Do you blame Plaxico for the downfall of the Giants? Do you want him back?

well plaxico was a play maker and took some of the pressure off of the running game n the other receivers n Tight end, so it helped having him on the field for sure, but i dont think its the reason they lost, i think eli didnt step up to the plate on that last playoff game, bottom line..

I do not want to blame it all on Plaxico for the downfall of the Giants but he is at fault. I think the Giants are a much better team with him in the lineup, then without and he is a much better reciever than Dominick Hixon. The Giants started their season 11-1 with him in the lineup and it went into a downward spiral after they reported he was out for the season. I would actually want him back but there is still a long time before anything can be resolved and he could face jail time in the near future. Don't worry, Giants will be fine and next year will be our year.

I don't think they needed him soley to win. But him being gone really enabled defenses to focus on the Giants running game, which hurt. Plaxico was a big tall target for Eli also. I don't know I really think it did effect us badly.