sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

do you support the idea of "Animal Rights"?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 72/100. jfxrsch (321)   ranked 6,144 out of 7,859 in dogs 4 years ago

We love animal and we don't want to hurt them and we want to protect them from being abused. No doubt.
But, is it right that human play God, try to apply Animal Rights? It's kind of un-nature, what do you think?

 

dogs
sponsors
Top Value Medical School
Accredited M.D., MCAT not required, USMLE Prep, US Clinicals, Fin Aid
www.eustatiusmed.edu

Law Schools Online
Earn An Assoc, Bach, or J.D. Completely Online. Get Free Info!
EarnMyDegree.com

The Mormon Faith
Get Closer to God. Learn about Our Heavenly Father& His Plan for You.
www.mormon.org

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  animal rights, animal, animals, god
 
1. myLot reputation of 91/100. coxjamir (1178)   4 years ago

I do not think that granting animals rights is "playing God." Animals obviously have feelings and can love and care for people and feel pain, and it is not right that they should be abused just because humans feel like it. Also, God cared about animals, a lot. Remember, Noah took two of every kind onto the ark. Also, there are scripture references about how God cares about the sparrow. He provides them with food every day. Actually, here is a very interesting article online about this very topic: http://www.monmouthchurch.org/Reference/Animals - Gods View.htm . It talks about how the Bible says that animals are our companions, God blesses animals by enabling them to reproduce, providing for their feeding through plants, and providing for their care by us, humans. We are to care for animals and animals are accountable to God. Check out the article!


myLot reputation of 72/100. jfxrsch (321)   ranked 6,144 out of 7,859 in dogs  4 years ago

Or, should I ask--" do we human have the Rights" to grant animal rights? I think human and animal are equal, one can't grant the other anything.


myLot reputation of 76/100. marcialoyd (1078)   ranked 264 out of 7,859 in dogs  4 years ago

We agree to disagree. I can grant my dog protection. and you can bet if anyone tries to lay a finger on me in harm she is going to eat them up. So we are equal in my eyes. :-)


myLot reputation of 72/100. jfxrsch (321)   ranked 6,144 out of 7,859 in dogs  4 years ago

the relationship between you and your cat means friendship

Top Value Medical School Accredited M.D., MCAT not required, USMLE Prep, US Clinicals, Fin Aid  www.eustatiusmed.edu
 
2. myLot reputation of 83/100. ralphido (725)   4 years ago

well. i don't know whether i'm the right person to comment on this topic since i am an ardent fan of chicken. There are lot of campaigns going on to save Tigers and Pandas from being extinct but that doesn't mean we are protecting animal rights.
When i think more about it, even chicken have their own rights but we butcher them just the same for our own conveniences. I wonder whether we would file lawsuits to protect chicken from being fried if they were on the brink of extinction..


myLot reputation of 72/100. jfxrsch (321)   ranked 6,144 out of 7,859 in dogs  4 years ago

Probably chicken started weakening from the time when they started being protected by human.

Law Schools Online Earn An Assoc, Bach, or J.D. Completely Online. Get Free Info!  EarnMyDegree.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 76/100. marcialoyd (1078)   ranked 264 out of 7,859 in dogs   4 years ago

I don't believe it is playing God. We have a responsobility to protect animals I believe. I mean we have rights. No one can abuse us, beat us, etc without paying the consequences. and the same should be for animals. They have feelings to and do not deserve to be treated badly.


myLot reputation of 72/100. jfxrsch (321)   ranked 6,144 out of 7,859 in dogs  4 years ago

It's our human's bad if we treat animal bad. So, maybe it's better work on our human's rights instead of work on animal's right?

The Mormon Faith Get Closer to God. Learn about Our Heavenly Father & His Plan for You.  www.mormon.org
 
4. myLot reputation of 88/100. zoesden (669)   4 years ago

Animal rights, then plant rights. We are all living creatures. My grandfather was a hunter. But he told me this. Don't kill unless it is for food, don't plant a plant unless you will take care of it. Don't buy meat or any food unless you are gonna eat, don't waste it. As far as pets, his thoughts were don't have one unless you will love and care for it. Everything in his opinion was, here for a reason and you should respect, love and care for. He hated people who hunted for sport, hated seeing a garden uncared for. We must eat but we must love and respect too. If it is a pet or animal, a plant, a human, treat it as you would like to be treated, then even better.


myLot reputation of 96/100. CatsandDogs (6424)   ranked 30 out of 7,859 in dogs  4 years ago

I have to tell you, you have a VERY wise grandfather!! I LOVE the way he thinks!! He has a GREAT way of putting it!! thumbup


myLot reputation of 72/100. jfxrsch (321)   ranked 6,144 out of 7,859 in dogs  4 years ago

Your grandfather is a great man!

Real California Farms We are Dedicated to Sustainable Farming. See What We Are Doing.  www.realcaliforniamilk.com
 
5. flutterbee (12)   ranked 3,799 out of 7,859 in dogs   4 years ago

YES I DO! no animal should be hurt or abused in any manner what so ever.

PetMeds on Sale Only FDA/EPA Approved Medication.Save up to 40% compared to your Vet!  www.petmedsnmore.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 66/100. morningstar369 (406)   ranked 2,417 out of 7,859 in dogs   4 years ago

Animals have feelings and the domestic animals give unconditional love. They deserve to be protected and taken care of. The thought of animal rights being is un-natural is very odd. It's like saying human rights is un-natural. I am a vegetarian and I do understand that there are people that eat meat. The quality of the meat is better if the animals are cared for better, than being caged or pened. As far as wild animals it's survival of the fittest. That is the law of natue. Sometimes that is crewl and hard to know about. When it comes to things that are un-naturan like areal shooting of wolves and other animals it's plain wrong. Clubbing of baby seals is crewel and shameful. I could go on but I think you get the idea.


myLot reputation of 72/100. jfxrsch (321)   ranked 6,144 out of 7,859 in dogs  4 years ago

How would you feel if animal grant you some rights?


myLot reputation of 66/100. morningstar369 (406)   ranked 2,417 out of 7,859 in dogs  4 years ago

I do not understaand your question???

Animal Care Training Learn about care and treatment of animals as a Vet Assistant.  www.PennFoster.edu
 
7. myLot reputation of 96/100. ronaldinu (9358)   ranked 6 out of 7,859 in dogs   4 years ago

I do believe in animal rights. Even God wants us to respect animals. The catholic church has a saint, St Francis who loved and respected animals. there is nothing wrong in respecting and protecting the animals.


myLot reputation of 72/100. jfxrsch (321)   ranked 6,144 out of 7,859 in dogs  4 years ago

Nothing wrong, but it limits animal's nature.

Makeup - Free Shipping Shop Online With Me, Your Mary Kay Independent Beauty Consultant!  www.marykay.com/nadine
 
8. apakhale123 (57)   ranked 6,906 out of 7,859 in dogs   4 years ago

The God has given life to both man and animal. So, they have the equal right to live as we have. It is very unfortunate that man because of his greed kill animals and clean forests. This is the reason behind the some animal kingdom are extict and some are endangered of getting extinct. Animals also have same pain as men when someone is harming us. Animal Rights need to be protected from cruel men.


myLot reputation of 72/100. jfxrsch (321)   ranked 6,144 out of 7,859 in dogs  4 years ago

I believe man and animal are equal. But I don't believe lifes come from God. If life is God given, that brings the logic that no man should bother whoever is killed- beause God knows all and manage all.

Animals Looking For Animals? Find It Nearby With Local.com!  Local.com
 
sponsors
Real California Farms
We are Dedicated to Sustainable Farming. See What We Are Doing.
www.realcaliforniamilk.com

PetMeds on Sale
Only FDA/EPA Approved Medication.Save up to 40% compared to your Vet!
www.petmedsnmore.com

Animal Care Training
Learn about care and treatment of animals as a Vet Assistant.
www.PennFoster.edu

similar discussions
Horse racing
My favorite animal is horse and I am strictly against horse racing. Horse racing is one of the best...
In search for friends
I am fairly new to mylot and I was looking for some new friends that are supportive of animal...
What Is Wrong With Wearing Fur?
I know it may cause a bit of a fuss, but to be fair, I don't see a problem with wearing real animal...
Do Animals Have The Right To Sue?
Well Obama's regulatory Czar believes so! Meet the regulatory Czar, the new nut job of the week for...
Help Animals And Get Free Stuff
Recently I became a member of PETA's streetteam. Streetteam is designed for people in the age range...
Tradition or Animal Rights?
I just read in a newspaper article that the indigenous arctics are allowed to hunt polar bears as...
Do animals have rights?
We humans are often very protective of our rights to privacy. You would object, wouldn't you, if a...
TV show 30 Days - Animal Rights
Last night we caught the last half of the newest 30 Days where they had someone who was very...
Animal rights group vs dolphin show
Hello everyone! In our city, a dolphin show event just opened up this Christmas season. An...
Live animals freezing in nativity scene
Old news, but... "2010-12-23 04:39:00 PST Warsaw, , Poland — (12-23) 04:39 PST WARSAW, Poland...
sponsors
Real California Farms
We are Dedicated to Sustainable Farming. See What We Are Doing.
www.realcaliforniamilk.com
PetMeds on Sale
Only FDA/EPA Approved Medication.Save up to 40% compared to your Vet!
www.petmedsnmore.com
Animal Care Training
Learn about care and treatment of animals as a Vet Assistant.
www.PennFoster.edu
Makeup - Free Shipping
Shop Online With Me, Your Mary Kay Independent Beauty Consultant!
www.marykay.com/nadine
Animals
Looking For Animals? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com
Holy Spirit Jewelry Coins
Beautiful Holy Spirit Pendants Coins Key Chains Coffee Mugs T Shirts
www.witnesstools.org
Top Rated Veterinarians
Need Top Rated Local Veterinarians?
yellowpages.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.