sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

How do the cast of the films compare to the characters in your head? email this discussion to a friend?

L_aura_4 (6)5 months ago

As the title says, do you think the actors cast in the films were good choices? Do they portray the character as you imagined them? If not who would you have liked to see cast in that role?

For me, Alan Rickman is the perfect Severus Snape, I don't believe their is anyone better suited. But I'm not sure I liked David Thewis as Professor Lupin. I imagined that character to be a bit more gentle and quiet.

 
 
harry potter series
sponsors
America's Best
Find top-rated Opticians near you Try Citysearch® now
Washingtondc.Citysearch.com

See Young Frankenstein the Musical
Don't miss the new musical at the Opera House. Get tickets here.
Kennedy-Center.org

Macy's ® Wedding Registry
Create or Find a Registry @ Macy's. Rewards Program Save 5-10%!
MacysWeddingChannel.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  harry potter, characters, films, potter, harry potter film
 
1. myLot reputation of 70/100. jimmy87 (357)   ranked 494 out of 1,377 in harry potter series   5 months ago

Apart from the characters,I don't like the Harry Potter films since it seems to be a fast forward of the books.If one doesn't read the books,he/she would not be able to understand the film.
And for the characters,Lord Voldemort is perfectly good,and as one sees the film,character imagination comes automatically..


L_aura_4 (6)  5 months ago

I agree with you. I'm not a big fan of the films either for exactly that reason. I know they can't recreate every detail of the books but it sometimes seems like they haven't really tried to explain important points of the story.

America's Best Find top-rated Opticians near you Try Citysearch® now Washingtondc.Citysearch.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 79/100. jeeva_s6 (328)   5 months ago

One thing the potter movies boast of having achieved is the exact picturisation of the characters and most of the scenes and of course not all of them. I don think there could be any substitutes for the characters Hagrid, Snape, Dumbledore and more importantly the Weasely twins in the first three parts. I feel most of the characters are well chosen. I read in an interview that even Rowling is found to be satisfied with the cast in the film. One thing the directors failed to concentrate on is the story on the whole. I don think anyone who has not read the book will be able to understand the movies and I reckon everyone of them will leave the theatre with their minds full of doubts. Its not the directors to be blamed of as they do have the time constraints and they will have to show a four hundred page book in 150 minutes. I think they have done their best.

See Young Frankenstein the Musical Don't miss the new musical at the Opera House. Get tickets here. Kennedy-Center.org
 
3. myLot reputation of 96/100. masterviajero (504)   5 months ago

i totally agree with you.. alan rickman is perfect for the role of snape.. also prefer Richard Harris as Albus Dumbledore (Philosopher's Stone and Chamber of Secrets). and of course Maggie Smith as Minerva McGonagall (cant wait to watch her on the hogwarts battle in the next movie)

Macy's ® Wedding Registry Create or Find a Registry @ Macy's. Rewards Program Save 5-10%! MacysWeddingChannel.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 76/100. Weirdology (402)   5 months ago

Most of the characters fit what was going on in my head pretty good. Some are perfect. Like Luna, Hagrid, Voldemort. Snape too, kinda.

Although I think Alan Rickman makes a perfect Snape, and I would not want anyone else to fill that roll, I pictured him different when it comes to looks. I thought of him as skinnier and with sharper, more severe facial features. And with a goatee and longer hair. At least a little past the shoulders.

Also, Hermione is supposed to be ugly, not pretty. lol. I think they should have at least kept her hair bushy, like they did in the first film. She was supposed to go through a transformation for the yule ball, and then decides that she likes who she is and spending all that times on looks is pointless for her. But in the movie she looked exactly the same as she always does. They ruined it.

Washington VIN History at Carfax Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get CARFAX Vehicle History Reports. www.Carfax.com
 
5. nskhan1983 (47)   ranked 945 out of 1,377 in harry potter series   5 months ago

Yes. the choices were perfect. I love all the characters. They couldnt have chosen any better actors for the given roles. No matter how ill plotted the movies are, i Love them allllllllll

health testing Looking For health testing In Your Area. Call Now. TheQualityOfLifeGroup.Local.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 43/100. pyarebhai (163)   5 months ago

Harry Potter film, i feel, was very well written, but it is not possible to read all the Potter books written, Film is perfect, for those who do not offer to read it due to certain other immportant items to be attended for. what ever it may be it is perfect for the charectors,actors and other plots in the film. a person with open mind, willing to know at actually going on, in the Potter literature is safely see the picture and relates.

Used Honda Civic Si at Yahoo! Honda Certified Used Cars in Washington, DC. Shop for Used Cars. www.honda.com/yahoo
 
sponsors
Washington VIN History at Carfax
Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get CARFAX Vehicle History Reports.
www.Carfax.com

health testing
Looking For health testing In Your Area. Call Now.
TheQualityOfLifeGroup.Local.com

Used Honda Civic Si at Yahoo!
Honda Certified Used Cars in Washington, DC. Shop for Used Cars.
www.honda.com/yahoo

similar discussions
Why does people compare Twilight Saga to Harry Potter?
HI to all. I'm just curious why does some people compare this two? Any opinions there? I like both-...
comparing harry Potter series and Twilight
Which one do you like better 1. Harry potter Books or Twilight Saga Books? 2. Harry Potter Movies...
Did you like the 7th Harry Potter books' ending? (spoiler)
I'll try to blab to fill up this space so that no one who sees this discussion will witness a mega...
Harry Potter 7 and 8!
The DVD of Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince (6) came out recently, and it features the first...
Hermione
If you could say something to her, what would you say?
what sort of fanfiction do you read/write?
I love HP and Buffy. Spike is just too awesome to not write about. What do you write? What...
How many times have you read any or all the books of Harry Potter series??
I have re-read book6 before the release of book 7...and watched all the movies before watching...
sponsors
Washington VIN History at Carfax
Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get CARFAX Vehicle History Reports.
www.Carfax.com
health testing
Looking For health testing In Your Area. Call Now.
TheQualityOfLifeGroup.Local.com
Used Honda Civic Si at Yahoo!
Honda Certified Used Cars in Washington, DC. Shop for Used Cars.
www.honda.com/yahoo
Compare CD Rates
CDs, Savings, all US rates, Plus tips & articles from Bankrate.
www.bankrate.com/cds
Washington DC College
Looking For A College That Works With Your Schedule! Call Today.
ArgosyUniversity.Local.com
Audition in Washington, DC
Casting calls now in Washington, DC Free Auditions for Paid Jobs
ExploreTalent.com/DC-Auditions
Reagan Intl Park Sleep & Fly
Don't miss your flights - Washington airport parking & hotel packages.
www.ParkSleepFly.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.