sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Which is the best External hard disk?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 80/100. yashumgm (103)   ranked 589 out of 6,367 in computer 3 years ago

I want to buy an external hard disk drive. But apparently there is an option of with and without external power. What is the best brand to buy? Seagate? or Western Digital? Does anybody have experience of buying an external hard disk drive?

 

computer
sponsors
Back Up External Drives
Encrypted Backup. No Extra Hardware Needed. Start A Free Trial Today!
www.Carbonite.com

Local Electronic Stores
Find Local Electronics Stores& Get
yellowpages.com

Top Laptop Computers -57%
Laptop Computers at bargain prices: Compare offers and save up to 57%!
www.Laptop-Computers.news72.com

MistyWood (98) response was accepted on 8/29/2009.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  1tb, computers, expierence, externa drive, external hard disk drive
 
1. MistyWood (98)   3 years ago

I have 2 external hard drives and it really depends what you want it for....

If you want it for portability you are better off buying one that doesn't have an external power supply (mine is a western digital 250GB one)

If it is to back up your computer and is most likely to stay in one place then I would say one with an external power supply will be cheaper for the amount of storage that you get (mine is a verbatim 1.5TB one)

They both work fine and do exactly what I wanted them to do - it really comes down to a choice of cost and what you want it for...


myLot reputation of 80/100. yashumgm (103)   ranked 589 out of 6,367 in computer  3 years ago

Yes. I think I will do that. I do not know about Verbatim HDD. Will check it out as well. Here I see only Western digital, Seagate and Transcend.


MistyWood (98)  3 years ago

Currently if you want 1TB you are better off with one with an external power supply they seem to be more robust and if the data is that important... Well I am sure you can understand what I am saying?


MistyWood (98)  3 years ago

Thank you for the best response :o)

Back Up External Drives Encrypted Backup. No Extra Hardware Needed. Start A Free Trial Today!  www.Carbonite.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 87/100. riezen30 (589)   3 years ago

Go for a western Digital i do use WD for long years and does not give me any problem i do have a simple tech external drive which do uses a western digital. my computers are equip with western digital and have no experience of crash yet. I do recommend you for WD. Try passport WD


myLot reputation of 80/100. yashumgm (103)   ranked 589 out of 6,367 in computer  3 years ago

Thank you. I will think about Western digital as well. I need 1TB of disk space because of my experiments. Each experiment I do aroung 5 GB of data is generated. So have to buy one. :(


myLot reputation of 87/100. riezen30 (589)  3 years ago

What kind of experiment are those. That was too big 5 gig. You need a 1 TB for sure. Western will be the best.


myLot reputation of 80/100. yashumgm (103)   ranked 589 out of 6,367 in computer  3 years ago

these are like mass spectrometry experiments. the stupid machine just keeps puking data all day long. I cannot make sense of the data whether it is useful or not. so i thought ill store it. I was thinking of 1TB now I guess will go for a 1.5TB one. Thanks again.

Local Electronic Stores Find Local Electronics Stores & Get  yellowpages.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 88/100. harpreet89 (495)   ranked 512 out of 6,367 in computer   3 years ago

Well i would prefer going for Western Digital.Coz thats the company which still makes quality products.I'm using two hard disks of Western Digital ,one is more than 2 years old and other is 8 months. Both HD are running smoothly without any noise.
One of my friend has purchased a Seagate HD but that HD is now making noise even after a use of around 6 months.
Seagate seems to have dropped quality in competition with WD.
Here in India most people prefer Western Digital(WD) coz it comes with 5 years on-site warranty(which is a benefit--if any problem arise WD person will visit your place to collect the HD are take it and will bring new HD to your place) whereas seagete comes with 3 years regular warranty.
With onsite warranty you dont have to search for nearest WD service centre. Just call their toll-free no. and they will take the HD from you and get it repaired or replaced whichever is possible.

So go for Western Digital...

Top Laptop Computers -57% Laptop Computers at bargain prices: Compare offers and save up to 57%!  www.Laptop-Computers.news72.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 86/100. lovedude (2507)   ranked 9 out of 6,367 in computer   3 years ago

Both are the best.. My one friend is using Seagate from last one and half year but he doesn't have any problem with it and computer vendor recommends you for Western Digital. I don't have branded External Hard Disk. I use selfmade 160 GB Harddisk..

Robots Like Us You will too. 50-90% off local fun, new adventures & more. Try us!  www.Groupon.com/Sign-Up
 
5. davidrefer (3)   3 years ago

i have a portable seagate 500gb
it is great there is just one usb cord, that powers it and moves information.
its pretty sturdy too

ORIGIN PC Custom Built PC Started by former AW execs. Customize your desktop or laptop today.  OriginPC.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 71/100. tarundrebellian (163)   3 years ago

Well you are going to want one with USB,so that you can use it on all computers.I suggest buying 500GB because the price difference from 320GB to that isn't very large.Also,if you feel like spending a little money,you can get an external hard drive that doesn't require additional power,i.e. the only cord is the USB one.As far as brands go,I would buy Western digital or Seagate.
westerndigital.com

Ask Tech Support Now Tech Support Will Answer You Now! Ask a Question, Get an Answer ASAP.  Mac.JustAnswer.com
 
sponsors
Robots Like Us
You will too. 50-90% off local fun, new adventures& more. Try us!
www.Groupon.com/Sign-Up

ORIGIN PC Custom Built PC
Started by former AW execs. Customize your desktop or laptop today.
OriginPC.com

Ask Tech Support Now
Tech Support Will Answer You Now! Ask a Question, Get an Answer ASAP.
Mac.JustAnswer.com

sponsors
Robots Like Us
You will too. 50-90% off local fun, new adventures & more. Try us!
www.Groupon.com/Sign-Up
ORIGIN PC Custom Built PC
Started by former AW execs. Customize your desktop or laptop today.
OriginPC.com
Ask Tech Support Now
Tech Support Will Answer You Now! Ask a Question, Get an Answer ASAP.
Mac.JustAnswer.com
SONY VAIO ® Laptops Sale
Free Shipping & Custom Upgrades. 2nd gen Intel® Core™ i7 processor.
store.sony.com/VAIO
Watch TV On Your PC
Watch 3500+ Channels On Your PC. Unlimited Usage. No Monthly Fees!
www.StopPayingCableBills.com
Laptop Computers
We've Got Your Neighborhood Laptop Computers
Local.com
Desktop Deals
Solutions for Your Small Business Business Begins Here.
www.business.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.