sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionsblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLot

Should Jack have died in the water? email this discussion to a friend?

jlr0407 (11)   ranked 571 out of 662 in titanic4 months ago

I think that even though he was trying to be a gentleman and let her be on top of the board, they should have taken turns being on it so that they both could have had the chance of living happily ever after together. He deserved just as much a chance of living too.

 
 
titanic
sponsors
Audi A5 Model Years
Get A5 Info from Experts Free News, Pics, Video& More.
www.InsideLine.com

2008-09 2008 Audi A5 Bargains
Get Audi Car Dealer's Weekly Specials, Rebates, Discounts.
CarBargainsWeekly.com/a5

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  titanic, jack, jack dawson, rose, death
 
1. myLot reputation of 95/100. cher913 (8193)   ranked 19 out of 662 in titanic   4 months ago

sure but with the water and air temperature as cold as it was (in real life) they wouldnt have had a chance anyways, hyperthermia would have set in very quickly. (the water and the air were around freezing).

Audi A5 Model Years Get A5 Info from Experts Free News, Pics, Video & More. www.InsideLine.com
 
2. kirisryche (3)   4 months ago

well the water must have been a little less colder that the air, i think rose had to die first, if it were real. because she was wet and whit the air that cold she had to die first.

2008-09 2008 Audi A5 Bargains Get Audi Car Dealer's Weekly Specials, Rebates, Discounts. CarBargainsWeekly.com/a5
 
3. myLot reputation of 94/100. karadiablo (278)   4 months ago

The real point of this movie was there was no happy ending. There so many people who died and if both hero and heroin would have lived the movie would not have been as beautiful, or nor would it have had such a turn out. Sometimes love needs to seperate to tear out or hearts and make us realise how precious it all really is.

 
4. myLot reputation of 72/100. schummi (769)   ranked 222 out of 662 in titanic   4 months ago

how can it be man....it was a cold water below zero degrees and its the basic duty of men to just go through all the physical and by far keep our love aways from it...i think he might have thought bout as u have said...but outa tiredness and weakness...rose fell asleep....and how could he have wake her up???.I think it was perfectly logical thing to do.....

 
5. ashwin9960 (7)   4 months ago

I think
jack was a idiot of all time

 
6. myLot reputation of 90/100. pearl1003 (615)   3 months ago

well, he died coz of the cold, his heart could hav stopped. he cant for sure take in turns with rose. why would he? would u let ur girlfriend dip in cold freezing water? i dont think so.

 
similar discussions
How many times have u actually watched Titanic?
I would say 10 times,and 4 of them I cried when Rose jumped back to the ship;4 of them I didn't...
how many times did you watch titanic?
for me,i watched it almost 50 times.
Have you watched the Titanic?
I love the movie. Although it has been years when I first watched this, I keep thinking of the...
Titanic Songs
Hi to all Do You like Titanic Song??? I Don't like English Songs But Like Titanic Songs as Well...
My daughter
I am so proud of my daughter. She is getting more into her writing and has become the first person...
The Notebook or the Titanic?
Which was the most romantic movie? I love both movies so much that I can't choose!