sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Would you cut your belly ?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 34/100. silverjapan (159)   ranked 8,929 out of 32,950 in life 2 years ago

I always wondered about Japanese warriors, they chose honor instead of life, if they were defeated they committed suicide, if they insulted their lords, they committed suicide, if they ashamed someone or themselves they committed suicide, it's not even a joke it's real !
I was thinking how many people would have the courage and chose to stick a blade in their bellies and cut it open !
Now the ritual is something like this, you take a bath, dress up, they serve you your favorite meal, then you sit down and take your wakizashi, a smaller blade than katana, you wrap a cloth on the middle of the blade, witch is on top of a wooden board, then you take the sword and stick it in your belly deep, then make a cut from left to right, spin it and go up, then you bend your head and someone from behind decapitates you, in all this time you are supposed to bear your pain and not show it on your face.
Now imagine yourself being a samurai, you ashamed yourself, and now you're expected to commit sepuku (hara kiri), no one MAKES you, it's your choice, would YOU do it ?

 

life
sponsors
Samurai Movie DVD Store
Over 500 Samurai Movies on DVD with English Subtitles - FREE SHIPPING.
stores.vendio.com

Now: Katana up to -63%
Compare prices and save up to 63% on high quality Katana now!
www.Katana.best-deal.com

New: Katana up to -57%
Find top Katana at bargain prices: Compare offers and save up to 57%!
www.news72.com/Katana

theonlyone123 (422) response was accepted on 3/27/2010.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  suicide, bushido, katana, samurai, self sacrifice
 
1. myLot reputation of 90/100. tigerlily1972 (274)   ranked 1,260 out of 32,950 in life   2 years ago


is this still practiced nowadays? i thought maybe it is only in movies or magazines... i have seen old chinese movies doing the same too. The common people as well as the warriors. But i want to believe it is only for the show .. not real thing.

Samurai Movie DVD Store Over 500 Samurai Movies on DVD with English Subtitles - FREE SHIPPING.  stores.vendio.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 83/100. theonlyone123 (422)   ranked 6,144 out of 32,950 in life   2 years ago

I think it's part of their lives and the way they think then. Their way of life and views before this may not be relevant or "right" in our time, but for them, it's considered to be something that he had to do as honour is the most valuable asset for them and they will do anything to preserve that, even if it means committing a ritual suicide. So I think if we live at that time, maybe we'll do it too. Different era and culture have different ways of thinking. Just like during the early Christians who thinks the earth is the center of the world until someone proved them wrong. If I had live at that time, I'll tell you that it's indeed true...

Cheers.

Now: Katana up to -63% Compare prices and save up to 63% on high quality Katana now!  www.Katana.best-deal.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 90/100. Cutie18f (2465)   ranked 2,311 out of 32,950 in life   2 years ago

But that's too much. Killing one's self for having wronged or shamed someone is just too extreme. I will never do it. I will ask for forgiveness, kneel down, and kiss his a*s but kill myself, no.

New: Katana up to -57% Find top Katana at bargain prices: Compare offers and save up to 57%!  www.news72.com/Katana
 
4. myLot reputation of 89/100. rinzgca (239)   ranked 9,551 out of 32,950 in life   2 years ago

Yes, that is an interesting part of the culture of the Japanese. Not intending to demean this ancient ritual of samurais, but, I just realized something. Isn't it also cowardice when you end your life because of a wrong doing? It isn't really punishment, is it. It's just one way to get out of the wrong doing. An easy way out as they say. Wouldn't it be better if you bear the shame, and make up for it for your whole life? After all, a dead person isn't really valuable or beneficial to anyone. However, a live person can still do something for you.

To answer your question, if I was a Japanese during the time of the samurais, I probably will. Honor is very important to a Japanese. They are very loyal to their lords. Being a shame does not only affect how people would look at you but it would also affect how the people would look at your lord. Thus to end it all, you just end your life.

But if it were today and I am who I am, no I wouldn't. I will make amends. Even if I have to work for that person my whole life, I will.

Japanese Samurai DVDs Japanese Samurai and Kung Fu DVDs at Low Prices.  shaolindvd.com
 
sponsors
Japanese Samurai DVDs
Japanese Samurai and Kung Fu DVDs at Low Prices.
shaolindvd.com

Paintball -Free Shipping
Paintballs, guns, goggles. Shipped Free today if ordered by 3PM ET.
www.reddotpaintball.com

TargetĀ® Official Site
Find Great Deals at Target.com Free Shipping $50 on 100,000 Items!
www.Target.com

similar discussions
Suicide is crime.
The god has give beautiful life for us. There are some persons who are wasting their life by...
Suicide of 6 Family Members....
Hai friends... Today I wake up from bed by hearing a bad news...My near neighbour's family is...
One needs courage to...what???
A person suffering from a fetal disease cries inconsolably when he or she is informed of his or her...
A man cuts off his own head
A while ago I read in the news that a man cut off own head with chainsaw and it is understood...
sponsors
Japanese Samurai DVDs
Japanese Samurai and Kung Fu DVDs at Low Prices.
shaolindvd.com
Paintball -Free Shipping
Paintballs, guns, goggles. Shipped Free today if ordered by 3PM ET.
www.reddotpaintball.com
TargetĀ® Official Site
Find Great Deals at Target.com Free Shipping $50 on 100,000 Items!
www.Target.com
Shelly Kunker Therapy
MFT Intern specializing in trauma San Diego area
shellykunker.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.