sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

The Hobbit, new movie email this discussion to a friend?

cd_lear (52)   ranked 17 out of 99 in lord of the rings11 months ago

I've been following the upcoming Hobbit movie as its been discussed back and forth. Conflict between Peter Jackson and the studio. I'm glad they have finally begun production. I'm not sure splitting into 2 movies is a good idea, but I'm willing to admit i'm wrong if it works.

I have just finished reading a great article about it in this months Empire magazine. Peter Jackson doing the producing and writing, with Guillermo del Toro directing is making me excited to see what they will produce. I thought Pan's Labyrinth was excellent. There was a lot of speculation as to who would be cast in it, though it was only speculation.

I wonder what everyone thinks about the choice of 2 movies to tell the story, who they think they should cast in it.

 
 
lord of the rings
sponsors
Spider Vein Treatment - No. VA
McLean Vein Center Offers Multiple Treatments for Spider Veins.
DC.Vein-Treatment.com

Hyattsville Janitorial Cleaning Services
MaidMagic.net is your source for residential and commercial cleaning needs. Serving Hyattsville, MD and surrounding areas. Look up to us for a clean and tidy home or business.
www.maidmagic.net

Wampler, Souder& Sessing, LLC
Construction law firm serving Maryland, Virginia, and Washington, DC.
www.wamplaw.us

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  hobbit, peter jackson, guillermo del toro, lord of the rings, empire
 
1. myLot reputation of 91/100. uath13 (3755)   ranked 61 out of 99 in lord of the rings   11 months ago

It was a rather long book. If they put everything Tolkien put into it then a single movie would be way too long for anyone to sit through in the theaters. 2 movies isn't a bad idea so long as they do as good a job as they did on the LOTR trilogy.

Spider Vein Treatment - No. VA McLean Vein Center Offers Multiple Treatments for Spider Veins. DC.Vein-Treatment.com
 
2. rsk721 (42)   11 months ago

I have to say I'm excited to hear that they are going forward with the movie. I think it might be awkward to put it into 2 movies. Where would one end and the next one begin? With the first 3 movies they were actually individual books so they had a definite ending and beginning. I hope they don't split it into two just to make more money.

Hyattsville Janitorial Cleaning Services MaidMagic.net is your source for residential and commercial cleaning needs. Serving Hyattsville, MD and surrounding areas. Look up to us for a clean and tidy home or business. www.maidmagic.net
 
3. myLot reputation of 88/100. AikaruJ (115)   11 months ago

for me, i would like the original casting of the trilogy. they have chemistry and they portrayed their characters very well.


cd_lear (52)   ranked 17 out of 99 in lord of the rings  11 months ago

Aside from Gandalf, and Gollum, there won't be many of the Lord of the Rings characters in the Hobbit. Yes Bilbo is in it, but it supposed to be Bilbo at the same age Frodo was at the start of LOTR.

I complete agree though that Sir Ian Mckellan and Andy Serkis should play Gandalf and Gollum.

Wampler, Souder & Sessing, LLC Construction law firm serving Maryland, Virginia, and Washington, DC. www.wamplaw.us
 
4. Vonhooverhiggen1 (9)   10 months ago

I dont think 2 movies is a good idea. The book wasnt nearly as long as the others. but it does have alot in it... still.......

ABC Limo Service Chauffer Limo services in Dc, Va, Md. Flat rate to all airports. . www.limowashington.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 89/100. thelastwolf113 (3060)   10 months ago

It wasn't long, compared to the LOTR.
This is what they are going to do:
The first part, due out in 2011, will basically be The Hobbit.
The second part, due out in 2012, will be beyond what the book of The Hobbit has to tell, it'll be additional material to bridge what happens in between The Hobbit and LOTR, which hasn't been written of. All we know from the books is Bilbo gets the ring, kills Smaug. In LOTR, we put up the story many years later. I think the second part is a good idea.
I read this at scifi.com sometime in past two weeks or so.




TomAustin (15)   ranked 15 out of 99 in lord of the rings  3 months ago

I had heard that the second movie would be the eighty or so years between the books, and this is what's getting me just a little worried about how it's going to turn out. I'm not sure Guillermo de Toro is going to keep to the canon that Tolkien set up, especially since I still think Peter Jackson should have let certain details alone (*cough* Arwen*cough*).

There really isn't that much information about the time gap, so they are going to have to make up a lot of information about it for the story. I heard that it could involve The Story of Arwen and Aragorn, from the appendices, which would make sense to me, since that's when it happened.

I am looking forward to the battle with the spiders. That's just going to be fantastic. At any rate, it's got to be better than Bakshi.


myLot reputation of 89/100. thelastwolf113 (3060)  3 months ago

I still wish Jackson was directing this one.

Using The Latest Technolo Read reviews for this business with directions, offers and more. Washingtondc.Citysearch.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 41/100. wowdca (400)   9 months ago

I think this will be a movie to look out for. I'm a huge fan of the Lord of the Rings trilogy so I have high hopes for this one. I hope they would illustrate the story with much vigor and drama. I just love movies that exhibit great drama.

Back in Action Spinecare & Rehab Chiropractic - Spinal Decompression - Rehabilitation - Nutrition. www.virginiachiro.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 82/100. starsailover (880)   ranked 85 out of 99 in lord of the rings   2 months ago

I don't think splitting the story in two parts would be a good idea- i hope to be wrong- because i see it as a whole. Maybe they decide this to buy "twice" in tickets and that's not right to make this things just for the economics reasons. Even with that I'll watch the movie and maybe Peter Jackson will surprise me with his decition

Lord of the Rings Online Live the Story That Started It All. Find Fellowship in Middle-earth. www.LOTRO.com/trial
 
sponsors
ABC Limo Service
Chauffer Limo services in Dc, Va, Md. Flat rate to all airports. .
www.limowashington.com

Using The Latest Technolo
Read reviews for this business with directions, offers and more.
Washingtondc.Citysearch.com

Back in Action Spinecare& Rehab
Chiropractic - Spinal Decompression - Rehabilitation - Nutrition.
www.virginiachiro.com

similar discussions
My Latest Knitted Toy
I added another toy to my knit/crochet blog today if anyone is interested in checking it out....
Which is better?
Which is better in your opinion? the LOTR series (and which book) OR the Hobbit?
Has anyone tried the Hobbit game for X-box?
This is one of my favourite books, so obviously I had to try out the game for our X-Box. It is so...
Similarities between Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings.
In fact this is a similarity between any two fantasy books. When I saw the Harry Potter movie, I...
Just found out! They are making The Hobbit!!!!
I just found out and I am sooooo excited about it!!! The Hobbit will come out sometime in 2012!!! I...
Great Trilogy
I watch everyday this film, i thing this very good scenario this film is better, so I hope can make...
The Hobbit (movie)
Now, everyone will be looking forward to another sequel of LOTR, The Hobbit.It is now announced and...
Have anyone read anything by
J.R.R. Tolkien? I´ve not,but I´ve heard of his books. Can you recommend me to read them?
The Hobbit movie
Is it worth getting some to make the Hobbit while the same actors and sets exist, even if Peter...
Lord Of The Rings Books!
just wondering how many of you out there read the books before seeing the movie and if so How did...
sponsors
ABC Limo Service
Chauffer Limo services in Dc, Va, Md. Flat rate to all airports. .
www.limowashington.com
Using The Latest Technolo
Read reviews for this business with directions, offers and more.
Washingtondc.Citysearch.com
Back in Action Spinecare & Rehab
Chiropractic - Spinal Decompression - Rehabilitation - Nutrition.
www.virginiachiro.com
Lord of the Rings Online
Live the Story That Started It All. Find Fellowship in Middle-earth.
www.LOTRO.com/trial
Residence Inn Dupont Circle in D.C
Official Site: RI Marriott Dupont Circle. Book Now & Save.
www.Marriott.com/wasri
Washington VIN History at Carfax
Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get CARFAX Vehicle History Reports.
www.Carfax.com
Local Locksmiths
Washington DC Locks & Locksmiths - 24 Hour, emergency, all lock types.
WashingtonDC.YellowPages.com
Audition in Washington, DC
Casting calls now in Washington, DC Free Auditions for Paid Jobs
ExploreTalent.com/DC-Auditions
western washington wa basement finishing
Looking for General Contractors? View the top experts.
contractors.locallytrusted.com
Young Frankenstein in Washington D.C.
See the musical Dec. 15-Jan. 10 at the Opera House. Get tickets here.
Kennedy-Center.org
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.