sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

Lord of the Flies is a book about loosing the veneer of civilization. email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 82/100. debrakcarey (1351)   ranked 2 out of 7 in lord of the flies5 months ago

When I read it in eighth grade we discussed how quickly our teachings on right and wrong,our ethics..... slip away from us when we are not under the influences of authority and law.

A group of young English boys is shipwrecked without adult supervision. They quickly become savage and bloodthirsty little buggers.

What do you think...is it only the fear of punishment that keeps us from being savage and bloodthristy? Or is there something deeper within the human being that makes us civilized? What IS civilized, what does the word mean? Are we really just 'animals' that can talk? or were we made in the image of God, something higher than the animals?

 
 
lord of the flies
sponsors
Bank of America
Moving Ahead with BankAmericard Basic™ Visa® Card - Learn More.
www.BankofAmerica.com

Thinking About Getting Veneers?
Find a Dentist Near You Who Specializes in Veneers.
GetLocalDentist.com/Veneers

Free Patent Search Guide
Steps to Online US Patent Search. Do It Yourself Before Hiring Expert.
www.LitmanLaw.com

dawnald (10121) response was accepted on 9/27/2009.
denotes best response.
tags:  civilization, morals, ethics, dawn
 
1. myLot reputation of 99/100. SomeCowgirl (8288)   5 months ago

I think there are those with the capacity to be savage, but then there are those that even the toughest times, or situations, those who have or are going through things that could or should make them savage, have and can pull through without becoming savage themselves. I believe that we were all created in god's image, but that it takes believing in him and trusting in him, to steer away from paths that lead you into savagery.


myLot reputation of 82/100. debrakcarey (1351)   ranked 2 out of 7 in lord of the flies  5 months ago

I have come through a lot of things that would have made another person bitter and angry. Now, I do have a temper. But it is usually targeted at injustice and unfairness of the world and at others who are cruel or unjust.

I believe we can rise above those baser instincts within ourselves...it is a matter of choice. I see the bullys or the liars in life....and I see that they have chosen to be that way. To me, they are not civilized.

Bank of America Moving Ahead with BankAmericard Basic™ Visa® Card - Learn More. www.BankofAmerica.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 95/100. dawnald (10121)   5 months ago

And then I can think of at least two Science Fiction novels in which young people are dropped off and left to survive (or not) and most of them rose above the circumstances and came out much stronger (Tunnel in the Sky and Rite of Passage). But then Science Fiction tends to be a pretty optimistic genre, mostly.

Interesting though. I wonder how well any of us would do under those circumstances. I suspect our upbringing would have a lot to with whether we rose above our instincts or not.


myLot reputation of 82/100. debrakcarey (1351)   ranked 2 out of 7 in lord of the flies  5 months ago

I would like to read them. I have pondered why some seem to be born 'bad' and others rise above the worst possible circumstances. I love the psychological aspect of these types of novels. The human mind is so very complicated. I responded to another discussion on here that claimed animals were higher life forms than humans. I disagree. I love animals and believe that they can teach us much if we pay attention. But the human mind is so much more complicated and for that reason it is not easy to understand. Animals on the other hand...just do what is good for them, they have built in programs for survival. Man often does things that are contrary to his and his species survival.

I'll look for those books. I'm going shopping at amazon.com as soon as we get paid here on the lot...btw...when is payday?


myLot reputation of 95/100. dawnald (10121)  5 months ago

They're both juveniles (at least I was able to read them as a teenager), but they're both still two of my favorite reads after all these years.

I'd disagree with whoever said that about animals also.

I remember a discussion that my mom got involved in. She was talking about helping the poor, and saying that if the government didn't step in, people would never be able to improve their circumstances. Somebody pointed out to her that her family had been fairly poor and she'd managed to make something of herself. She replied that many people had no way to find a way out. So I have caught myself pondering the same thing. Why can one people rise above and others can't.

There was an advice column letter yesterday from a woman who had two sons and one of them was a total user and when she called him on it, he basically decided to withhold her grandchildren from her as punishment. Her other other son is a really good guy. Sometimes, even with the best of parenting, a person goes wrong. Or the opposite.

Some day maybe we'll figure it all out!


myLot reputation of 95/100. dawnald (10121)  5 months ago

PS we usually get paid on or around the 10th.


myLot reputation of 82/100. debrakcarey (1351)   ranked 2 out of 7 in lord of the flies  5 months ago

thumbupcool...thanks


myLot reputation of 82/100. debrakcarey (1351)   ranked 2 out of 7 in lord of the flies  5 months ago

I know what you mean about kids being raised by same parents and same values and one being a looser and the other being a responsible person. Believe me, I know.


myLot reputation of 95/100. dawnald (10121)  5 months ago

yeah, you do your best, but sometimes bad friends, bad whatever...


myLot reputation of 82/100. debrakcarey (1351)   ranked 2 out of 7 in lord of the flies  5 months ago

sad

It is what it is.

Thinking About Getting Veneers? Find a Dentist Near You Who Specializes in Veneers. GetLocalDentist.com/Veneers
 
sponsors
Motley Fool Free Report
New Tech Stocks Poised for Profit Motley Fool's Expert Picks.
www.Fool.com

Match.com® Official Site
Now You Can Meet Attractive Singles on Match.com. Register for free.
www.Match.com

thoracic aorta stenosis surgery
Read About Cook Medical Thoracic Aortic Dissection Repair….
www.CookMedical.com/TX2

similar discussions
who are we? generation of monkey or human?
let's friend have talk ours history. think about a while when there wasn't any fascility of life so...
Can human kind live without Internet??
i think humans will die without internet....what u think??
Which civilization you use the most..
hey friends, which civilization is the most favourite of you and why? what are the units which...
Have you played the new Colonization?
So, Civilization came out with a new version of another great game, Colonization. Unfortunately, I...
Do U think that the more civilization progresses, the less civilized we become?
I think that No, I think that we have always been uncivilized and barbaric and will remain so.
21st of DECEMBER ...... 2012 ...... END OF EARTH???????
Hi friends! According to Mayan civilization, The world is going to change on 21st of december. Do...
Is civilization only a pretence?
Don’t we all have those primal beastly interests inside us? How else could you explain this...
What is disease of Civilization??
What is disease of civilization? Why it is called so? What is the prevention of it?
Have anybody played Civilization 4?
Have anybody played this game? In my view, this game is not only a ordinary game but also an...
Can "Change" Save Western Civilization?
Mental Decay Has Already Occurred If you were to observe your aging mother attempt to boil water...
sponsors
Motley Fool Free Report
New Tech Stocks Poised for Profit Motley Fool's Expert Picks.
www.Fool.com
Match.com® Official Site
Now You Can Meet Attractive Singles on Match.com. Register for free.
www.Match.com
thoracic aorta stenosis surgery
Read About Cook Medical Thoracic Aortic Dissection Repair….
www.CookMedical.com/TX2
Curves Women's Gym
Need a 30 Minute Workout? Find a Curves Gym in your Area Today.
Curves.com
used r8 car lot
Research Used Audi R8 Cars Find Unbiased Car Buying Research.
www.Edmunds.com
Reagan Intl Airport Park And Fly Packages
Don't miss your flights - Washington airport parking & hotel packages.
www.ParkSleepFly.com
Get Ripped Without Roids
Build Serious Muscle Without Risking Your Health In 4 Weeks.
SixPackAbsGuide.com
Mother's Day Jewelry
Find elegant, unique Mother's Day jewelry in & near Washington DC.
yellowpages.com
veneer
Find Local Veneer Online. Search For Veneer Today!
Tazinga.com
Car Signal Processors
Buy equalizers, crossovers, and bass knobs at competitive prices.
www.hifisoundconnection.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.