Which is your favorite judge for american idol

I seldom watch the show and have mostly just seen reruns but from what I observe I like Randy the best. Simon is cruel and Paula at times just seems zoned out.

Yeah I guess mines Simon also.,most of his comments are pretty funny and amusing

I like Simon unless he's being unnecessarily cruel. Which he can certainly be sometimes. It's one thing to critique a performance and say it wasn't up to par, but to call names or something seems unprofessional. Except during the audition process because some of those people need the reality check and half of them know they're not good enough and are just trying to get on TV.

mine is simon,very harsh but i'm loving him!hehe..

Simon. He knew what the problems of the players were and pointed them out, but he expressed them totally directly.

I like Simon. He's honest and funny^^

Simon.:)

He is harsh but he always has a point when he is harsh. Lol.:D