sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Star Wars Prequels  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 94/100. thezone (3927)   ranked 6 out of 217 in star wars 4 years ago

As a big Star Wars fan, I was very dissapointed by the new Star Wars movies. They just seemed like sacrilege to the Holy Trinity that was the original trilogy. Out of the three prequels "Revenge of the Sith", was the best out of a bad lot.

So did you want to choke Jar Jar Binks binks to death with your popcorn?
Were the prequels just a jumped uo toy commercial ?

 

star wars
sponsors
Need A New Ceiling Fan?
Only $195 Supply And Install A Ceiling Fan
GreenPElectric.biz

Find Toy Stores Nearby
Find Local Toy Stores& Get Great
yellowpages.com

Star Trek Enterprise
Complete Series On Dvd. Always Shipped Priority Mail.
www.EntireSeries.tv

Anora_Eldorath (3661) response was accepted on 3/20/2009.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  star wars, artoo, comic relief, fan, jar jar
 
1. myLot reputation of 100/100. uicbear (1639)   ranked 80 out of 217 in star wars   4 years ago

I wasn't a big fan of the prequels. I had some of the same issues that others did. Like, for instance the technology seemed more advance in the prequels. I don't know how this could have been remedied as it being a sci-fi movie, cool visuals are part of the fun. The original trilogy was very cutting edge when it came out.

The thing that really got to me in the prequels, was the acting for Anakin, both young and old. I really didn't care about him. I didn't feel any emotion about his struggle. The acting just turned me off that I was sitting there thinking, so what, become Darth Vader already.

I didn't really know the story in the prequels going in. All I knew is that Anakin becomes Darth Vader and Obi Wan was his teacher. So some of the back story was interesting. But the really wasn't much suspense, partially because you know how it's all gonna turn out.

So, the original is still my favorite, hands down.


myLot reputation of 94/100. thezone (3927)   ranked 6 out of 217 in star wars  4 years ago

Yes the original trilogy is still the Holy grail. For me the "Revenge of the Sith" was the best of the prequels, it was good, as you said, to have some back story of how Anakin turned to the dark side. Although the the turning of Anakin, seemed rushed a little bit. The worst part of "Revenge of the Sith" , was Darth Vader screaming "NOOOOOOOOOO!" like a litle girl.

Need A New Ceiling Fan? Only $195 Supply And Install A Ceiling Fan  GreenPElectric.biz
 
2. myLot reputation of 65/100. BrianDaniel (271)   ranked 57 out of 217 in star wars   4 years ago

I liked all 6 :-)


myLot reputation of 94/100. thezone (3927)   ranked 6 out of 217 in star wars  4 years ago

Hey there. Yes I do like all the films as well. The prequels did have some very good points but I will always have a place in my heart for the fiest 3.


myLot reputation of 65/100. BrianDaniel (271)   ranked 57 out of 217 in star wars  4 years ago

Sentimental!


myLot reputation of 94/100. thezone (3927)   ranked 6 out of 217 in star wars  3 years ago

Yes I am a little sentimental when it comes to the first three filmsblush

Find Toy Stores Nearby Find Local Toy Stores & Get Great  yellowpages.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 62/100. Anora_Eldorath (3661)   ranked 20 out of 217 in star wars   4 years ago

I really enjoyed them. I wrote about this on another thread, but I feel that Lucas did well in his creation of the first three because they gave a sense of what occured when the Empire took over. The Empire ruined anything it got its hands on, so it makes sense that prior to the Empire the world would have been a brighter place. It also makes sense that there would be more freedoms, better places, etc before the Empire fully took over.

I didn't want to choke Jar Jar. I think he was a pivotal character that needed to be put into the story. He represented persons who are totally and completely innocent and naieve. That is why he got into so much trouble. For example, he was easily moved by Senator Palpatine's aide to call for a vote when Amidala was gone because he did what he thought she would have done. And in all fairness to Jar Jar, Amidala at that point in time would have voted with Palpatine because no one saw him for what he was yet. Jar Jar was the representations for the child in all of us who is introduced to war, and a world he didn't know existed before the Empire's interferance.

I don't think they were at all jumped to just for toy commericalism. Lucas has stated in countless interviews that he had the entire story written out prior to the first three but that he didn't have the funds at the time to tell the story, and people weren't going to sit through a long movie. And that is true, most American's won't sit through a movie that is longer then two hours.


myLot reputation of 94/100. thezone (3927)   ranked 6 out of 217 in star wars  4 years ago

Thanks for for the different perspective on Jar Jar, I will think of him in a whole different light, when I watch the movies. You really know your stuff.

"May the force be with you"


rastagirl17 (43)   ranked 31 out of 217 in star wars  3 years ago

Good point on Jar Jar. I think that's what Lucas really wanted to achieve. However, Jar Jar DID annoy me a lot. I think it was because, in a shallow note, Jar Jar tried to serve as a comic relief but failed miserably. I think since Artoo and Threepio weren't together there yet Jar Jar kind of had to be a stand-in for that duo. But good point on Jar Jar nonetheless.


myLot reputation of 62/100. Anora_Eldorath (3661)   ranked 20 out of 217 in star wars  3 years ago

Zone-

I just noticed this lol, I'm sorry it took me 3 months to respond. May the force be with you as well. Yes, I definately take my Star Wars life very seriously. Ok, so I'm bit more like Qui Gong (though according to a recent survey I took on what Jedi I'd be, I scored Obi Wan-heh, maybe I'm an old hermitess and don't know it yet lol). Thanks for the response though.

Namaste-Anora


myLot reputation of 62/100. Anora_Eldorath (3661)   ranked 20 out of 217 in star wars  3 years ago

Rasta-

I'm still not sure I buy into the idea that he was only "comic relief". There was bits of humor throughout the film by various people, but I know when we get to third film, there is very little humor to be found and one of the most dark of all of them. I'm not sure I'd even say that R2D2 and C3PO are even comic relief, though they do get into quite a bit of trouble together lol. I think in Lucas's films, everything, and I mean every little detail has deep meaning and purposeful placement. Of course, that's just my humble opinion.

Namaste-Anora


myLot reputation of 94/100. thezone (3927)   ranked 6 out of 217 in star wars  3 years ago

Hi Anora,

Can you post the link for the Jedi survey, I'm a sucker for those things. Thanksthumbup


myLot reputation of 62/100. Anora_Eldorath (3661)   ranked 20 out of 217 in star wars  3 years ago

It's on Facebook under applications/quizzes. It's called Which Jedi Are You.

Namaste-Anora


myLot reputation of 99/100. Aliceinwebland (5358)  3 years ago

hiya Anora

I think that Jar Jar was so innocent too and that's what made him so loveable, thanx for sharing this.


myLot reputation of 94/100. thezone (3927)   ranked 6 out of 217 in star wars  3 years ago

Yes I would agree Anora, Sith was very dark in tone, just like Empire and I think that is why I enjoyed it so much.

I took the jedi quiz and my result was Yoda, I didn't think I had that in mehappy


myLot reputation of 62/100. Anora_Eldorath (3661)   ranked 20 out of 217 in star wars  3 years ago

Alice- I very much agree. Thanks for the response.

Zone-I knew you had it in you, Master. thumbupOh, and I don't know how I missed it, but thank you very much for the best response. I love anything that has to do with Star Wars, and I love when we can have conversations of such depth about it. It truly is an Epic, and there is so much to discuss.

Namaste-Anora and May the Force Be With You


myLot reputation of 94/100. thezone (3927)   ranked 6 out of 217 in star wars  3 years ago

No problem. It can be hard to keep up with older discussions. I myself almost forgot about this one myself.


rastagirl17 (43)   ranked 31 out of 217 in star wars  3 years ago

@ Anora

Of course you're right about the fact that every detail in the films has a holistic purpose. In fact Artoo and Threepio also served as a different point of view, a view of the story from minor characters in the film. I was just thinking that Artoo and Threepio were one of the funniest for me and I love them so much. However, I would really really love to like Jar Jar and I do acknowledge the explanation. It does make sense. He almost represents the galaxy before the empire. I just don't know what irks me about him. I'm sure it's really shallow. His voice? But I acknowledge your explanation nonetheless. It's actually relieving for me to know that Lucas didn't make a mistake on that one. Thanks!


myLot reputation of 62/100. Anora_Eldorath (3661)   ranked 20 out of 217 in star wars  3 years ago

His voice and speech patterns were actually modeled after a real language.

Star Trek Enterprise Complete Series On Dvd. Always Shipped Priority Mail.  www.EntireSeries.tv
 
4. rastagirl17 (43)   ranked 31 out of 217 in star wars   3 years ago

I actually have a list of the 6 movies according to my favorite in descending order. Empire Strikes Back, Return of the Jedi, Revenge of the Sith, A New Hope, Attack of the Clones, Phantom Menace. Notice that the bottom two are from the new trilogy. Yes, they were a bit disappointing... for me they lacked the depth seen in the originals. I put Phantom Menace as my least favorite because even though it was the pivotal movie of my 9-year-old life, it didn't really look much like the originals. Too bright indeed. Hmm... And maybe because Jar Jar had a major part in that movie. Haha. But all in all, I like all of them. This list is like just the ranking of the best of the best. Revenge of the Sith was awesome because it looks like the originals and emotionally, it completed the circle. These are very good movies.


myLot reputation of 94/100. thezone (3927)   ranked 6 out of 217 in star wars  3 years ago

I would agree with the order you have posted. The Empire Strikes back is one of the most darker films in the series and is a fan favorite. Out of all the films Empire is most memorable for the twist with Vader being Skywalker's Father. Sith was definitely my favorite of the newer films

Now: Marvel Comics -63% Incredible deals on Marvel Comics! Compare prices and save up to 63%.  www.Marvel-Comics.best-deal.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 99/100. Aliceinwebland (5358)   3 years ago

hiya zone
You were?! shocked I thought they were awesome and have them in my collection. I kept watching them over and over again when I first got them, but that could be something to do with Hayden Christensen.. phwooaarr! drool
lol I also thought 'revenge of the sith' was the best from those three. LOL Jar Jar was a bit nippy but tolerable. I just don't understand why they started away in the middle of the books to make the movies confused
Alice


myLot reputation of 94/100. thezone (3927)   ranked 6 out of 217 in star wars  3 years ago

Yes I still love all the films but my heart is still with the original trilogy. All the women love Hayden even if he can't really act but is good eye candy. Sith was my favorite too out of the new ones, it seemed just made for the fans and is almost perfect. I was a bit ticked off with Jar Jar but check Anoras' post and you will have a new found respect for him just as I do.

Lucas said the technology was not there at the time to film the story the way he wanted, such as the use of CGI, but at least they did get made.


myLot reputation of 99/100. Aliceinwebland (5358)  3 years ago

CGI? I'm a bit fik lol


myLot reputation of 94/100. thezone (3927)   ranked 6 out of 217 in star wars  3 years ago

CGI - Computer-generated imagery, that technology was not around when Lucas made the first three films.

Find Soft Spots Footwear Afford Your Favorite Designer Shoes w/ Masseys Credit Payment Options!  www.masseys.com
 
6. KElkins09 (30)   ranked 168 out of 217 in star wars   3 years ago

I actually loved all 6. Of course Episodes 4, 5, and 6 will always be a level above the prequels. However, my all time favorite out of the six is actually Revenge of the Sith. I don't know why. Maybe because I am female so it has a lot of things in the story that I like. It covers a lot of bases to cater to all audiences. It has the action, a love story, drama, etc. Not to mention Anakin is pretty freaking hot in this one haha.
But aside from that, the story in this Episode just thrills me the most. I get chills when Anakin takes his first breath as Darth Vader.
Return of the Jedi is right up there with this one though for me. I really love the ending and feel satisfied with it. I would love to see Episodes 7, 8, and 9 that Lucas wrote but it does not seem that will happen, so the ending to Episode 6 is as satisfying as possible. Star Wars is just all around awesome. What else needs to be said? haha


myLot reputation of 94/100. thezone (3927)   ranked 6 out of 217 in star wars  3 years ago

I would have to agree Sith was a favorite of mine, we caught it at a midnight show and it was time well spent. I would love to see more Star Wars flicks, if Lucas decides to make them. Love the Star Wars shirt, you are every Star Wars geek dreamthumbupw00t

Great Action Figure -57% Action Figure at bargain prices: Action Figure up to 57% cheaper!  www.Action-Figure.news72.com
 
sponsors
Now: Marvel Comics -63%
Incredible deals on Marvel Comics! Compare prices and save up to 63%.
www.Marvel-Comics.best-deal.com

Find Soft Spots Footwear
Afford Your Favorite Designer Shoes w/ Masseys Credit Payment Options!
www.masseys.com

Great Action Figure -57%
Action Figure at bargain prices: Action Figure up to 57% cheaper!
www.Action-Figure.news72.com

similar discussions
The end of the World of Warcraft
It has finnaly arrived! Star Wars the Old Republic, will be the most epic mmorpg of all time, it...
Mark Hamill is 60!
I didn't realize he was that old! We know her the best s Luke Skywalker from the original Star Wars...
Star Wars In 3d
I would love to see start wars in 3d all the series. plus in surround sound If i was George I would...
When Was The Last Time You Watched Any Of The Star Wars Films?
I am a big Star Wars fan, I know I grew up on the original Star Wars - Episodes IV, V and VI but I...
What are somof your most favorite movies that u love to watch over & over again?
For me there are quite a few of them. I have always been a big fan of classic movies. There are...
Can a blind person become a Jedi Knight? (Video included)
Hi everyone, As a blind person I am truly inspired so much by Star Wars. Talking computer, force...
Favorite sites to buy t-shirts
I really like pop culture and scifi t-shirts. My favorite sites to buy them online are teefury.com...
Anyone played "LEGO Batman" the video game?
I saw the previews and all and thought it'd be cool to play since it has all those characters in...
A starwars based game
I currently play a starwars based game. Its basically in beta test, and has been for many years,...
Favorite Star Wars Character
My kids are so excited because today Star Wars The Clone Wars is released in theaters. They have...
sponsors
Now: Marvel Comics -63%
Incredible deals on Marvel Comics! Compare prices and save up to 63%.
www.Marvel-Comics.best-deal.com
Find Soft Spots Footwear
Afford Your Favorite Designer Shoes w/ Masseys Credit Payment Options!
www.masseys.com
Great Action Figure -57%
Action Figure at bargain prices: Action Figure up to 57% cheaper!
www.Action-Figure.news72.com
Fan
Looking For Fan? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com
Super cheap Action Figure
Action Figure at Best-Price.com! Over 6.000 shops & 23 Mil products.
www.best-price.com/Action-Figure
The Unified Human Mind
Read the hit sci/fi serial at
www.stevengwilliams.com
Jar Jar
Find Jar Jar Online. Free Shipping $50 on 100,000 Items!
Target.com/FreeShipping
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.