American Idol..Katharine Mcphee or Taylor Hicks?  

well, katherinie is pretty and really could sing but america voted taylor hicks.

I like taylor all the way.I voted for him until my fingers hurt.I think Katharine is pretty with a nice voice but taylor just blows them all away.I just went to his concert this weekend and he really rocks on stage and Taylor looks good to me!

Taylor Hicks deserved to win over Katherine. He is a real entertainer.
I hope his CD sales do better.

well just like what ryan seacrest says whenever its elimination/judgement night...


america voted...

and taylor hicks won... i think he deserved to win for week in and week out he was entertaining and he is actually a good singer! big potential to be great... as for katherine mcphee she's good but there's nothing extraordinary about her... and yes she's pretty but so is the people in hollywood... taylot on the otherhand although just like kat mcphee he has a good voice but not great... his advantage was no one is like him out there... and that is his disadvantage also... but that what makes him interesting as a performer... and he has a lot of soul as well... =)