sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Largemouth Bass: Freedom or Eat'em?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 96/100. singout (342)   ranked 5 out of 193 in fishing 4 years ago

Fish have been a part of the human diet since history began. But one fresh water fish, in particular seems to have become a "sacred cow" to many fishing enthusiasts. The Largemouth Bass (and sometimes the Smallmouth Bass) seems to have been able to acquire their freedom more than any other fresh water fish. The Largemouth bass is a great tasting fish when eaten, but I've noticed now, a strange pang of guilt associated with my even considering it. I watched my son release an eight-pounder without even thinking about it; but not before he had his picture taken with it. There is a photo of that fish now, as my fishing avatar. So the question is: Do you give them their freedom or do you eat'em? And why do you do what you do where this fish is concerned?
Now, the extremely large Bass do have a distinct problem though. They could end up on somebody's wall. So, there are drawbacks to getting too big also. Where do you stand?

 

fishing
sponsors
Press Release: How To
How to Release a Press Release Learn How Quick and Easy it is!
PRWeb.com

Eating Disorder Treatment
Our private campus offers women a safe, tranquil place to heal.
TimberlineKnolls.com/EatingDisorder

Eating Disorder Program
Affordable Residential and Outpatient Programs, Non-Hospital Setting
www.MilestonesProgram.org

goinliveinfive (504) response was accepted on 8/25/2008.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  largemouth bass, release, bass, catch, eating
 
1. myLot reputation of 46/100. goinliveinfive (504)   ranked 82 out of 193 in fishing   4 years ago

As an omnivore with the ability to reason my way through a decision such as this, my response is: eat 'em. In my my estimation, fishing for sport is far more cruel. You injure the animal for your own pleasure, take a picture with it then release it, injured, back into the wild where it could easily succumb to infection or other predators. I wouldn't bother fishing for anything I didn't intend to eat.


myLot reputation of 96/100. singout (342)   ranked 5 out of 193 in fishing  4 years ago

Thank you for that great response, goinliveinfive. It does force one to think about it. I don't suggest that any injured fish be released, especially when it is bleeding. There is a couple of things about the largemouth, though. First is that it's mouth is very boney and seldom do you ever hook a vital part. The other is that this fish is a very hardy fish. It can live in a livewell practically all day without harm if the livewell is properly circulated with fresh water. You are right about one thing, though. Sometimes these fish do swallow a hook which is very difficult to remove without injury. In cases like that---enjoy the flavor.

Press Release: How To How to Release a Press Release Learn How Quick and Easy it is!  PRWeb.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 94/100. shrashira (257)   ranked 51 out of 193 in fishing   4 years ago

In my opinion, I think that throwing more fish back than you keep can actually harm a lake or pond.

This can reduce the overall food supply, therefore reducing the overall size of the fish therein.

I too think that catch and release is a harsh action to take on a fish that is within the legal limit to take home.

Catch and release was new to me. Before last year I was not aware of that policy. Or should I say , the unwritten rule. I caught a fish and my fellow anglers gave me this whole speech on why I should let it go.

Due to this I feel like a thief in the night when I catch a fish. I find myself rediculously looking over my shoulder if I want to keep it.

I don't fish for sport, I fish to eat fish. Just my thoughts...


myLot reputation of 96/100. singout (342)   ranked 5 out of 193 in fishing  4 years ago

Thanks for your response, shrashira. Your thoughts are what this discussion is all about. Well, so far, that is two people who think that those fish should not be released. I don't know when this unwritten rule started but it has made a lot of people feel guilty about keeping their fish. Do you think it may have started with professional fisherman?


myLot reputation of 94/100. shrashira (257)   ranked 51 out of 193 in fishing  4 years ago

I guess another issue that affects whether I catch or release the fish is this.

Most freshwater spots I fish at require some sort of fee along with the fishing license itself.

Now, if there was no fee for fishing (other than the license), I would be more inclined to return the catch. On days that I don't catch anything (which is common and frustrating), I feel like I just threw my cash in the fire.

Which makes me want to keep any fish I catch, to justify all the money I have "donated" to the act of fishing.

I think pro fishermen want the catch and release program to make sure they have a nice size fish to catch.

Eating Disorder Treatment Our private campus offers women a safe, tranquil place to heal.  TimberlineKnolls.com/EatingDisorder
 
sponsors
Forget about CBYG stock
This New Alternative Energy IPO might triple in value!
chicagofinancialtimes.com/SENY

Eating Disorders
Specializing in Child, Teen& Adult Eating Disorder. 888-740-4185.
RemudaRanch.com/EatingDisorder

5 Foods you must not eat
Cut down a bit of stomach fat every day by never eating these 5 foods.
Thedietsolutionprogram.com

similar discussions
Show us a picture of your largemouth bass
I hope I did this right. Hopefully, you can see the largemouth my son caught. I will probably never...
Largest Largemouth
What is the biggest large mouth bass you ever caught?
sponsors
Forget about CBYG stock
This New Alternative Energy IPO might triple in value!
chicagofinancialtimes.com/SENY
Eating Disorders
Specializing in Child, Teen & Adult Eating Disorder. 888-740-4185.
RemudaRanch.com/EatingDisorder
5 Foods you must not eat
Cut down a bit of stomach fat every day by never eating these 5 foods.
Thedietsolutionprogram.com
Local Coupons
Ridiculously huge deals every day. Like doing your city at 90% off!
www.Groupon.com
Kashi® Foods Have Protein
Add Protein & Fiber to Your Diet. Get Nutrition Info on Kashi® Foods!
www.kashi.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.