Sould we blame the addicts?  |
|
Drug, alcohol or food addicts: is it their fault, or is it society that made them like that? Do you feel guilty when people you know become addicts? what are your feelings when you see them on the street? I always feel sorry for such people, but should I?
| |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
1. maryrajam1962 (240) | 1 year ago | I do not feel sorry for drug addicts. They choose to become drug addicts. In my country drug addicts are sent for rehabilation. I noticed it is always the pampered spoiled kids who become drug addicts.
| |
| |
|
|
| thefreemind (34) | 1 year ago | No-one chooses to become an addict.
That's the definition of addiction: A compulsion that drives you to do something regardless of all rational thought. It's not a choice, it's something that's developed into a need.
| |
|
|
|
Obama Wants You to Return to School Get Your Degree Now. Financial Aid available. www.ClassesUSA.com | add comment |
|
|
|
2. rrdj71 (654) | 1 year ago | I believe that it's a little bit of both. Society and the media bombard us with advertisements CONSTANTLY so we wind up eating things we could've done without,drinking which we all know leads to nothing but sorrow and troubles in the end. But we also have to have some will power as well and learn when just to say NO.
| |
| |
|
|
Scarrlet (118) | 1 year ago | Will power is the key which helps to avoid addictiveness. but should people be left aside if they don't have such a well developed will power? If we see a person getting into something addictive, we must remember that they cannot fully judge the situation now, and our help, but not blame is what they would need the most. And your point about mass media is very fair, but it's a pity that nowadays a person can be hardly left outside its influence.
| |
|
|
|
Obama Urges Homeowners to Refinance See Rates - No Credit Check Needed. ($90,000 Refinance under $489/mo) www.LowerMyBills.com | add comment |
|
|
|
|
| thefreemind (34) | 1 year ago | 'Illegal' drugs have nothing to do with addiction.
More people are addicted to cigarettes than crack, cocaine, cannabis and heroin combined.
| |
|
|
Scarrlet (118) | 1 year ago | I guess it's hard to judge others if we haven't experience similar situations. As for me, i wouldn't be able to make through my addiction if other "normal" people would just turn away from me saying it's my fault. I guess you are talking in here about not feeling guilty for the people i don't know. and yes, it is very exhaustive to have such an attitude for everyone i see. but if the help is possible, it won't hurt them;)
| |
|
|
|
Obama Backs Auto Insurance Regulation Drivers Pay $44/mo on Avg for Car Insurance. Are you paying too much? Auto-Insurance-Experts.com | add comment |
|
|
|
4. sk66rc (2235) | 1 year ago | I believe addictions of any kind are by choice, at least at first... If you have to hide what you're doing, chances are, it's a wrong thing to do... I do know that there's always an exceptions, babies being born to a crack-addict mother is one of them... People without self control or even self esteem tend to be more likely to become addicts of some kind... I don't feel sorry for them at all... I do have compassion but not for the people who "choose" to be the way they are... If you were captured or abducted by a stranger & drugs were forced on you while you were tied down & as a result of this going on for 7 years, then yes, I can understand & we all should feel for the person who had to go through that kind of experience...
| |
| |
|
|
Scarrlet (118) | 1 year ago | You are right saying that we actually should judge a person when he/she is starting to "have fun". If this person or someone else has actually raised the question of further addiction, but a person didn't react, then we can say that the choice was made consciously. But still, the process of getting addicted is not an immediate thing, but a continuous one, and it is hard to make a line between the periods where a person wanted, for example, to establish a certain circle of friends, and where he/she started to have breakdowns.
| |
|
|
|
Online College Degrees Enjoy Online College Convenience! 100's of Career-Advancing Degrees. Education.NexTag.com/Online-Degrees | add comment |
|
|
|
5. singing1227 (312) | 1 year ago | Addiction is a disease. Yes, humans make choices that get them addicted, but once they cross that line, they are victims of a pernicious disease. We can love the addicts and hate their addiction. You should feel sorry for anyone who is hurting, but you should not condone their self-destructive behaviors. Tough love is still love.
| |
| |
|
|
Scarrlet (118) | 1 year ago | Yes! Addiction is a psychological disease, so we should treat it, but not leave people with it. Attitude towards people with other mental diseases has also started earlier with blaming, but now a lot of it is prescribed to the lack of conscious. Maybe it is still hard to equalize severe mental diseases and addictions now, but i truly believe that they have a common root. Thank you for responding
| |
|
|
|
|
|
6. Humbug25 (4101) | 1 year ago | Hi ya Scarrlet
I'm sorry to say that I don't feel sorry for these people because we all have a choice in life and I choose not to be drug addict or to abuse alcohol. There is help out there for those people and it is their choice to take it or not.
| |
| |
|
|
Scarrlet (118) | 1 year ago | And it's easier not to feel sorry for addictive people if we know that government or social organizations would take a good care for them. Too bad not in all countries it is possible...
| |
|
|
Humbug25 (4101) | 1 year ago | That is true and here in England there is a lot of help for people but they have got to want to be helped and some people actually choose to be on the street because they don't want to conform along with the rest of society.
| |
|
|
|
|
|
7. goldeneagle (3471) | 1 year ago | No you shouldn't feel sorry for them. They chose to get into that crap. Just like smokers and alcoholics. They chose to pick it up and try it. I smoked for over 10 years, and quitting was the hardest thing I have ever done in my life, but I made the decision to pick up that first one I ever smoked, so I can't blame anyone but myself for the negative health effects or for all the money I wasted buying them. I was a heavy drinker for a long time as well. I have given that up for the most part as well. I still have a few beers with a buddy of mine a couple of times per month, but I leave the hard stuff alone, and I don't drink very many beers when I do drink. There again, I can't blame anyone but myself for the hangovers I used to get, or all the money I wasted on booze either. I don't spend that much on it these days. There were times when I would go out partying all the time that I would spend more on beer and stuff in one weekend than I spend in a month or two now. It is sad that people get addicted to such things. It is also sad that it isn't always the addicts who suffer the most. It is often the wife, kids, or other family members who suffer the most. I feel sorry for the families of these people. The addicts do it to themselves, but the families are drug into it by the actions of the addict. They are not willing participants in the lifestyle that drugs and alcohol can lead to. It is the family members you should feel sorry for the most. I do believe that addicts can change their lives for the better with the right motivations and the right help. There is hope for them, but they have got to want the change enough to suffer through it. Anyone who has ever quit smoking can testify to that. I haven't smoked in well over two years, but I still get cravings. I could very easily drive down to the store and buy a pack and start all over again. I could very easily walk across the street and "bum" a cigarette from at least four or five of my neighbors right now. It would be as easy as putting on my shoes and walking across the road. The reason I don't do it is that I remember how hard it was to quit, and I realize how much easier life is when you can breathe. I ride my bicycle almost daily now, and have started lifting weights again as well, trying to get rid of some body fat. I am not really overweight by much, but I could stand to turn a little fat into muscle or at least to loose some fat in the mid-section. I know that if I started back smoking, I couldn't exercise as effectively, so I would likely become even more overweight. I also see what smoking has done to friends and relatives, and realize that it was slowly doing the same thing to me when I smoked, so I don't do it, nor to I want to be around too many other people who smoke for very long. It stinks, quite frankly, but I didn't realize how bad it makes you smell until I quit smoking myself.
| |
| |
|
|
Scarrlet (118) | 1 year ago | You and people around you must be very proud for the heroic actions your did. i am very thankful to you for sharing your personal story. this discussion needed an opinion from the inside. majority of addicts are not so lucky to take such problems into their own hands. I had a father who was and alcoholic addict, and died because of that. I loved him and was angry at him at the same time. his addiction ruined our family and my childhood. but when he was sober i still saw a loving person in him, and a person who wished to quit his addiction, but just couldn't. that's why i have these mixed feelings in me right now: all the crying couldn't make me blame my father for everything because i saw how addiction steadily destroyed personality.
keep up with making your loved ones happy!
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| 8. thefreemind (34) | 1 year ago | Just because someone has chosen to try a substance doesn't mean they have chosen to be addicted to it. Yes, they may be foolish for trying it, but I've never heard of anyone who has consciously chosen to be an addict.
And let's remember that this isn't just about drugs. As the opening post says, this could apply to food. Gambling is another option.
The question itself seems to be fundamentally flawed as it asks whether we should 'blame the addicts.' Blame them for what? What business is it of mine if someone has an addiction as long as they don't harm anyone else in the process of their addiction?
And, yes, I know I'm splitting hairs here and that right now you're thinking: "Well should we blame them for the effect their addiction has on society.?" Again, fundamentally, no we shouldn't. Sure, blame the person if they actually CHOSE to be addicted, but don't blame a person for trying something and then unexpectedly becoming addicted.
Addicts are sick. They need help, not blame.
| |
| |
|
|
Scarrlet (118) | 1 year ago | Thank you for clearing that up. the question might have been leading into different ways of thinking; yet i made it so for people to think about it critically, and you did a great job in this. blaming can be both: for the influences of the society, and for their own condition. putting a blame on such people have become a prejudice, and the fact that they need help is what i am trying to convenience others about.
congrats with your first postings;)
| |
|
|
|
|
|
9. fifileigh (2923) | 1 year ago | i think it is their surroundings and society that made them that way...people mess with one another and make people a certain way. child molesters, abusers, hateful people inflict their hate on others and mar others with scars and problems. parents mess with their kids a lot. teachers are not much help. and social workers are not helping the situation...i dont really know why people hire social workers or what they actually do because they are not helping all these messed up people in society... we need a volunteer psychiatrist to go into homeless shelters and help bums with their problems before giving them work...
| |
| |
|
|
Scarrlet (118) | 1 year ago | The influence of society is increasing with year due to the openness of media. and you are right in here saying that it's also a reason why people gain bad habits that are being promoted. question with social workers is hard to answer for me too. maybe they don't get training enough, or maybe there are not so many people to take such a challenge fully. Volunteer psychiatrist for the addicts seems to be a very tough way to spend your time. i think to have more positive results, we should make it the opposite: high payments for such job will make up for the big psychological damage that the psychiatrists experience themselves.
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| 10. Ravenstorm3 (37) | 1 year ago | My veiw of life progression is that we are born with innocent hearts and pure souls...however as we progress through life's experiences the process of jading our minds begins through societies "expectations" of who we are and who they belive we should be,and pressures of the world in general. I know people who have endured years of abuse from their own families. I also know people who have and will never know what it means to need, much less want for anything, along with people who's lives played out somewhere between the situations I just described. It is my belief, at a certain point in one's life one has the ability to exercise free will. It is at that point when one instictively knows what is and what is not good for them and should act in their own best interest....sounds ideal and easy...but it is not. People develope addictions more times than not to escape from situations they are going through. I have no "guilty" feelings about anyone becoming an addict...I DO have empathy for them. Ultimately, no one can "make" anyone into an addict unless they are diabolic and drug them without their knowledge. That being said, I feel horrible for anyone who thinks paying for a drug out weighs paying for a roof over their heads...but that is the reality. Niether me or my husband has ever failed to help someone asking for money for food...not by giving money but purchasing a good meal. I completely understand your feeling badly for these people...you have a good heart...
| |
| |
|
|
Scarrlet (118) | 1 year ago | I liked what you said a lot, and it's great that you try to help such people with this thinking in mind. Certainly, it is hard to claim that a certain person has been predisposed to addiction in major cases. And if the life of addicts would have turned into another direction before, they probably wouldn't face such a problem. Thank you Ravenstorm for your deep thoughts!
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| | Online College Degrees Enjoy Online College Convenience! 100's of Career-Advancing Degrees. Education.NexTag.com/Online-Degrees
| | |
|
|
|
|