I can't believe it
By Carolyn63
@Carolyn63 (1403)
United States
December 11, 2009 3:15pm CST
I have a cat 12+ years in age. She has had severe allergies her entire life. We had to keep her indoors because both times she was out she got a hematoma on her ear and had to have surgery. No, we couldn't find any bite marks, we haven't a clue what she got into. Well, for the last year she has not walked properly. Instead of walking on her front paws, she would use her forelegs. Suddenly she can't stand, walk, or even lay on her tummy. She is eating less than 2 tbsp. of food a day and less than half a cup of water to drink. She has no control over her bowels.
Silly me, I don't want her to die from starvation. This isn't a normal or healthy life for a cat to not be able to move. So I called the vet to see about euthanization. They informed me that as long as she is eating, they won't do it. I had to call another vet I know. He agreed with me. Can someone explain what the first vet I called is thinking.
I love my cat. I don't want to do this. But I don't want her to starve to death either. That would be cruel I think. Can you tell me how it would be fair or right to keep her alive under these conditions? I'm dumbfounded!
Thoughts.
4 responses
@minx267 (15526)
• Hartford, Connecticut
11 Dec 09
I have never hear of a vet doing that. The cat is clearly not thriving and she is older, has loss of her bowels... I don't understand why he wouldn't put her down it is clearly the right thing to do.
My vet would never do that. I mean I have had situations that I have had to put down an animal and they don't give you guidelines your animal must meet before they will. I had to put down my perfectly healthy 6 year old dog- they did it- they know how hard it was for me... I even had a cat that had been hit by a car (we guess) And
she had a dislocated tail, pelvic fracture (not bad -she still walked) and neurological damage. She could not control her urination or bowel movements due to the neurological damage. So We gave her prednisone, and antibiotics and I had to bring her to the vet every few days to express her bladder and bowels. He said if she didn't seem to get better in a few weeks I should think about putting her down.
Now she was eating great very friendly lovable and in no pain, she had no use of her tail. Well she got very sick (a bug passed to her by some of my kittens) a few days before The date we had arranged to put her down. After vomiting for a couple of days and not eating to great- I force fed her water so she didn't dehydrate. I called the vet and told them that she made it thru this sickness I wanted to give her another week.
They said ok. but I shouldn't prolong the inevitable- if she didn't regain bowel movement she was going to get sick and her quality of life would not be good.
Well the very day I was to bring her in I let her out of her cage and she went right into the bathroom to use the litterbox! I was so excited- all by herself I had to hold her tail out of the way.. :) when we got to the vet.. I told them and he checked her and said her bladder wasn't full either.. it looked like wshe was on the mend. Except that we would probably have to talk about amputating part of her tail since it just dragged behind her..
Long story short things kept coming up and it kept getting postponed. and no a year later that cat that would have been put to sleep if she didn't get sick 3 days before her "Expiration date" Is perfectly normal except for the last two inches of her tail.. She can now lift it and carry it over her back and everything. Everyone at the vet is calling her the miracle kitty. The cat They wanted me to put down.. So you never know...
But my vet fully leaves the decision up to me. If I were you I wouldn't use that vet anymore..
@Carolyn63 (1403)
• United States
11 Dec 09
I had never heard of it either. It totally threw me for a loop.
Pumpkin was a stray that showed up in our yard about 12 years ago. She had a kitten with her. At the time I had just gotten involved with a local animal rescue group. They helped me get her spayed and found a home for the kitten. They also helped me with the hematoma she had. We brought her indoors. Here came the allergies. One vet said she has ringworm. The doctored her and it didn't get any better. I went somewhere else after he said bring her in and we will cure her or kill her. (He and I had many fights over the years because of things he did and said. He was one of the vets the group used.) Another vet wanted to blame it on fleas. But I knew that she would have had allergies outside too if it had been fleas. I put her back outside. Overnight she developed another hematoma. We brought her back in. The allergies got worse.
Well, we finally figured out she was allergic to clay cat litter and to plastic. This cat went from having almost no hair to having a beautiful coat once again. At one time it was bad enough I cringed looking at her and was ready to have her put down. But like I said, I figured it out and had a beautiful healthy cat for years.
She didn't fall. She hasn't been bitten. All the other cats are fine. And yes, I will be looking for another vet. One that listens, is reasonable, and really cares.
I'm delighted about your miracle kitty.
@Carolyn63 (1403)
• United States
14 Dec 09
Actually, the poor cat almost lost an ear after the last procedure for a hematoma. The vet did some sort of button down procedure. When I picked her up her ear was this ghastly gray color. They told me to keep the tape and all on for another 2 weeks. If I had, she wouldn't have had an ear. I was so angry. I called and talked to one of the vets I really liked at the same clinic that did the procedure. He said no one else liked that procedure and was very apologetic. He said that the other man was a partner and they couldn't tell him not to do it that way. Her ear never was the same. That is why I stopped using that clinic. One never knew which vet was going to be in office.
@minx267 (15526)
• Hartford, Connecticut
11 Dec 09
Thank you.. And smart move- that vet sounds like a quack.. I have had cats with ear hemotomas I think they may have been caused by scratching do to a flea or something. But there ears just curled up and they looked a little different afterward. still same lovable kitties.. My dog got them too - on him I tried the surgery.. cost a pretty penny and didn't help he still kept shaking his head and would rip the sutures.
Good luck with the vet hunt- I'm sure you will find someone.
You know I work for an answering service -we have a few vets that we answer for.. But there is one that I always cringe when I have to call- SHE is a real B*tch on the phone. Cussing and carrying on because one of her people has an animal in need. OMG! I would never bring my animal to someone like that..I don't know why she is in business or how.. Do these people really keep going back to this mean lady? HOly cow!
I guess what I am trying to say is the weirdos are everywhere.

@savypat (20216)
• United States
11 Dec 09
Where do you live? If you were willing to pay I don't understand why they will not do this? If necessary tell them she stopped eating, what else can you do? Your cat is very ill, why would they want to keep her alive?
@Carolyn63 (1403)
• United States
11 Dec 09
I live in Alabama. Many of the old folks here still don't even carry animals to a vet for shots or anything. Most of them would put the animal down the old fashioned way. But just like anywhere, there are vets that are out to make a dime and vets that care. There is a place here that has several vets in one place and own two other clinics. The alternate between the clinics. They've gotten excessively more expensive than the other local clinics. Two of their technicians I can't even bare to look at because they don't listen because they know everything. The others there I like but goodness they are pricey. The first vet I called really does care about animals. They have a 3 legged kitty that lives on the premises. Someone dropped it and they did what was needed and kept the kitty. They have been great with one of my dogs. And I could see them hesitating if there was a chance the pet would be okay. But I'm not stupid. I know my cat and her habits. When healthy she would try to eat all the cat food. I have other cats. I teasingly called her bull dozer.
I don't like having to do this. If for 5 seconds I believed it were reversible, I wouldn't think of it.

@kaylachan (84740)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
12 Dec 09
Vwets don't like to put down animals. The only way they will do it is if they can justify doing so. And, as long as an animal can take in food, then vets often believe the animal can survive. Its part of old age for animals to show a decline in eating, and most vets recomend that you feed your cat less food, as more food leads to weight problems. Incontance is also not an issue as well as thease are common problems.
Look at it this way, if you were the vet, and you were asked to put down every animal that came in with simular or even less problems how would you feel?
I remember seeing my cats decline, go as far as to have strokes. But, we kept them alive because they still could eat, and they could still cuddle and enjoy life. When your cat stops eating completely then its telling you its ready to go. However, as long as your cat can eat, even if it is a little less and you haven't resorted to force feeding them, then that cat is asking for a chance to keep fighting.
@Carolyn63 (1403)
• United States
14 Dec 09
I am delighted vets don't like to put animals down! I don't like it either. That doesn't mean that sometimes it isn't in the best interest of the animal.
We once took in an older dog that had been rescued that had cancer. We didn't want him to spend the rest of his life in a small cage at the facility. He brought us great joy and love for many years. However, when the cancer began eating him from the inside out, and he lay there shivering, it was time. The vet, the rescue group, all of us knew from the start that the cancer would be back and worse. But for years he did wonderfully, playing and leaping, sometimes jumping out of the fence and scaring our uncle. He was loving and gentle. We miss him a great deal but we never regretted taking him. So when the sores appeared my husband hoped that the dog had been bitten by something. I knew better and I was right, sadly.
When a black and tan coonhound was rescued from the midst of the forest by a member of the rescue group and brought in I fought the vet. The dog was emaciated and his hip was broken in 3 places. The vet wanted to put him down. I told him I would take the dog and named him Handsome. Even when he said he might have to amputate the leg I still insisted. And that dog kept his leg. He got fat and sassy and he was able to jump and romp and play. When a family moved down from up north and had to leave their black and tan with family because they felt the age of the dog and extreme change wouldn't be good for him. I let them adopt Handsome. They had acres and acres of fenced in yard and kids for him to play with. He would have a family with children and room to run and play, more attention than I could offer, so yes, I did what was in his best interest.
When a cat came in and his nose was rotting from upper respiratory, I would go in 5 times a day and hold and feed that cat. He would only eat from my hand, not from his bowl. The vet gave me a hard time saying I wasn't helping the cat with all that attention. Jordan, I named him, did live and came home with me and lived many, many years.
The day when a man called about a kitten being tortured, his co workers had found the cat and strung it up, prodding it's rectum with a stick, I wanted to hurt those people. But the fact is someone did call and we did rescue the cat.
When a pregnant dog came in, I fought for it. The vet said the dog was "barely pregnant" and wanted to do an abortion. A friend and myself took the dog after much fighting. She took the dog home with her. That night, the dog, Angel, had 9 puppies!!!!
So, do you now understand? This wasn't me getting bored with an animal and not wanting to deal with it. I did try to force feed her. She gurgled and it ran back out of her mouth. When you touched her, she would eliminate. She was fine one day, and down the next.
May vets always hate having to euthanize an animal. May that it never be strictly about the money. But paying attention to the pet owner, that might just be a good idea.
@xJaiiDK (163)
• Philippines
12 Dec 09
I am a cat owner too. I am just saddened by your story. I hope the best for your cat. maybe let the nature do her thing upon deciding if she'll let your cat live or she'll let her rest. who knows, maybe your cat gets cured someday. Lets just hope for the best. I want to know more about your cat on what will happen next.
@Carolyn63 (1403)
• United States
14 Dec 09
Thank you for your support and concern. Sadly, she did stop eating and we did take her in to be euthanized. The vet strongly supported this and was gentle and compassionate. However, he knows us and he knows that when it comes to animals, children and the elderly, I won't abide ugliness. Pick on me, I can take it, but don't hurt them.




