sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Air india Plane crashed because of pilot mistake or Airport has some problem  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 82/100. saurabh_rmp (447)   ranked 362 out of 1,169 in india 2 years ago

Do you think Air India Plane Crash has happedned because of Pilot mistake or airport has problem??? What you think guys.


Air India Plane crash
 

india
sponsors
Super cheap Air Plane
Over 6.000 shops& 23 Mil products! Best-Price.com - the shop expert.
www.Air-Plane.best-price.com

New: Air Plane up to -57%
Compare prices now and pay up to 57% less on high quality Air Plane!
www.Air-Plane.news72.com

TripMama®: Airlines
Compare Airlines With TripMama® For Cheap 2011 Fares. No Extra Fee!
www.TripMama.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  plane crash
 
1. jc92619 (89)   2 years ago

i feel india has to stop spending money on useless crap like IPL, they should putting good roads, infrastructure, police, etc. This is one of the reasons i hate to take pride to be an indian. i feel its 70% problem with the runway, and rest with the pilot,...the pilot and co-pilot seems to have good experience flying tht flight according to the media.


myLot reputation of 82/100. saurabh_rmp (447)   ranked 362 out of 1,169 in india  2 years ago

IPL is not from Government, it is via BCCI which is not a govt. body.
I don't think that there is a problem in runway. So, many flights are already landed on that runway. Even same pilot previously landed same flight on the same runway.
Waiting for Black box which records Pilot conversation.
Then picture will be clear.


jc92619 (89)  2 years ago

Ok IPL is not government, but there are many infrastucture items owned by private entrepreneurs, so its of no use they put money into IPL and bring no big income for the government, and what do people get even watching it? Man i feel they have to pay us to watch all those crap ads on tv, and billboards on the pitch. I feel soccer is far more better to watch for free. And i dont know for what use ISRO and crap have been setup, with that much cash they can easily spend for infrastructure development.

Although there are a lot of planes landed on that ugly runway, u got to check how big that runway is from a helicopter view. Have u seen it? i dont knw how they could assign that much small area for runway. its not sufficient for safe landing at all.
its not my viewpoint, that runway is accepted bad even by the air officials in India.
The pilot seems to have hit a tower kinda pole, and the pieces of the planes, i guess it som part of the wing, have been found on the runway. I never said its not at all problem of the pilot but rather u need som good skill to land particularly on that runway in India. And those two pilots although they have flown a lot of hours in tht same plane, and also that they had joined only last year, there is less report of how many times they have landed on the same runway. 1 or 2 times cannot be sufficient to learn especially that runway.


myLot reputation of 98/100. AjaySinghBaghel (2133)   ranked 942 out of 1,169 in india  2 years ago

There are many contries investing in different games but that does not mean you compromise on basic infrastructure for anything like airport. IPL is totally different, its not connected. IPL is giving money to goverment and not harming anyone. Goverment shoul dspend money in infrastructure instead of giving MPs & MLA exemptions of various things like paying Toll.
Why should these MPs & MLA be exempted. There is lot of money coming from Toll and if you calculate exemption it will be in millions and that does count.

Its not about IPL but spending money at the correct place and taking care of expenditure for these corrupt politicians.


myLot reputation of 95/100. anuraa32 (787)   ranked 95 out of 1,169 in india  2 years ago

We cant compare with other countries which spend on games, but spend equally on the infrastructure. The problem here is we don't do both. Why are we just harping on IPL. One thing it was more or less because of Modi that IPL earned so much of money. If anything, IPL only made profit for the government.

Secondly, the politicians are corrupt and therefore nothing much happens. And we Indians have no one but ourselves to blame. Why blame the government. Government is a picture of what we have become. A corrupt society. It is we who choose the government. No one wants to join politics. And when one honest person joins the political stream no one votes for him. So what are we blaming the government for here, blame ourselves.

Super cheap Air Plane Over 6.000 shops & 23 Mil products! Best-Price.com - the shop expert.  www.Air-Plane.best-price.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 64/100. nitin_hec (912)   ranked 256 out of 1,169 in india   2 years ago

Above poster is right. All money spend on IPL should be spend on infrastructure improvement. No doubt BCCI is not government body but they run a team with name India. India name can not used by private companies. Government should use huge taxes from BCCI. You will get angry when you heard that Punjab Government has purchased huge land to create a Cricket stadium. Land will be acquired from farmers. A country whose 75% population is below poverty line is dieing for food and stupid govt using farmer land to create a stadium of stupid game.

And about Air plane crash, Anyone can make mistake and in case of Airplane, Such mistakes cost huge number of life.


myLot reputation of 82/100. saurabh_rmp (447)   ranked 362 out of 1,169 in india  2 years ago

I Punjab govt. news is correct then I am gree with you Nitin. Govt. should spend money on people rather then any game.and that also taking land from farmers. It willimpact india onthe whole.

New: Air Plane up to -57% Compare prices now and pay up to 57% less on high quality Air Plane!  www.Air-Plane.news72.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 98/100. AjaySinghBaghel (2133)   ranked 942 out of 1,169 in india   2 years ago

As of now I cannot say confidently that who is the responsible for this crash but from different news sources it seems problem with the short runway and pilot tried to again fly when he found the runway short.
I am not sure how true is this story, if it is true than the runway is being used from so long and this incident could have happened earlier.

Many lost their lifes and families are still batteling for dead bodies, so whoever did mistake whether its airport authority or pilolet but utimately many families are suffering because of this.

TripMama® : Airlines Compare Airlines With TripMama® For Cheap 2011 Fares. No Extra Fee!  www.TripMama.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 95/100. anuraa32 (787)   ranked 95 out of 1,169 in india   2 years ago

The accident at the Mangalore airport was an accident waiting to happen. There are many reasons to it.

Firstly, no gap for error is kept on the runaway, therefore if the pilot overshoots his landing point even by a few centimetres, it could cause risk.

Secondly, when the airport was being repaired and renovated, it was an advice given to the authorities to keep the safety region of 300 metres. No one listened to the technicians and experts and the safety region was reduced to 90 metres.

Thirdly, there was a report given by a pilot (if I am not mistaken, or some technician) warning the government of an accident. An accident which he described then was same to same what happen to the Air India this week.

So I think basically it was a huge error and ignorance from the side of the airport authorities and those incharge of taking the concerned decisions. Yes pilot did overshoot the landing point. But come on, he is a human. Do they feel and expect that this man who drives this huge machine, will land on that exact spot every time.

Air Traffic Controller Search 1000s of jobs. Top employers. Local & national. Apply now.  www.JobsOnline.net
 
5. myLot reputation of 96/100. besthope44 (10850)   ranked 441 out of 1,169 in india   2 years ago

Well i think its problem with pathway length. And pilot has not aware of it rather


myLot reputation of 82/100. saurabh_rmp (447)   ranked 362 out of 1,169 in india  2 years ago

If you are a pilot of a plane, you have responsibity of so many people then how could you dont know about the runway length. you have so much of experience and you already landed 2-3 times to the same runway.

So, i cant believe you in this.

Find Jobs All job listings. Indeed.com one search. All jobs.  indeed.com/jobs
 
sponsors
Air Traffic Controller
Search 1000s of jobs. Top employers. Local& national. Apply now.
www.JobsOnline.net

Find Jobs
All job listings. Indeed.com one search. All jobs.
indeed.com/jobs

Mutual Fund
Invest In Money Market Mutual Funds. See Exclusive Online Offers Today.
firstcountybank.com

similar discussions
Can you remember what you were doing when the World Trade Center fell?
What was your first reaction, when u heard this news?
plane crash
A plane just crashed in Russia. Plane have had on board the Lokomotiv Yaroslavl ice hockey team,...
my friend died in a plane crash at the age of 23
it's so sad, my friend died at the age of 23 just this week in a plane crash. he is pilot and just...
A plane just crashed...
Two people were killed while four others were injured when a six-seater plane crashed into a...
plane crash
pilot who crashed while flying the Super Decathlon plane PK-NZP in Airport Husein Sastranegara...
plane crash really near to my house
well i in islamabad and had really bad morning today coz a plane got crashed near at my home which...
Plane carrying 152 crashes in Pakistan
A Passenger jet carrying 152 people crashed into the hills surrounding Pakistan's capital amid rain...
Plane Crash
has anyone ever been a part of a plane crash ?? not a major one obviously but a minor..or a very...
160 dead in Mangalore plane crash
160 dead in Mangalore plane crash come forward and show some sympathy for those who died...
3 Sisters lost their husband in plane crash, a co-incidence?
The wives of Capt Golikeri and Capt Shamsunder were sisters. Both were widowed in 1979 when an...
sponsors
Air Traffic Controller
Search 1000s of jobs. Top employers. Local & national. Apply now.
www.JobsOnline.net
Find Jobs
All job listings. Indeed.com one search. All jobs.
indeed.com/jobs
Mutual Fund
Invest In Money Market Mutual Funds. See Exclusive Online Offers Today.
firstcountybank.com
5 Growth Stocks for 2012
Discover Your Best Opportunities For Safe Portfolio Growth.
www.insideinvestingdaily.com
Mortgage Rates Hit 2.50%
If you owe under $729k you may qualify for 3.01% APR Govt Refi Plans.
www.SeeRefinanceRates.com
Mutual Funds
Learn about the Top Performing Mutual Funds, Today!
ssgaFunds.com/MutualFunds
Credit Cards For Everyone
Rebuild Credit Today With A Second Chance Credit Card!
CardWisdom.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.