sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Book or movie??  email this discussion to a friend?

passionyao (35) 2 years ago

I read the book "The Da Vinci Code" about three years ago. I think it is an excellent book. Its scenario attracted me a lot and I was even frightened by that. Several days ago I watched the movie shot according to this book,and I was a little disappointed by that movie. I think the movie didn't express the scenarios of the book very well. So what do you think about it? Movie or book,which do you like better?

 

reader
sponsors
Take A Vacation
Get away this year without breaking the bank. Save 50-90% on travel!
www.Groupon.com/Sign-Up

Man "Cheats" Credit Score
He Added 126 Points To His Credit Score Using This 1 Easy Tip.
www.SecretsOfYourCreditScore.com

Free Movies
The Best Movies Online
TrailerAddict.com

aprilmmm (61) response was accepted on 3/29/2010.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  book, awesome, choice, movie, movies
 
1. aprilmmm (61)   2 years ago

Hi,passionyao.I agree with you. Before I finish reading the book,I can't help watching the movie...I know that it is difficult to contain all the plot of the novel in several hours.But the rhythm of the movie isn't that tight as the book shows.Moreover,I can't understand the french accent of heroine...

Take A Vacation Get away this year without breaking the bank. Save 50-90% on travel!  www.Groupon.com/Sign-Up
 
2. myLot reputation of 89/100. missliss08 (462)   2 years ago

I read the book, and then saw the movie. I am opposite of you, I thought it went almost exact to the book. I loved them both!


passionyao (35)  2 years ago

Thanks for your reply. Different people have different ideas on the same thing and it's very normal. Maybe my expectation to this movie is too high and this makes me feel down when I found that it's not so fantastic.

Man "Cheats" Credit Score He Added 126 Points To His Credit Score Using This 1 Easy Tip.  www.SecretsOfYourCreditScore.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 92/100. vhinzstrife (582)   2 years ago

I would prefer movies though.. much entertaining for me and i think i can understand it better... books... honestly I'm lame when comes into books but we all know that most movies that came from books doesn't really meet our expectations..

read the book? movie came up = see them both
movie came up? haven't read the book = it's up to you (story wise).


passionyao (35)  2 years ago

I think your opinion is very interesting and also very sensible. We all have a different taste on movie or book. Some like movies while some enjoy reading books. Just do what we like~

Free Movies The Best Movies Online  TrailerAddict.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 78/100. 3honor (9768)   ranked 17 out of 553 in reader   2 years ago

A film will rarely replicate our imagination. So if you've been very deep in the book the film will tend to disappoint

Open .book Files (Best) Can't Open .book Files? Download this 100% Free .book Opener.Voted #1  OpenAnyFormat.com/Data/BOOK
 
5. myLot reputation of 60/100. 6precious102 (2531)   2 years ago

I read the book; but have not seen the movie, so I can't compare the two. However, it has been my experience that the book is almost always far better than the movie.

Local Movie Theaters Find Listings for Local Movie  yellowpages.com
 
6. Langstra (15)   2 years ago

Most of the time books are more detailed then movies, so in that case a book.
But a movie is just more realistic you can see it. It shows things a books can't descripe that well.


passionyao (35)  2 years ago

Well I agree with you. Books can describe scenarios much more detailed. And what's more reading books leave us more space for us to think. This is very important as imagination of human-beings is infinite. But a movie can also have great effect if the director can consider more and the actor can act more lively. This can also reflect the quality of the movie.

Local New Movies Find New Movies Near You. See Actual Customer Reviews!  Local.com
 
7. morriganesque (26)   2 years ago

Hi!
It's always the same for me: everytime I read a book first and see the movie after, I'm disappointed (the last Harry Potter movie was a nightmare for example)
it's often better to watch the movie first then read the book.
sometimes it's just because your imagination of the characters doesn't quite fit with what they've done to the movie and I can deal with that but there's a lot of cases where they (I mean the movie crew) just skipped parts of remade it to fit and I hate it!
I definitely like books better (Da Vinci Code included) but I still watch movies because it's faster and sometimes I'm too lazy so I just sit back and let the images move instead of turning the pages!

Publish for Real We have the expertise you need from editorial through publicity.  VantagePress.com/freeguide
 
8. myLot reputation of 73/100. fifileigh (3300)   ranked 43 out of 553 in reader   2 years ago

books are always better than the movie.
i recently bought The Da Vinci Code and Angels and Demons in a used book sale, but havent read them yet. are they both good?

Quick Movie Reviews Weekly Movie Reviews Current Films / Classics  lastonetoleavethetheatre.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 98/100. hunterkim_07 (374)   2 years ago

Even if the movie has 'exciting' offers, I still prefer its book counterpart. It's because the book is so detailed to every scene and event in the story. When it's translated into a movie, there are lots of detail missing already. I've also read and watched The Da Vinci Code and then Angels and Demons. I loved the books, not much their movies. I suggest that you read first then watch.

Buy Onward - Books & More Save up to 30% on over 1 Million Book, Movie & Music titles!  www.BuyOnward.com
 
sponsors
Open .book Files (Best)
Can't Open .book Files? Download this 100% Free .book Opener.Voted #1
OpenAnyFormat.com/Data/BOOK

Local Movie Theaters
Find Listings for Local Movie
yellowpages.com

Local New Movies
Find New Movies Near You. See Actual Customer Reviews!
Local.com

similar discussions
Topics in the Paranormal
I want to write a book that ties everything paranormal together. What do you think I should start...
ok im thinkin of writing a book.
i've been debating now for 3 days on if i want to write a book or not and if i do what should i...
The Time Required To Read A Book...
Something that holds true for me, anyway. How many pages a book has does not factor into the...
Finding the best book on any topic..
Hi Friends, How do you find (Search on Internet) a good book on any topic? E.g. I want to...
Ghost Writers for celebrities...
My question is, how can you tell if a celebrity has a ghost writer write their book or memoir for...
The problem with mystery/crime novels...
While I love them, over the years of reading probably thousands of mystery/crime/suspense novels,...
What should I read next?
I'm trying ot read 52 books this year, I do like to read anything but don't do horror,and such like...
do you like reading and which book/novel you like best?
reading is one of my significant ways to spend my spare time. i like to read english books,...
Write about what you know!!
They do say that there is a book inside each and everyone of us, its up to us wether we ever decide...
Books lifted me up!
After the 6.9 Earthquake in my hometown, I am being so paranoid that it will happen again and die...
sponsors
Open .book Files (Best)
Can't Open .book Files? Download this 100% Free .book Opener.Voted #1
OpenAnyFormat.com/Data/BOOK
Local Movie Theaters
Find Listings for Local Movie
yellowpages.com
Local New Movies
Find New Movies Near You. See Actual Customer Reviews!
Local.com
Publish for Real
We have the expertise you need from editorial through publicity.
VantagePress.com/freeguide
Quick Movie Reviews
Weekly Movie Reviews Current Films / Classics
lastonetoleavethetheatre.com
Buy Onward - Books & More
Save up to 30% on over 1 Million Book, Movie & Music titles!
www.BuyOnward.com
movies
Enter The AARP Movie Sweepstakes & You Could Win $1,800 In Prizes!
AARP.Promo.Eprize.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.