Talentadong Pinoy (TP) or Pilipinas got Talent(PGT)?
By eil_noz
@eil_noz (961)
Philippines
May 16, 2010 8:49am CST
Both reality shows searches for the talents of the Filipinos from Luzon, Visayas and Mindanao. Well, They're both good shows and really nice to watch I both watch them during weekends. PGT is of ABS and TP is of TV 5.
I enjoyed Talentadong Pinoy more than PGT because the contestants in that show was really outstanding considering that they're one year already and the 4 judges were really unbiased and experts in commenting. They were really humorous too and good observers while
PGT is like a copycat of talent shows abroad having three judges. Some of the contestants that joined for me, wasn't really as good as those from TP and the judges always agree to each other since Kris and Ai-Ai were friends and the guy judge wasn't that strict or I mean very considerate.
How bout you? which do you prefer? TP or PGT?
3 responses
@zedrick_11 (931)
• Philippines
21 May 10
hi eil_noz
i prefer PGT than TP because all talents in Talentadong Pinoy is the same, at first it was entertainting but now it's kind'a boring cause i've seen all those talents before and they're bringing back all Talentados that we've seen, unlike PGT they are all new and they can be in showbiz, there are exceptional singers, dancers, artist, actors, etc. so i do prefer PGT more than TP..
have a nice day.
1 person likes this
@babyEj (1522)
• Philippines
18 May 10
hmmm.... I like PGT not because I like ABS shows but because the talents here are really considerably for international showcase. Although you're right on one part that judges aren't that harsh to comment with the skills presented on stage on one side it's good. Harsh comments have nothing to bring out but pain. So why tell? Instead constructive criticism will do. This is not like American show, like Simon Cowell does on his show, he has to hurt somebody to bring out more the talent.
Shows in Entertainment Industry are almost a copycat . It is maybe the technology has running out of new spaces to make things new since everything is new. Yet, still you have to make a twist though things may appear almost the same. That is the face of tight competition these days.
@eil_noz (961)
• Philippines
18 May 10
Yes! I do agree with you. The truth is somehow I don't get excited when I watch PGT because of the judges. I like funny and wise comments but I don't see it there. THe talents were somehow good but I prefer the contestants in TP.
You haven't told me whether PGT or TP. I guess you haven't
watched TP in TV5 channel 28. I suggest you to watch it first then comment again. I'll forward to your next reply.
