sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

Which do you like more: American Idol or America's Got Talent? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 99/100. hotsummer (2746)   ranked 17 out of 38,338 in life1 month ago

I think that both are good talent search. but i feel that American idol is quite more taxing as the contestants has to go through lots of performances and survived lots of elimination before getting the chance to win the contest. but in Got Talent they have to compete with different people with different kind of talents and not just singing . and so this can be hard also . but i feel that those who have talent in singing have a better chance to win in Got Talent than other contestants who do some acts and other kind of talents beside singing.

but i think that i like Got Talent a bit more cause it ends faster and only after few weeks times the winner will be known. and i feel that the contestants in Got Talent get to relax more and rest more as i think that they get home after each contest unlike Idol where they have to stay throughout the whole duration of the contest in a hotel or any place that was given for them to stay.

 
 
life
sponsors
Bank of America ®
Read More About Recent Changes To Our Credit Card Fees& More.
www.BankofAmerica.com

GMC NFL Quiz
Enter For a Chance To Win a GMC Sierra. See Official Details Here.
www.promo.espn.go.com/GMCNFL

America's Got Talent Winner Terry Fator
You simply have to see it - America's Got Talent's Terry Fator live.
www.Mirage.com/terryfator

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  singing contest, america's got talent, american idol
 
1. myLot reputation of 78/100. eyeneed30Gs (766)   ranked 5,056 out of 38,338 in life   1 month ago

American Idol. It's more catchy and eye-popping. And, it's on the FOX network.


myLot reputation of 99/100. hotsummer (2746)   ranked 17 out of 38,338 in life  1 month ago

it seems FOX is your favorite tv network. i tend to like some show because i like the tv station. but of course the show itself is the big factor and not only because it is from tv station i got used to watching.

anyways, AI is shown also here in the philippines. we don't have the Philippine Idol yet again. it just aired early this year. it didn't seem a hit locally. anyways, we have already also the local version of Got Talent. Pinoy's Got Talent. i think that is the title. mind you, it is going to be shown on the same station where the Philipine Idol was shown. so this local station brought the rights of both shows.

Bank of America ® Read More About Recent Changes To Our Credit Card Fees & More. www.BankofAmerica.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 95/100. CatsandDogs (5132)   ranked 399 out of 38,338 in life   1 month ago

I can't say I like either one any better than the other because I like both. American Idol can be funny so I like that and America's Got Talent has a wide variety of things to see so I can't choose, I like them both.


myLot reputation of 99/100. hotsummer (2746)   ranked 17 out of 38,338 in life  1 month ago

yes Got Talent is more entertaining and they have not age limit. you can be as young or as old as long you can perform something. and the variety of talents don't keep me bored. but sometimes i really don't like the acts some contestants do. But in Idol, we know it has some age limit. so that's it. but i don't like the long show of Idol as we have to follow it for many weeks to see who will emerge as the winner.

GMC NFL Quiz Enter For a Chance To Win a GMC Sierra. See Official Details Here. www.promo.espn.go.com/GMCNFL
 
sponsors
Talent Development
Pharmaceutical marketing solutions from experienced professionals.
www.Klick.com

Candidate Management
Streamline HR talent management solution& integrated background screening.
abso.com

Castrol Contests& Promos
Enter Now For Your Chance to Win One of Many Fabulous Prizes.
Castrol.com

similar discussions
Do you have a videoke or signing system at home?
I don't sing like Mariah Carey but I won a singing contest. The machine gave me a score of 99. My...
sponsors
Talent Development
Pharmaceutical marketing solutions from experienced professionals.
www.Klick.com
Candidate Management
Streamline HR talent management solution & integrated background screening.
abso.com
Castrol Contests & Promos
Enter Now For Your Chance to Win One of Many Fabulous Prizes.
Castrol.com
Find Washington DC Hotels
Need a hotel? Search our local Washington DC listings today.
DC.YellowPages.com/Hotels
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.