sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Mother staged a fake arrest for her five year old son  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 88/100. manvik (421) 2 years ago


I am disappointed to read the news of a mother from Florida who staged a fake arrest for her five year old son just because he was playing with match sticks. She justifies her action to be right which would help to reduce crime. Local people are supporting the mother's action and some even said that this is the best way to teach children. What do you think? Is it a way to control your child?

 

mother
User has not selected a best response.
tags:  parenting
 
1. myLot reputation of 73/100. Jaluke (631)   2 years ago

While on the plus side it taught her children that it is bad to play with matches, this has seriously probably forever scarred her child and is a major event that will dictate his personality in the future. It was an over the top scare tactic that I personally believe was going too far. It probably traumatized the poor little boy.


myLot reputation of 88/100. manvik (421)  2 years ago

Thanks Jaluke for your valuable comment. Probably the boy learnt a lesson but such an extreme action is not recommended.

 
 
2. myLot reputation of 98/100. vjenkins86 (794)   2 years ago

I guess I can kind of understand how the mother feels. Especially if the child has continuously done this after her telling him to stop and disciplining him in other ways. I know from personal experiences that children can be extremely hard headed and downright disobedient brats. I just wish that it did not have to go to that extent. A mock arrest does seem a bit overdramatic and could be a waste of taxpayers' money, however because I don't know the kid and his mother, I cannot condemn her completely.


myLot reputation of 88/100. manvik (421)  2 years ago


Thanks vjenkins86 for your valuable extent. I think what the mother did is beyond expectation.

 
 
3. myLot reputation of 88/100. p3ks626 (4142)   ranked 259 out of 4,890 in mother   2 years ago

I think children can be taught especially if a child is around 3-5 years old because that's the age of their training when they will be able to remember a lot of things that will make them a better person. I dont think its right that the mother faked the arrest cause it would give the kid some sort of trauma that's not going to help him in the future. I think it would have been best if the mom just talked to that kid and explained to the kid why playing with matches was not good.


myLot reputation of 88/100. manvik (421)  2 years ago

Thanks p3ks626 for the comment. If parents teach children with love then I think we don't need to employ such extreme measures.

 
 
4. myLot reputation of 60/100. Rysonia (280)   ranked 2,206 out of 4,890 in mother   2 years ago

If this was the only way to get the message through to her child then she managed a very creative and innovative punishment. To many parents do not seem to care when their child is behaving in a manner that is harmful to themselves and others. At 5 years old I sincerely doubt the child could be traumatized by this, more that he had it made clear to him in a manner that he could not miss that playing with matches is wrong and has severe consequences. It was far better (in my opinion) for her to stage a fake arrest of her child then for the child to have injured himself or others through the use of the matches.

That being said, she seriously needs to learn how to hide the matches from her kid.

 
 
sponsors
Still looking 4 a nanny?
Tell us your needs and we will send the perfect nanny to your door.
www.themcnannyagency.comparenting

Parenting
FREE Report 5 Special Steps for calmer, happier families
www.spiritualityandparenting.com

Local Medical Help
Find Medical Businesses In Your Area With Local.com!
Local.com

similar discussions
its hard to control my 3 year old son..
lately,my son is been playing outside most of his day.sometimes I've got a headache to got him at...
Why does everyone want to parent our children????
I tell you, I consider myself a very good, responsible, loving parent/grandmother...Why do the...
No, I'm NOT being "fussy"!
Today at my parents' house. I admit I was already annoyed with my partner for being an idiot, but I...
I am exhausted!
Both Adam & Eli are still suffering from the RSV. For some reason they both think that they need to...
Do you think parents plays an important role in the study habits of students?
Today, its quite interesting to know that technologies are arising and is utilize by schools today...
Becoming a Parent
Why do people want to be parents? When I think of parenting, I immediately think of the first two...
Facebook parenting.
Parents!! What do you think about this? What are your thoughts? Did this man do the right...
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.