sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

If you had to die in battle, but it could be at any time in history... email this discussion to a friend?

seacaucus4 (61)8 months ago


OK, so here's my thought experiment. Sorry if it's morbid (maybe not for everyone), but I think it raises some interesting issues.

If you had to die in battle, but you got to choose what period of history it would be in, what would you choose?

For instance, Roman legions were disciplined regimens of foot soldiers, wielding mostly spears and short swords. Death in battle during the Roman Empire meant looking your opponent in the eye, smelling his sweat, and feeling cutting metal.

In the later Middle Ages, cavalry was employed more, as were long-range archers. Still, though, the majority of the work was done by foot soldiers, many of whom (because of economic/social class) were essentially dispensable.

In the Civil War, getting hit by a bullet at all meant amputation of that limb. They did yet know about the causes of infection, but they knew that gangrene was fatal. Because of notched bullets, rifles replaced muskets in the Civil War, and you were able to shoot at an opponent from much longer ranges. Meanwhile, canon would be used to decimate reserve troops in the back, and to scatter formations.

Then there's World Wars I and II, and then superpower proxy wars such as Vietnam and Afghanistan, and now we're in the age of unmanned drones, GPS, and heat seeking missiles.

So, once again: you have to die in battle, but you get to choose the time period. What do you think?

 
 
thinking
sponsors
United Kingdom Passport Service in US
Urgent Experts Handling, On time solutions. Call us for instructions.
www.passportdocs.com

Local Concrete Services
Washington DC concrete contractors - forming, finishing, seals& more.
yellowpages.com

Insurance Captive Solutions
The Taft Companies, an Insurance Captive and consulting group, provides captive management in Bermuda, Washington DC, South Carolina and Montana.
www.taftcos.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  war, battle, death, thought experiment, questions and answers
 
1. myLot reputation of 98/100. savypat (7906)   ranked 239 out of 312 in thinking   8 months ago

Well I don't want to know so I'd take today's wars where you are driving along and then all of a sudden you aren't there anymore.

United Kingdom Passport Service in US Urgent Experts Handling, On time solutions. Call us for instructions. www.passportdocs.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 37/100. juanypablo (126)   8 months ago

Well I definitely wouldn't want to be in a war where I could be shot with one bullet and die... I like the idea of hand to hand combat and sword fights like in the middle ages. I think that would be a lot more epic way of dying and you would actually get to "fight" to the death.. and not shoot to the death.

Local Concrete Services Washington DC concrete contractors - forming, finishing, seals & more. yellowpages.com
 
3. tinapay01 (55)   8 months ago

I would want to die in battle like in the movie 300. Like, wow, I would love to die like King Leonidas did, killing tons of Xerxes' soldiers with only 299 comrades by my side! SO FREAKIN' AWESOME!

Insurance Captive Solutions The Taft Companies, an Insurance Captive and consulting group, provides captive management in Bermuda, Washington DC, South Carolina and Montana. www.taftcos.com
 
sponsors
Wedding Gown Cleaning Experts
Wedding Gown Cleaning and Preservation Experts.
www.gowns-remembered.com

Civil war Clothing for Entire family
Civil war clothing for ladies, men, children, and infants.
www.confederatefamilyfashions.com

Historic Appomattox VA
Where Our Nation Reunited! America's Civil War Crown Jewel
www.TourAppomattox.com

similar discussions
Have You PLay Wolfteam???
Its a awsome online game that million of persons play...Its about war;] HD ... Try it.....
Whether all the things are true or not in the documentary Fahrenheit 9/11?
Have you ever seen the documentary Fahenheit 9/11? I saw it just now, and that made me really...
What is the title of this story?
Need the original title of this love story. If anyone can recollect it, it was WW 1 I think. Its...
sponsors
Wedding Gown Cleaning Experts
Wedding Gown Cleaning and Preservation Experts.
www.gowns-remembered.com
Civil war Clothing for Entire family
Civil war clothing for ladies, men, children, and infants.
www.confederatefamilyfashions.com
Historic Appomattox VA
Where Our Nation Reunited! America's Civil War Crown Jewel
www.TourAppomattox.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.