactions depending on the...
Who is more aggressive man or woman?
I heard so many discussions and murmur on who is more aggressive is it the man or woman?? Normally...
Aggressive
Am now aggressive to earn money in my lot. I put and effort to work,spend my time.and also...
Which is better passive or agressive women?
I'm confused. I have a friend who said that men needs to be pushed to make a move. I also have a...
Shy Type or Aggressive?
Would you prefer a shy type girl (guy) or an aggressive guy (girl)? A good guy (girl) or a bad...
sponsors
Blue Bank Resort
Stay where Bill Dance Kevin VanDam & the rest of the pros stay.
www.bluebankresort.com
Healthy Happy Puppies
Adorable Puppies from Responsible Breeders with Health Guarantee
CaliforniaPuppiesforSale.com
Fish Tank
Looking For Fish Tank? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com
Discount Fishing Tackle
Crankbaits $1.25 Poppers $1.99 Swimbait $1.99 Spinnerbait $.99
www.themangler.com
Aggressive
Find Aggressive Online. Free Shipping $50 on 100,000 Items!
Target.com/FreeShipping
Canaan Valley Vacation
Affordable Ski Lodging, Hot Tubs, Fireplaces, Pets, Online Discounts!
www.mountaintoprentals.net
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.