An unassisted labor?
By maximax8
@maximax8 (31042)
United Kingdom
July 18, 2008 12:19pm CST
A couple of weeks ago I saw a program about ladies having babies without any medical assistance. There is a website that promotes this and gives the women advice how to deliver their baby themselves. One lady in the UK found that her health authority wouldn't give her any equipment. She had to set about getting all the things necessary for the birth like sterile scissors herself. Sadly she had to go to a hospital to deliver her placenta. One lady in the USA gave birth in a water pool really calmly. Everything went really well for her.
I have had two home births, but with two midwifes present.
What do you think of free birthing and unassisted labor?
What sort of labor to you prefer: home, hospital, active, medical?
Thanks.
2 people like this
8 responses
@maddysmommy (16230)
• United States
24 Jul 08
I don't think I could do it. I would rather be in a hospital having nurses, midwives and doctors take care of me. If something went wrong then at least medical help was there right away.

@maddysmommy (16230)
• United States
24 Jul 08
Yes he was. My first child, I didn't want to risk anything so flew from Samoa to New Zealand to have him.

@ellie333 (21016)
•
18 Jul 08
I knew in advance that I would have problems with my pregnancies and would need general anesethic caesarians so I never really thought about this. I think ideally I would have liked to experience a labour and to have had a water birth but with the medical profession present. Years ago a lot of babies and a lot of women did die through childbirth so if there were complications I would like someone else present like you having the midwife there for you. Ellie :D
@maximax8 (31042)
• United Kingdom
19 Jul 08
Yes, I felt happier knowing that the midwifes were there Ellie. It is a shame that you needed C-Sections but it was good that you knew in advance. An emergency one would be very scary I imagine. A labor in water is so relaxing but staying alive and having a healthy baby are what every lady wants.
1 person likes this
@ravinskye (8237)
• United States
21 Jul 08
i couldn't imagine giving birth without any health professionals there. what would happen if there was something wrong? they may teach you how to deliver your own baby, but what if something happens? what if the cord is wrapped around the babies neck? what if you need a c-section? i guess if you want to do it yourself and have a hospital nearby, but still. i think doing a home birth isn't bad since you had a midwife with you. i had all three of my kids in the hospital, but here we can choose midwife or doctor and i chose midwife with all three. i just felt like they knew what i was going through more than some. funny thing is with my son my midwife had actually just came back from her maternity leave right before i had him. 

@maximax8 (31042)
• United Kingdom
24 Jul 08
You make some very good points about the safety of an unassisted birth. All may go well but in the worst scenario the cord could be wrapped around the babies neck. In such a case then a midwife would be able to make alternative plans but a lady on her own might just panic. It must have been funny to see your midwife had her maternity leave then delivered your baby.
@foxyfire33 (10005)
• United States
21 Jul 08
I think a woman should be able to choose whatever she feels is best for her. I have had only hospital births. With the first 4 I never even considered an alternative. With number 5 I discussed using a midwife but s/o thought it was too dangerous and I ultimately gave in. With number 6 I wanted an unassisted birth. I was fully prepared. After 17 hours of labor though s/o was getting panicky and annoying so he drove me to the hospital...I stretched it to an hour drive because I insisted it was too uncomfortable when he drove faster, in reality I was just hoping the baby would hurry up and be born before we got there. I delivered about an hour after arriving and that hour and the following 1/2 were the most uncomfortable parts of the labor and delivery. I'd spent the whole 17 hours at home walking and using various positive positions because I have always experienced painful back labor...the hospital put me in bed immediately, on my back and then after the baby left be sitting there legs spread in an uncomfortable position because they "didn't want to clean the bed up yet since they'd have to do it again so soon"...it was a totally unrelaxing position and put more strain on certain places than the delivery did.
Anyway, there won't be any more babies I'm sure but if I did have another I would again push the issue of not delivering in a hospital. I feel very strongly that woman with no obvious risks can delivery more safely and with fewer complications if they can deliver in a setting that makes them most comfortable. If that happens to be in a medical setting then that's their choice, but I feel non medical deliveries can be safer if the mother and others present educate themselves and properly prepare for the birth.
@maximax8 (31042)
• United Kingdom
24 Jul 08
Wow! You have had six children so it is great that you have replied to my discussion. Yes, it is lovely if a pregnant lady feels totally comfortable about where she is having her baby. Some people like the security of medical equipment in a hospital. I think that a midwife led unit is a more relaxing setting. Home is only right if the pregnant lady feels happy about this and her midwife think it would be safe. I thought that if a lady has six children each of her labors would be of a shorter duration so I am surprised that you had a labor of 17 hours with your 6th child. It must be awful to have strong back pain and I guess getting into a supportive and comfortable positions helps.
@ShealM (388)
• Canada
19 Jul 08
Despite my medically necessary hospital births I support unassisted pregnancies and unassisted childbirth when the pregnancy and birth are not high risk. I support informed consent and informed birthing and pregnancy. It is a woman's choice on how she wants to birth but it is also her responsibility to insure the health of her baby and herself. IF there is a problem during an unassisted childbirth then it is both her and the father's responsibility to seek medical help.
I support it and I believe in it. I've never had one, nor could I have had one with my high risk preterm and preemie history. I have what is called a bicorneated uterus (reactive double chamber) and had a uterine rupture with my 4th child. I am very high risk and unassisted childbirth is not an option, neither is home birthing (unfortunately). I envy the women strong enough to do something like this, it takes a lot of courage and strength and self confidence to do it.
Kuddos to them and I support their decisions fully.
@maximax8 (31042)
• United Kingdom
19 Jul 08
You have written some lovely things about the ladies brave enough to take on unassisted labor. In my second pregnancy I was so sacred about the labor and what might happen during the birth. But all was fine, with a quick labor and only 20 minutes of it was strong pain. I am so sorry that you have a bicorneated uterus. It must have been terrible when you had a uterine rupture during the labor of your 4th child. Thanks for an excellent response.
@gabbana (1815)
• China
19 Jul 08
I once read a report on newspaper: a school girl about 15 was preganent who lives with her grandmother with poor eyesight. The girl finally gave birth to her baby in the toilet. During all those months, her grandmother didn't find out. poor girl and poor granny. Being afaid of criticisim , the girl tried hard to hide.
@nannacroc (4049)
•
18 Jul 08
All my girls were born in hospital but I would much rather have been at home. I don't think a birth without access to medical help if necessary is a good idea but can't see any problem with a home birth and a midwife there. I know people in less developed countries deliver their babies with no medical help but there is always an older, experienced woman there to assist if necessary. We in the west have lost this and so really need medical assistance from a midwife.
@maximax8 (31042)
• United Kingdom
18 Jul 08
Yes, some ladies in the developed countries prefer unassisted labor like is common in some less developed countries. It is interesting that you would have preferred to have had your labors at home but with a midwife. Thanks for your very good response.
@marketing07 (6266)
• South Korea
18 Jul 08
hi maxima, for me an assisted labor is to dangerous...i wont risk it.. i prefer to give birth to the hospital..i had a ceasarian operation with my 2 kids coz i cant give birth normally.. 

@maximax8 (31042)
• United Kingdom
19 Jul 08
It is a shame that you a need C-Section when you have a baby. I was born in that way because my mum had a difficult labor when she had my sister. I guess some women just can't have a baby naturally. Thanks for sharing your experience my friend Marketing07.









